Rangoon (II) (2017) User Reviews

Could have been better

[kinshuk-gaur · 7/10 · 26 February 2017]

Vishal Bhardwaj when comes to film making has a vision that is illustrated in his earlier ventures. The music in his movies always stand apart this could also be seen, as a highlight in this undertaking.

Rangoon is set up in the pro-independence India. This movie is different from his earlier Shakespearean outings Haider, Omkara and Maqbool. The Cinematography is excellent. The music is as usual the high point of the movie.

Leading cast is excellent, with Saif again portraying frightening and is reminiscent of langda Tyagi from Omkara.

Shaid deserves an applaud not as superlative performance as in Haider but still top notch.

Kangna again shows why she is considered as a queen of Bollywood . She dances and manages action sequences with ease.

The movie keeps the viewers engrossed throughout. The patriotic song Jan Gan man infuses patriotism when played and beautifully composed by Vishal.

Than what is the issue with this flick? The problem lies in the script of this movie. The last 20 to 25 minutes of the movie struggles and make it tedious for the viewers.

The climax is elongated and gives an unscrupulous taste to the movie. Overall an highly ambitious project from Vishal but the climax could have been glossy and absorbing which has always been a forte of his earlier movies. Also, regulars in Bhardwaj's flicks the likes Irfan Khan and KK Menon are missed. Overall a good watch

Well tried Vishal Bhardwaj but need more focus on script.

[prafullasrivastav · 7/10 · 25 February 2017]

Vishal Bhardwaj directed again in Shakespearean style War and Love triangle saga to give tribute to Azad Hind Fauj like he directed Maqbool, Omkara and Haider Movie. Kangana Ranaut is the USP of this movie as there is just good performance from Saif Ali Khan and Shahid Kapoor. Good Music created by Vishal and Gulzar sahab. There was so many songs which break the pace of the drama. Only Bloody Hell, Ye Ishq Hain and Mere MIyan gaye England were good to listen. Script need to be better treatment as there was more Dance or Performances of Julia but Pankaj Kumar's Cinematography is also good ingredient.

As movie has collected 6 crores on day 1 so it seems 40-50 crores will be lifetime collection.

But, BLOODY HELL ... it, still, is a GREAT WATCH !!

[postsenthil · 7/10 · 27 October 2019]

Rangoon is set in 1943, when the British colonials in India were fighting the advancing Japanese and Netaji Bose's Azad Hind Army on the country's north east along the Myanmar border and a resurgent freedom struggle under Mahatma across the country. On this wide and raging canvas, Vishal Baradwaj crafts a love triangle involving a clutch of plucky characters. Rusi (Saif Ali Khan) a Parsi aristocrat and an erstwhile action hero whose career was cut short by an accident where he loses a hand and becomes a movie producer. Nawab Mallik (Shahid Kapoor) is jamadar in the British Indian army. And, then there is Miss Julia (Kangana Ranaut), a daredevil movie star who complements the incomplete lives of both these men.

Kangana is fabulous as the pioneering action star of her times and is able to ace a role which is physically as well as emotionally demanding. She owns this part and explores its innocence, action, romance, confusions, arrogance, vulnerability as well obsession with aplomb. Shahid is excellent as the sincere jamadar Nawab Mallik who is torn between his mission and his love for Miss Julia. Saif is a natural as a bruised aristocrat who is driven to desperation to salvage his life and love slipping away. Of the competent supporting cast, the notable performances are from Saharsh Shukla as Zulfi, Miss Julia's make-up man and confidante and Richard McCabe as the British General Harding with a taste for Urdu poetry.

After completing his spectacular trilogy of Shakespearean tragedies with Maqbool, Omkara and Haider, in Rangoon, Vishal Bharadwaj presents an ambitious period drama set against the second world war and packs in a potent mixture of love, action, jealousy, deceit and more through lush visuals of Pankaj Kumar.

Vishal Bhardwaj also excels as the music director as he delivers a background score that accentuates the moods of the movie even as continues his fruitful collaboration with Gulzar and the duo have come up with some wonderful songs.

Rangoon, thus, presents quite a heady cocktail of fine performances, several stand-out sequences such as the conversation between Kangana and a captured Japanese soldier, both glib in their own languages, trademark humour, some great dialogues, superb songs and captivating cinematography. Yet, one feels that there is something amiss which stops it short of being a masterpiece that it seeks to be. The romance does not exactly set the screen afire, the narrative fabric couldn't consistently weave together the multiple strands, the length could have been a tad trimmer or perhaps, the finale could have been much more nuanced.

