"Shetland" Episode #3.6 (TV Episode 2016) Poster

(TV Series)

(2016)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A fine six-part story
Tweekums5 March 2016
Warning: Spoilers
These comments refer to the entire six-part story not just his episode.

Shortly after the arrival of the NorthLink ferry from Aberdeen a woman comes to the police station to report than the young man she was travelling with has disappeared; she states that she saw him arguing with a man before the boat docked. The man is questioned but denies all knowledge of the crime; there is something suspicious about him though. Soon the young man's body is found but before Perez and his team can investigate they are told to stay away from the case by the drug squad on the mainland. Inevitably they don't entirely stop investigating and start moving in on their prime… only for him to be shot and killed. It then becomes apparent that he was in the witness protection programme and was intending to give evidence against a major player in the Glasgow criminal world. Perez and Tosh fly to Glasgow and get into very murky waters that will have major consequences as they start to uncover evidence of corruption and details of a case that was covered up some time before.

Previously stories took place over a couple of episodes but this one is stretched over the entire six part series… this is a definite improvement as the story never feels rushed. Equally there is enough material to fill those episodes so it never drags. There are some good twists along the way; most notably the death of the prime suspect, played by the excellent and imposing Ciarán Hinds, I certainly didn't expect him to be written out so soon. The story has plenty of tense moments; at one point it looks as though one of the team may have been murdered. As corruption is uncovered there is a sense that few people outside the regular team can be trusted. The cast do a fine job with Douglas Henshall excelling as DI Perez; Alison O'Donnell impresses as DS Alison 'Tosh' McIntosh, especially after the events in Glasgow that have major implications for her character. The guest cast that includes the likes of James Cosmo and Anna Chancellor is also impressive. When we get to the final episode there are several surprising revelations leading to a well wrapped-up story
19 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best season ever watched in a mystery series!
grgpptss11 September 2022
All my reviews are mostly around 7-8/10 of every mystery series because the plot twists presented are usually based in random information thrown in at last minute. In this series however the plot twist was always there and something was odd from the beginning you just had to use your brain to find it. It is the perfect plot, congratulations to the person who wrote the script. I've watched multiple series this season is by far the best of any. I hope the next season are as well made is this one and this will remain as the best mystery series I have ever watched. I hope you continue your good job.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Excellent Scottish mini series
fiona_r_lamb28 November 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I LOVED the entire series 2. Having watched a number of French, Australian and Scandinavian police series that were good but getting a bit predictable, along comes this - very fresh, really well made and acted. And the cinematography is stunning too.

The storyline(s) developed believably and always held my interest. The whole story arc centering about rape was well handled except I did not like the fact the two rapists were not punished. The shy loner artist with the crush on the detective was sweet and not overdone. I also liked how the story came to Glasgow as well.

I do have one major issue. After the ferry docks in episode 1 the young woman is seen searching the boat for the young man she met, Robbie. But in ep. 6 when she is uncovered as the person who locked Robbie in the lorry during the night on the ferry, why would this have happened??? She knows where he is. Makes no sense whatsoever and is very sloppy.

But otherwise I was very impressed with the acting and plot. Very well done!
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Realllllly??
dwbbee17 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This is a most-excellent show, which is definitely the first thing I must say, unequivocally. The scripts are well-written and the shows excellently acted, which also must include well-edited because acting is never perfect. My disappointment, however, is with this season is Tosh's rape. Must we really still have to rape a woman in order to create drama??!!! This excellent story line could have evolved without the humiliation of one of the viewers' favorite/main characters. But a woman's rape is such a reliable trope, which promises to titillate and also create empathy among viewers. It's just soooooo disappointing that this show fell upon it. Why is the image of a strong, intelligent, professionally competent, yet now personally/emotionally disgraced, woman so necessary in a story's development???
8 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
One glaring, unanswered question
ww1buff6519 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Without revealing whodunit, I have to say that the one loose thread they didn't tie up was how the killer knew to contact Calvin via the anonymous e-mail. Without that, the ending wasn't 100% complete.
9 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
I was confused by the ending...
rusoviet3 September 2018
Warning: Spoilers
....wasn't actually sure how the young lady first seen on the ferry in episode 1 somehow 'fitted' into the solution to the crimes. Also the McColl character faded very quickly - it almost seemed to me the writer patched a confusing 'wow' that didn't fit at all. Sad actually because the episodes leading up to this point were well written. Also no comeuppance for the 'unknown' assailant of the assistant detective 'Tosh at the Glasgow Airport that I recall nor any blowback for the Female overall superior unless that's laid down the following season 4.
10 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
far from Ann Cleeves
mark_kingma16 March 2023
While "Vera" stood by it's original, story-wise, Shetland is now going far from ms Cleeves novels. Both Vera and Shetland went for original stories. Vera just run out of novels and only could use a new novel for a new season after a novel was released. Shetland have still 3 novels and two novella's they decided to abandon and went for season-stories with one story. And now you have to fill 6 episodes for one mystery. In any 6-episode minis-series this is no problem. And this story in it self of a decent story. But now it seperates from the Ann Cleeves-type stories and i think that is a bit of shame. And with the rape entered into it from ep 5, the series has turned also a bit depressive.
2 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed