- [Agent Zapata tells the FBI agents about the Aldebaran antique shop]
- Tasha Zapata: Aldebaran is the brightest star in Taurus, as in the Taurus bull.
- Tasha Zapata: [Reade stares at her with an uncertain look] What? I like stars, and I was very unpopular in high school.
- [first lines]
- Patterson: [Agent Patterson continues to talk to the imaginary David about what puzzle he solved] 'Got one... Patterson.' Wait.
- David: Pretty clever, huh? Took me forever to work it in there.
- Patterson: You solved one of the tattoos! That's... Which one?
- David: Seriously?
- Patterson: Oh, right. Of course, you don't know because I'm imagining you.
- [Agent Patterson finds out that David left her a scavenger hunt for the tattoo he solved]
- Patterson: You organized a scavenger hunt. The crossword clues and...
- David: A piece from our favorite board game.
- Patterson: David, when you solved a tattoo, you should have called me immediately...
- David: And we would have had a two-second phone call instead of an adventure.
- Patterson: You were supposed to be here for all of this. It was gonna be...
- David: Super romantic.
- [Agent Zapata tells Asst. US Attorney Matthew Weitz she'll work with him]
- Tasha Zapata: Thought about what you said... about Mayfair. If Mayfair's going down, she goes down alone. I don't want my friends to be dragged down with her.
- Matthew Weitz: You got it, partner.
- Tasha Zapata: [Zapata walks off] I'm not your partner.
- [Kurt Weller makes a toast to his dad at the dinner table]
- Kurt Weller: I'd also like to say... to dad. I know there's been some distance between us. I'm glad that distance has gone away. I'm really happy we're all a family now.
- Bill Weller: [Mr. Weller reaches to hug Kurt] Come here, son. I love you, Kurt.
- [Agent Patterson tells the imaginary David that she's sorry]
- Patterson: [Patterson cries, sniffling] I'm so sorry. I - I don't know how I'm ever gonna forgive myself.
- David: You can't blame yourself.
- Patterson: But I do. If I hadn't have...
- David: It's not your fault. You loved me. I know that. And I loved you. You know that. That won't go away.
- [the imaginary David tells Agent Patterson that she will find someone one day]
- David: I know you think you're never gonna find someone like me again, and... well, you're right. It'll be impossible to find someone with my specific intellectual and sexual gifts. I know it seems impossible, but one day you're gonna be ready for somebody else. And he's gonna be incredible. Know who I've always liked? That Borden guy.
- Patterson: You've never even met him.
- David: Oh, you're right. It's almost like I'm a manifestation of your subconscious.