Beautiful movie with disappointing ending

[asra-47867 · 7/10 · 25 February 2017]

The movie is good if you forgive the cliché ending. The performances of Kangana Ranaut and Saif Ali Khan is mind-blowing. Kangana Ranaut steals the show. Indeed, she is the 'Hero' of the movie. The cinematography is good. The film shows the INA version of anthem which is worth mentioning. Except for the climax, the movie is worth watching.

RANGOON ... Best Indian Real Movie

[polimera-33271 · 26 February 2017]

Mr. Vishaal Bhardwaaj''s RANGOON film is good that you really have to appreciate the Story, Direction, Acting, Music and songs. A Love triangle story backdrop of Second World War. Hero''s Saif Ali Khan & Shahid Kapoor and Heroien Kangana Ranaut Acting really good and has looked really pretty. Overall Very Good Indian Cinema. --- S V APPARAO POLIMERA (VISAKHAPATNAM)

Average

[indevgoyalbba · 5/10 · 16 May 2017]

Rangoon is the average movie can be seen if you have no alternate movie to watch. It will entertain you by cant be excite you. Cast of the movie is good so if you are a fan of one of them then you can go and buy the tickets otherwise i suggest you don't waste money and time on it go and do party with friends.

Masterpiece Actors, but not the movie!

[savya93 · 6/10 · 27 February 2017]

When you see such an ensemble, you ought to expect a lot from the movie. And when it's Vishal Bhardwaj's directorial, it seems to be a cherry on the cake. But here, the cake is not so delicious. After a slow first half, the movie progresses well in the second half but fails to impress. Bhardwaj's ambitious concoct of a love story against the backdrop of second world war seems loose. The story lacks crispness and does not look intense.

Coming to performances, Kangana is the hero of the movie. she effortlessly portrays her character of Julia, who is stuck between love and obligation. Her transition from a naive and beautiful girl to a strong and bold lady scintillates through her eyes. "Bloody hell".

Shahid is one fine actor who has been constantly diversifying his roles. And Vishal Bhardwaj always brings best out of him. He is terrific in this one too and let's his eyes do the talking.

Saif, with reminiscence of Langda Tyagi, gives one fine performance. His portrayal of an obsessive lover, who thinks that Julia is his to posses, brings a lot of conviction.

The last scene is way too dramatic, cinematography is good but unrealistic at times. Had the story been more crisp, it would have been a treat to watch these actors sharing the stage; but sadly it is not.

Weakest film of Vishal Bhardwaj till now. Completely disappointing

[ketgup83 · 1/10 · 25 February 2017]

There comes a time when as a audience you are eagerly waiting for a film with supremely talented actors, finest director and breath- taking visuals. Will Rangoon live up to its name ? Lets find out ..

Set in the Pre-Independence era during the British rule, "Rangoon" is a love triangle between Kangana Ranaut, Saif Ali Khan and Shahid Kapur. Kangana plays as actress, Jaanbaaz Julie, and looks absolutely gorgeous in her new avatar. While Saif plays the role of a director, Shahid gets his down dirty essaying a soldier in the film.

When you know that film is being directed by Vishal Bhardwaj, the curiosity will reach sky high as the marvelous director has given us "Makdee", "Omkara", "Haider", "Maqbool" and "The Blue Umbrella" to name a few. However, my joy turned out sour after watching "Rangoon" today. The movie does not give out the cinematic brilliance as showed by Bhardwaj in his previous films. The movie begins with a guerrilla war scene which has been well executed followed by introduction of each characters. The movie does not keeps you engaged and inclusion of unnecessary songs just adds further woes.The second half does not seem to take off and even the main story unfolding here does not help much. Climax is weakly depicted and has nothing to talk about.

Vishal Bhardwaj seems to have missed the bus this time as "Rangoon" falls flat on the face. Script is a mess with no clue about what is the actual story. Cinematography is amazing along with tuneful songs (though too many). Art direction is good but editing is bad. Performances wise, none of the actors were impressive. Kangana Ranaut went over board while Saif Ali Khan had nothing much to do. It was Shahid Kapur who showed some decent performance.

