Liberty's Secret (2016) User Reviews

Low Budget Musical

[nammage · 4/10 · 13 October 2019]

I enjoy many types of films, even Musicals; even low budget ones though the last good one I saw was "Cannibal the Musical". It was hilarious. I don't know how much this film cost but that film cost $150,000 ($260,000 in today's dollar) to make. (I don't count "Reefer Madness: The Musical" because it's budget was $25 million.) In my opinion, I think all the money and effort went into the choreography and singing and both were poor except the singing from Alfrelynn J. Roberts who, sadly, only sang one song (that I remember) in the entire film.

It's also a Comedy. And, I did laugh but not at the things I think the audience was supposed to laugh at. Like the part in the beginning where the Senator's team says that those at the church really loved Liberty's singing. I laughed at that because...it's her church! Her father's the preacher. They've all probably known her her entire life; of course they're going to love her. Oh, and if all it took for a Senator to win in a conservative area is to have a singer that people love then all politicians would have singers with them. And why would a Conservative help a non-Conservative get re-elected but to know that that person will do what they want? They wouldn't. Not reality.

Anyway...what's up with all the montages?

Great Film!

[benjamintimpf · 25 April 2017]

A wonderful film Great romance story full of uncertainty Camera movement was a little off sometimes The music was just good, but the dancing was wonderful Overall pleased. Wish there was less emphasis on her being a good Christian, but appreciate that she does not give up on her faith. Hopefully, see this movie be entered into some film festivals and win some awards.

Some spoilers not that it matters don't waste your time watching this.

[catadaiana · 1/10 · 6 January 2017]

Just wow. I read the plot and I was excited to watch it, it seemed like a good idea with potential. When it started I immediately wanted to turn it off but I didn't. I made a check list with everything I hated:

-The camera moving funny at some points was it filmed hand-held?! - The slow motion at some scenes NOT GOOD. -The singing is good the music however very bad. -What was that music over the montage? It didn't work at all. -What was with the green screens, just why?! -I love you?? after one kiss? sure they spent time together but you didn't build on the relationship at all that music over the montage took away from the depth so jumping into I love you was bad. -Omg I can't even start on the acting, Jaclene Wilk was the only one that acted somewhat okay everyone else was horrible but I don't know if it's because of the cast or the script. -The script was very bad it felt very fake and not how people talk at all. A character named Dick was the realest character in the film. -The lady that snaps the picture is the best character in the film. -I cannot stress enough how bad the script was. -What's with that parody of the TV show? -Seriously it made me so cringed out and angry that I want to talk to the dude who made it and find out what the heck was he thinking. -They get married?! What the.... man. -It felt like a parody of a parody.

Just a bad lesbian movie in general then you add the music and somehow it makes it worse. I cringed so hard I couldn't stop cursing. The LGBT community needs better movies and better representation than this. This can't be it!

Very entertaining

[andgettinghotter · 7/10 · 6 October 2021]

I clicked on this movie as I was getting tired of browsing and I am glad that I did. It is a very lighthearted (as most musicals are) look at politics, the news media and the religious right. The lesbian relationship between the two main characters is a sub-plot in my opinion. Jaclene Wilk was absolutely delightful as Liberty. I hope this isn't a one-off for her. I also liked the portrayal of Kenny Weston and Dick Dinkler. I was raised a Roman Catholic and I found the church scenes comical.

Girl-meets-girl political satire musical

[juliedybdahl · 7/10 · 13 May 2017]

Very clever, lots-of-fun musical that supports same-sex marriage at the same time that it spoofs US politics and those who wrap themselves in the flag of "family values." The film has much humor, and the music and lyrics are wonderful!

This is not a polished movie, but a low-budget independently produced film. It's a little uneven, but over all it's worth the watching - light, funny, clever, and topical. It's a good film to show your Aunt Mary who needs to be educated about "gay marriage" while enjoying a show.

In a word: Delightful

[sonofsoulreaver-50329 · 8/10 · 7 May 2021]

This is a feel good movie that is perfectly campy, cheesy, romantic, and impactful. The music good, the lyrics are mostly heartfelt, the characters are likable, and the lampooning of right wing fundies without being mean is awesome. Despite it's obvious technical flaws and low budget style, I enjoyed it from beginning to end. There are two things keeping me from giving it 10 stars. First is the lack of chemistry between the two leads. I just don't feel the romantic spark between them. The second might have helped the first if done properly, and that is that we don't really see the development of a relationship. There's a montage, but the meat of the building of the romantic relationship just wasn't there.