Overall, probably the most weakest film of Vishal Bhardwaj till now. Poor 1/5

Hamlet versus Hamlet

[reigh-01939 · 9/10 · 16 June 2017]

I watched Rangoon on Netflix. Since I knew my beloved Japanese actor Satoru Kawaguchi will appear this film, I had been eagerly waiting for this day. (Incidentally, it has not been screened in Japan yet!)

The synopsis of Rangoon is so epic. Love, War, Deceit... there are completely wrapped in beautiful screen images and music. From the beginning to the end, I felt my heart beating so fast. Especially, expressive Julia and stoic Nawab Malik... their appearance that two hearts melt in love is so emotional and heartwarming, but on the other hand I became saddened by the feeling of the tragedy.

Satoru as their prisoner Hiromichi, he played the role of bonding lovers, was surprisingly perfectly. He gives a heartfelt performance as a soldier who is never strong and wants to go back to his mother, and his honest acting and comic timing are surely the jewels in his crown.

By the way, before watching this film, I was worried about how the Japanese army would be drawn in this tale. Its canvas is the Burma campaign during World War II. Even though I knew that Shahid Kapoor would play a BIA soldier, I could not think that Japanese would be drawn a villain.

I was excited to the utmost in the fight scene between Nawab and Hiromichi. Both of them were not villains and desperately trying to live in the wartime. Although each of them masterpieces were Hamlet, both had surpassed themselves. Exactly, Hamlet versus Hamlet. I was so glad because my favorite film is Shahid's Haider and of course I adore Satoru deeply.

The scene where Hiromichi left there, was the most impressive. I have never seen a film which Japanese true colors accurately drawn as much as Rangoon. Kill or shame... he was suffering between honor and friendship. So sad, that was wartime. So I think Director Vishal Bhardwaj is awesome who can draw foreign souls.

Also I found a brilliant actor in this film. Kangana Ranaut... How attractive she is! Her innocent smile, eyes that talk too much, adorable action, dance... I'm sure that there is no same feelings on her face as one regardless of which frame in chosen. She is the best actress I have ever watched, and I guess Rangoon further amplified her charm.

However, there were parts which I did not like. In the same director's work Haider, I found reality in fiction. But in Rangoon, the climax where Julia goes to help her lover has lost reality. Of course I understand that Julia and her ex Rusi are excellent action star, but I wanted to see a scene where Julia and Nawab are joined together in the beautiful river. There are many entertainment films in the world, but I like socially which is the feature of sir Vishal.

Still I love this film. Rangoon, I have a soft spot for there. I learned English to watch this, and as a result, saw the landscape of India I had never seen before, heard beautiful music, knew the history of war. And I made friends of foreigners, my life became rich by talking with them. Thanks a lot of happiness, Team Rangoon, I will never forget your amazing work and two Hamlet's chemistry!

A love story with breaks

[kamalikaray · 7/10 · 27 February 2017]

Wish characters could write their own ends. Wish the actors playing them could rescue them from this helplessness. A fiery little 'banjaaran' is bought off a street performance by a visionary businessman. He then tames this 'wildness' into a feisty and fashionable Miss Julia. But for obvious reasons, he is unable to tame her heart, which is still lost in the wilderness it had come from. Rangoon the movie, promises from the very beginning, to be made to appreciate Kangana, the 'queen'. It is she, in a welcome change, who gets a royal 'introduction' into the story and she accepts it with aplomb. Because here is a performance which overshadows everything, the other performances, the confusing storyline, the gigantic sets, the excellent cinematography and of course, the soulful music. Because, when Miss Julia enters, you look at only her and when she exits, you wait, only for her. Cheers to both the male leads, a painfully restrained Shahid Kapoor and an equally, if not more controlled Saif Ali Khan, who gracefully accept the reign of the 'queen' over the entire film. The brilliant actors that they are, they have shown bravery in accepting itself, the roles of characters who are nothing but providers of plot points to a scattered story to which the heroine acts and reacts. So it is a welcome change indeed to see the heroine ride into the den of enemies and save her prince charming, the heroine to make the first move in her own love story and the heroine again to playfully defeat an exceptional soldier in swording. If only the climax too could keep the queen's flag flying high. Good songs, poetic visuals and excellent dialogues. We only wish the script had focused on one story in completion instead of getting scattered into so many snippets of different ideologies. Rangoon should be watched, for all these positives and of course, for the queen on screen, Kangana Ranaut.

Nothing new except the premise and look

[dineshprakash · 3/10 · 24 February 2017]

Score 3 / 10 Major problem of this film is Director's Mr. Vishal Bhardwaj's especial craving for dark comedy. It hampers two major emotions of this film that is love and thrill. Either it tenderness or wilderness, he could visualize black comedy in it. Screenplay is below average. Characterization is bad. This film is a old love triangle rather than action drama but screenplay writers are so creatively empty that when love has to be established, they come with only lip lock, that is so many. This is there take of love. This love track is typical, like a person is appointed to guard her, then some mishap and they are lost in jungle, some armed personal attack with comical angle like force to dance then rescue, hostage and finally rain and others lame incidents including sudden kissing. This shatters lead girl character because lip lock was forced. Only removing leech from her entire body by male was enough for her to fall for him when she was established madly in love with another man. That person ditches her to go alone to Burma makes his character grey too. British general speaks good Hindi, even rare Urdu words like Unvan, rehearse Gazhal singing but his pronunciations clearly reflect that he is faking of his Hindi or Urdu knowledge. Few dialogues are very good but rest are just OK. First half is wasted in the name of love track, second half should have been patriotic but mostly revolves around love triangle. There are lot of drama too but you feel nothing. Climax is so lengthy, boring and somehow childish. Especially the bridge sequence after blast. In interval, body guard belongs to same army but it seems that girl is going towards some rival army. It was just so it could look like interval. Performance wise everyone is average except the Major General Harding David played by Richard McCabe. His expressions are fantastic and very swift.

For Vishal n Shahid, with love n respect!

[maulin5 · 8/10 · 24 February 2017]

Vishal Bhardwaj is back after Haider(2014) with a love triangle set in the era of world war 2. He was saying in promotion that this is his first love story while most of his work before this was containing love story as a backdrop. I was amazed to here this. But after seeing the trailer, I made up my mind that this film is gonna be a Love Story. I was waiting for 24th February since November. You can not believe me but it's true that it was really hard for me to sleep last night. As I'm a huge Vishal Bhardwaj and Shahid Kapoor fan. The curiosity level was damn high. So I went to watch 9 am show.

Movie starts with a tiny but very well captured war sequence. Then moves towards the film industry situated in Bombay. Rustam is a film producer, as well as lover of his heroine Julia. He has been approached by British Officer to arrange a special show of Julia and her band for Indian soldiers working for Britishers. For the purpose of security of Miss Julia, Britishers have arranged Nawab Malik. Journey starts from Bombay to Rangoon in train, but because of a tragedy, Julia and Nawab Malik get closer to each other. Their love makes the way to end or not is the question. Other questions are also there (like some kind of suspense) which we will get to know in post interval part.

If I talk about story, then till interval I was enjoying a good stuff by Vishal. At the moment of interval, Alvida song was playing, and I was just into that. I just loved it! Post interval there are moments, but Julia and her train sequence was the best part. Ending could have been more justified or you can say more detailed. It was cleared but not so much effective. The visuals could have been better I guess. If this is your dream project, than you don't let it go anyway like this. I know i am revealing much, but, I felt it so.

Okay, now only positive talk! Direction and camera-work were as usual like we had seen in Haider. But the Kashmir and its snow were missing. Arunachal was good, but not my cup of tea. Dialogues were good. Shahid and Kangna's dialogues were lovey. Officer's dialogues were the biggest plus point, as they were witty as well as very well spoke. Some Ghalib's couplets from his mouth was a funny thing to see!

Saif Ali Khan delivers an easy performance. He is the perfect choice for Rustam. Kangna is good, but I don't like her in Dancing moves. Supporting cast is superb. All actors and supporters are fine enough. Ye Ishq Hai, Miyan Gaye England, Bloody Hell, Alvida- all are fantastic. Gulzar Saa'b's lyrics are too good. I like Jan Gan Man by Bhardwaj. It gave me goose bumps.

Kissing scenes are best! No one can imagine how to capture a kiss like Vishal has done. I think he is more romantic than serious deep inside his heart. I guess that's why he can compose such a romantic numbers with a great melody.

If you compare this film film with his last film Haider, than for me, it is not that good. Haider was the best film of that year. This is good film, can be there in nominees, but I doubt of its winning. It has many things missing. But for me, many positive vibes the film has been offering since beginning, the climax ruined all. I'm not opposing the script, but I don't like the visuals.