Still, I thoroughly enjoyed this movie.

Enjoyable even with the flaws

[ktsthegame · 9/10 · 24 April 2017]

It may not be the best musical but has so much charm, that the low budget works in the movies favor. I watched it on Amazon Prime and liked enough that I bought the film on Amazon. So it's with checking out if want some laughs in a good cheesy love story that comes from the heart.

A Non Controversial Movie of a Controversial Subject

[maglanpro-28215 · 9/10 · 14 May 2019]

A (dare I say it?) wonderful charming film. Very reminiscent of the so-called Golden Age of Hollywood musicals. What I found especially "charming" was that its potentially controversial subject matter was treated in a very matter-of-fact, no big deal way.

A Feel-Good Movie For A Feel-Bad Time

[Jenlar7983 · 10/10 · 30 December 2016]

In a time when politics is turning all the tables, there's no better escape than a film with the perfect balance of relatability, comedy, and music! Kick back and enjoy this All-American treat!

The style pulls viewers back to a time of Technicolor MGM movie-musicals, which is hard to find in new releases. Reminiscent of the beloved new release La La Land, this film resonates with lovers of theater, LGBT, and politics alike.

In 98 minutes, we experience a character begin in a wholesome religious life and, unlike many films of its kind, Liberty maintains her beliefs without becoming a martyr as she steps out of the closet and embraces who she is. It is a truly refreshing tale.

Unforgettable

[verab-596-794033 · 10/10 · 26 April 2017]

This is the musical the LGBTQI world has been waiting for. Far too often our stories have been told in gray tones, this movie brings joy and color to our relationships. The singing is great, the acting superb, in fact this should be a milestone, a gauge for all the gay musicals that are now free to be created.

Absolutely brilliant!

[M1racl3sHapp3n · 10/10 · 22 April 2017]

This is one of the most refreshing movies which deals with homosexuality where sexual scenes have not been overly emphasized. It manages to portrait a complete picture of average America where stereotypes are held in the most brilliant way. It's destined to become a cult! The lyrics and the music are so intelligently intertwined that you catch yourself singing along just after the first few lines. Expect to burst out laughing at any moment.I will watch it again!

A Sweet, Wonderful Film

[lemonwoodcourt · 10/10 · 11 January 2017]

Beyond the lilting music, clever lyrics, spirited dancing, and wacky politics, Liberty's Secret is the heartbreaking and heart-enriching story of a young woman struggling to accept her love for another woman.

This basic story has not been told nearly enough in popular culture, and certainly not with the trappings of a classic Hollywood musical!

Jaclene Wilk, as Liberty Smith, brilliantly embodies the fear and doubt of a woman forced to love in silence. Behind her chipper, all-American pose, there is pain in her eyes as she asks herself the question, "I love her. Love is good. How can what I feel be so wrong?"

It's a sweet, wonderful film with a generous heart. Revel in it!

Simple & beautiful musical movie with thin layered poetical love story

[zhulu-34998 · 10/10 · 13 September 2018]

The director Andy Kirshner well handled the movie with what he portrayed to audience is pristine and highly appreciable one. I was really enjoying each and every scene , characters and notable soulful rendered songs and music. This movie has Senator Political campaign, Countryside church , More musically , decent love story with more lively characters from Cara AnnMarie & Jaclene wilk ( two beautiful artists).

I watched the movie on Amazon Prime and worth it.

Loved it

[prystalcage · 9/10 · 30 August 2020]

This movie incorporates all my favorite things: religion, politics, and lesbians--all the things you aren't supposed to talk about. It is fun, it is entertaining, and there are so few Lesbian musicals. The music is really great and consistently well done. Performances and story are solid. My favorite musical scene was the song when Liberty tried conversion therapy.

I'd definitely watch it again. I told my wife we would have to learn one of the songs for our vow renewal <3. Good job to all involved.

Quite Enjoyable

[stephangw · 8/10 · 31 March 2022]

Quite enjoyed this movie, good story line, satiristic of far right wing politicians. The only downfall that i could see is the lip synching between the musical video and audio tracks was somewhat lacking. Overall, a good watch without any gratuitous lesbian scenes and suitable for all ages.