On the whole, Rangoon is a dream project of Vishal. So his fans out there, please go and watch it. Make this film his biggest hit at box office. He is one of the creative and intelligent directors of India. You have to give him what he deserves. This film belongs to him. And this film without its STAR could never been possible. Yes, Nawab Malik aka Shahid Kapoor is at his best. After Haider, Tommy Singh in Udta Punjab and now this film, he is on role! I hope this film gets him another award. He is going higher and higher. No one can give competition to him now as his cinema and his acting skills, both are extremely high. Kudos to Mr. Kapoor.

For Vishal Bhardwaj and Shahid Kapoor, with Love and Respect 8/10.

Another Example of Classy Film Making but There is something less in it at the End.

[SAMTHEBESTEST · 7/10 · 25 February 2017]

RANGOON REVIEW : From the beginning to the End it is a Complete Vishal Bhardwaj Film. You know what i mean if you have seen Highly Critical acclaimed films of Vishal Bhardwaj, he does not make films for entertainment or Commercial success, he makes films only for Quality Cinema Lovers. And Rangoon is another feather in his Cap. Starcast is Brilliant, and Top 3 Leading Actors have done a Brilliant Job. Saif is Rough and Royal, Kangana looks damn beautiful and presents another Outstanding performance for which i except some Nominations for her if not Awards, Shahid Kapoor is Excellent in his Role especially in 2nd half. Film is set in 40's so Locations are really very good and a suitable Cinematography makes it eye pleasing. Writing is Perhaps the best part of film as it is set in 40's and as shown in Trailer and film's poster it has all the engaging elements like Love, War and Deceit. Screenplay is Good, engaged, never makes you feel bore but still looks stretched due to less Comedy and entertainment factor. Editing could have been better but i'm confused which scenes deserves cuts because i never felt bored while watching film. Music is Surprisingly Good, reason is, there is Not a single Chartbuster or not even a Hit song in film and i felt bored when i watched video songs promos and listen mp3 but in a Film all songs are situational, meaningful so does gripped. Dialogues are Hilarious at some stages, meaningful and classy in some scenes. Approx 10%Dialogues are in English which only Highly Educated Saifians can understand, not for Masala Film lovers. Direction is Top Class, i mean if you notice carefully then almost every frame of film gives hints of Classy Film Making. Climax was Patriotic and suitable but Shahid and Kangana's death scenes looks animated and childish. A better climax would have made this film a Classic like previous films of Bhardwaj but Rangoon clearly fell short to that Tag. Overall it is a Very Good Film but i recommend this film to only and only Classes Audience. It is not a Massy film so masses should stay away from it, it is not a Family Entertainer so Family audience should not even think to watch it. If you loved Classics like Omkara and Haider then you will definitely like Rangoon but just don't expect a same kind of Quality cause Rangoon has its own Magic. I'm going with 7/10 stars, giving it a Verdict that It is a Film that keeps you hooked from the beginning till the End, looks like another Classic from Bhardwaj but slightly disappoints you in Climax.

Worst Movie Ever!!!

[pranav-35-595039 · 3/10 · 5 March 2017]

Set in the Second World War era, the movie is a complete disaster from the start. Its yet another love triangle cliché with not even one descent song or dialogue. Had much better hopes from Vishal Bhardwaj. The ending is as bad (if not worse) and vague as the rest of the movie. The only descent part of the movie was Shahid Kapoor's acting which definitely wasn't enough to keep the audience from leaving the theaters half way through the movie.

Simply Awesome

[harafat · 6 July 2017]

A great movie by Vishal Bhardwaj again. Seem to be a bit slow in the end but boils down later on. The story is spell bounding. Acting is awesome by all actors. Kudos to Vishal Bhardwaj. Simply awesome ! This movie will entertains you to the hilt and touches you in a manner that isn't as simple to decipher and understand as it seems to be. And why it should be? After all, it's a Vishal Bharadwaj movie.

A love triangle with a side missing in this Vishal Bhardwaj film.

[oazam · 6/10 · 24 February 2017]

From Omkara until Haider, I've always admired Vishal Bhardwaj's work based on his writing, direction, acting, and music. I was pretty eager for this film based on the good trailer despite the negativity it received on Youtube but the songs on the other hand made me skeptical about it. But after watching this, I felt that that something went wrong in terms of storytelling and visuals in some way.

So this movie focuses on an actress named Julia who dates a Parsi filmmaker and millionaire Rustom Billimoria who is already married but tries to hide this relationship from his wife. But due to some circumstances, Julia falls in love with an Indian soldier named Nawab Malik who is currently fighting at the Burmese Border along with the British and Japanese army. The love triangle between the actress, soldier, and the filmmaker is basically what this movie is about.

Quite frankly, this film is a bore to many extents. The way the movie started was good and unapologetic making me realize that this film is going somewhere but post interval becomes too far-fest and uneven creepiness starts to crawl in especially with a generic ending which didn't do any justice to the movie.

War genre-based films follow a certain pattern by its set design, costumes, weaponry,and VFX. The film managed to tackle some of these elements but the VFX wasn't crisp enough. Vishal's previous film Haider had all these elements. I believe he should continue making Shakespeare play based films because of the amount of success he retained from these films.

The music was below average especially taking 75% of the film for these songs. What I mean generally is that there were more than 10 songs in that movie and that is how it took so much time of the movie. The lyrics were written like some 5 year old was singing a lullaby. Even with VB composing, he also lost the touch in music.

Despite the criticism, there are some saving grace moments in this film.

The acting was amazing. Shahid Kapoor gives a flawless performance and he started really well in this film. Just stay away from R.Rajkumar and Shandaar's zone please. Even surprisingly, Saif Ali Khan was also good in his part. Kanagana Ranaut's mentality from Queen raised her performance in this movie a notch from the top. But the British Dude was so irritating in this film especially the way he spoke Hindi.

The cinematography and direction was nice especially the way the film was shot. Every frame was executed beautifully and the war scenes were also shot good but like I said, the VFX and editing needed more work.

Overall, this movie is undoubtedly one of the most disappointing films of 2017 and yeah based on the good performances, I would rate it a one-time watch but in my opinion, this VB film is worth watching on a T.V broadcast or on a Netflix.

Vishal Bhardwaj, I would bid this masterpiece for a dollar but not more than that.

2/5

A stupid film with absolutely no-sense

[royronit-51350 · 3/10 · 23 February 2017]

Nothing sizzles in this movie except the performances............not recommended at all!!! Performances-6/10 Direction-2/10 Music-2/10 Story-1/10 Visual Appearance-3/10........One of the worst films of this years pls don't waste ur precious time in watching this stupid wahiyat film.....there r even some part where Kangana overreacts just too much!!! And Saif Ali Khan's looks r very awful he is looking like a prehistoric ape!

A sell out for the lover of alternate History

[abhiakssingh · 7/10 · 26 February 2017]

Well, I am a Software engineer, who runs his kitchen, quite handsomely, by selling Science, Maths and at times, Powerpoint presentations. And I am doing it for years; a decade to be precise. While being so indulged in science & process, I do know that there is another side of the brain which functions for art, and it isn't the same. A discussion on history does bring a breath of fresh air for me. It breaks the monotony of science in my life. This film just did it precisely. I don't hold the Ph.D. degree in Arts or Pre - independence history, but every time that INA anthem played in the movie, I had goosebumps. And for that, this movie was worth it. I am not sure, how accurate it was in depicting the era of 1940's - it is something for historians to dissect - but I will have to say, I did understand what its maker wanted to convey. It does talks about an era when a lame Indian, not an indulgent one, had two choices to make, to choose the path of non-violent Gandhi or the military of Bose. We know that eventually Gandhi won and we got a partitioned India. But hypothetically, let's just assume, as it paints in the film, the victory of Bose's INA - hadn't we got a different India than what we have today. It is quite a seducing thought for one weekend. I believe the maker deliberately wanted to leave his audience with this thought. And I will have to say; the maker has been quite successful in that. At least in my case. Once the movie got over, I did check on the internet on the history of that era. So in the end, yes, I did like the movie.

As far as rating is concerned. I will hate to do that. I am a science student, not of art. I would hate to hear an explanation of quantum mechanics from an art student. And so, I assume would an art student protest my rating to the painting of Mona Lisa by Leonardo Da Vinci. I already stated the side of the brain which works for art doesn't work for science. So please do not take my rating seriously. I will just say, it isn't Casablanca nor it is La La Land, but for someone with Indian origin, it does have a connect.

Thanks Abhijeet Singh Author of Money Man, 21st century Super hero

Flaccid direction and feeble script

[shwetsinha · 5/10 · 26 February 2017]

The movie revolves all around the love-triangle amongst Rusi, Miss Julia and Jamaadaar (Nawab Malik). Its like the title of the film is just used to make the plot sound heavy but actually the plot is found weak, which would've been much better if more of the unsung history of Rangoon was portrayed in the film. Full marks to Kangana for doing justice to the key role she plays in the movie, but one less for saying 'Bloody Hell' so many times, and a bonus for looking nevermore sexy on screen while playing the glamorous actress Miss Julia. Both of Shahid's and Saif's role are written to be auxiliary, therefore, they don't get a chance to be impressive. Overall, Rangoon fails to live up to the expectations that Vishal Bharadwaj - Shahid duo has set for us.

A Great 'Vishaal Bhardwaaj' film with a disappointing 'David Dhawan' film ending

[sohailwaheed · 8/10 · 24 February 2017]

If I am going to watch a 'first day first show' of Rangoon, there is no need to say that I am a big Vishaal Bhardwaj fan. I started waiting for the release date since I came to know that 'Rangoon' was being directed by Mr. Bhardwaj. From very first scene to 5 minutes before the end, film is so good that you really have to appreciate the story, direction, music, acting and all. But if you talk about climax, it is so disappointing that you can't believe it is the same film. I mean, how would you feel if after having a perfect cup of Coffee in the evening, you are suddenly forced to taste the 'plum sauce'? Or, while watching a whole 'Bhardwaj' movie, you are forced to watch the climax of a typical 'David Dhawan' or 'Anees Bazmee' film? It doesn't mean that I don't like the movies of these two film directors, or I don't like 'plum sauce' at all. But is there any combination? I mean, seriously? Besides the disappointing ending, overall it is one of the best Vishaal Bhardwaj movies. It makes you feel as good as watching 'Omkara', 'Ishqiya' or 'Haider'. Cast is good. Saif Ali Khan and Shahid Kapoor are great in their roles. Kangana is the pure 'soul' of the film. She has acted really good and has looked really pretty in the film. Music is fine. Dance performances, war scenes are also great. But, if you don't want to feel as bad as I am, it is recommended to leave the hall 5 minutes prior to the ending.

Interesting

[professionalid · 7/10 · 16 May 2017]

You can find some interesting scenes in movie Rangoon. Shahid and Kangana Ranaut played their role very clearly. One of the good factor is about the movie is the star cast of the movie. Movie has really a big start cast. Nawab sahib - Saif Ali Khan has a big fan following so no doubt movie will income good. And this movie could make interest in its story you cant leave theater without completion of this.

A Glorious Mess!

[namashi_1 · 5/10 · 24 February 2017]

Vishal Bhardwaj is a Filmmaker to reckon with. His filmography has grandeur & soul. With his last outing being the stirringly beautiful Haider, expectations from 'Rangoon' are gargantuan. So, does Bhardwaj deliver another winner in his luscious repertoire? The Answer, sadly, is a No!

'Rangoon' is A Glorious Mess. Its primarily a love-story, but because its set during the Second World War, it adds an array of over-stuffed sub-plots & caricatures serving as villains. Bhardwaj has directed the film well & the Cinematography by Pankaj Kumar is stunning. Even the solid cast put up their best efforts, but 'Rangoon' stands on a faulty script. And no technical or acting triumph, can overcome a weak story!

'Rangoon' Synopsis: Set during World War 2, A feisty actress known as Miss Julia (Kangana Ranaut) falls in love with a Indian solider Jamadar Nawab Malik (Shahid Kapoor). But trouble arises when Julia's authoritative lover & boss Rustom "Rusi" Billimoria (Saif Ali Khan) learns of their affair in the midst of warfare.

'Rangoon' is a regular love-story about a woman having another man in her life. Bhardwaj takes a familiar route & builds the love-story, although the love-story, is very ordinary. There's nothing special or new about it. The sub-plot, involving a grey shaded Saif & the British Army, led by a hammy Richard McCabe, is half-baked. The problem with 'Rangoon' is that, it doesn't know which path it wants to lead too. If its a love-story, then why is it sidelined in parts? And if its a story on World War, why is there such minimal action? Also, the twists & turns are predictable here. The narrative has a few interesting moments, especially in the first-hour, but that's about it!

What Bhardwaj does succeed in, though, is the marvelous visuals. 'Rangoon' is like watching a painting coming to life. With Pankaj Kumar's masterful work with the camera, Bhardwaj explores the stunning locations of Arunachal Pradesh & all of the rest, with zeal. Not a single frame lacks in any manner. Even the Art & Costume Design, as well as the Background Score, is excellent. 'Rangoon' is remarkable achievement technically & there are no two ways about that!

But alas, 'Rangoon' falters in its Writing level. Bhardwaj, Matthew Robbins & Sabrina Dhawan's Screenplay is disappointing. Stunk in two stories, the film eventually serves very less for both. While the first-hour still holds some appeal, the second-hour keeps getting messier as it progresses. Even the culmination, is strictly okay. The Writing is the culprit here!

Performance-Wise: Kangana is a complete scene-stealer. Her part, supposedly based on the life and times of the late/great Mary Ann Evans aka Fearless Nadia, is bought to life with precision. Kangana blends romance, heartache & humor in a performance that completely arrests you. Shahid is earnest, but if one has to compare it with His & Bhardwaj's Kaminey or Haider earlier, it barely stands out. Saif, who has teamed up with Bhardwaj after a decade, the last being the Magnificent Omkara, gets limited screen-time & an underwritten role to perform on. He's fair, but considering his terrific talent, he's wasted. Of the supporting cast, Saharsh Shukla, as Kangana's make-up man, is fantastic.

On the whole, 'Rangoon' is a letdown, despite a few merits.

Love story set in the time of world war II.

[ppriyanshuu-17 · 10/10 · 24 February 2017]

World War II has never topped the long list of stories that the writers and directors in Bollywood have covered. Rangoon, for a change, and a good one at that, is set in the time of the war. For the first time, we get a glimpse of India during the world war II.

How India survived and dealt with the war while fighting for its own independence tooth and nail? You get an idea about it through the movie.

It's not only about the soldiers fighting in the uniform, it's also about soldiers fighting without ever donning a uniform. How Azad Hind Fauz, gave a tough time to the Britishers during the time is beautifully depicted in the movie and yet, it is not the typical movie about the wars and battles. It's a Love Story.

This Vishal Bharadwaj movie pleases you, entertains you, and touches you in a manner that isn't as simple to decipher and understand as it seems to be. And why it should be? After all, it's a Vishal Bharadwaj movie.

The movie flows like poetry. Music is very different from the typical Arijit Singh music that we have, in the last couple of years, become so used to listening. Intense performances from all the three leads; no one less than the other, each challenging the other while at the same time, complementing the other. 10 on 10. Go watch. Period.

Average

[qasimrazi · 6/10 · 5 April 2021]

Movie was OK but ending could be better.

Is it just me or someone else also noticed that the background music of rangoon sometime feels like of hollywood thriller "Shutter Island"

Way below the standards set by Vishal Bhardwaj!!!!

[Rawal_Afzal · 3/10 · 2 March 2017]

The film seemed to give the impression of the ingredients to success, and an Indian film about World War Two itself sounds so unique and unheard of that one ends up pinning high hopes on it, but the plot and the story-line falls well below the capable mind and the intelligence of Vishal. The performances were pretty good, no two ways about it, especially of Shahid who looked so handsome and appealing as soldier with that mustache and the physique, and Saif was good (nothing extraordinary as Shahid since he got a very limited role) in his kind of territory of roles, Kangana... Well, she wasn't bad but I'm in general not a huge fan of her acting skills, in particular that shaky voice. But again, the plot fails the film.

Although I've my reservations about the subcontinent's soldiers that fought for either sides in that war, but I can understand the admiration and the sense of patriotism attached with those who allied with Germany and Japan back then. This however seemed like a film that Vishal made on kind of force. He's not that kind of a man, his films never revolve around the emotions of nationalism. It seems so coincidental that director Kabir Khan makes a film ('Bajrangi Bhaijaan' 2015) which shows Pakistan in good light, then proceeds to go all patriotic and anti-Pakistan in a film like 'Phantom' (2015), and Vishal makes a film ('Haider' 2014) in which he takes a critical look in the happenings with the people of Kashmir, and then goes all patriotic in a film like this. Strange really!

It can happen, we all can have a bad day at the office, but here's hoping that Vishal gets back to his usual best and continues to make the tragedies I so love with passion.

Either way, Vishal deserves a tremendous amount of credit for unearthing the actor within Shahid. This man on his own has given Shahid a direction, a type of roles that he now knows that he can pull off. It's down to Vishal that Shahid's performances are now valued in the eyes of the public. Prior to that, Shahid was at best a poor's man Shah Rukh Khan - or at least trying to be!