A Christmas Carol (2018) Poster

(II) (2018)

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
3/10
A truly tragic adaptation
blott2319-127 December 2021
I've lost track of how many different versions of A Christmas Carol that my wife and I have watched at this point, but it's a lot. I was interested in watching a modern-day version of the story, but had no idea how lazy they could be. This movie was truly atrocious and included some of the worst acting I've ever seen in an adaptation of the Dickens tale. They tried to shoehorn in some of the original dialogue from the book, and it simply didn't work when put in the context of a modern setting. I know the beats so well from this story, and yet somehow this adaptation managed to make it all seem clunky and lack any kind of flow.

It's clear that some guys gathered together and decided they could do an easy cash grab with a story which is in the public domain, so they slapped something together and even tried making it a little more edgy by changing Bob Cratchett into a woman, and making Tim her husband with cancer rather than a kid. However, they didn't think about how this impacts the overall story. I mean there's really no financial way that Scrooge can magically make cancer better, particularly in a nation that already has the NHS to cover most medical costs. It's just a dumb movie, and it's kind of embarrassing that they manage to take a story that even kids cartoons can get right and mess it up this badly.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A different take, try it and see what ya think
stonebrake21 December 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Well. It's a different take which is fine. Ive probably watched 20 different versions this season. The problem with this version is. The production. Very odd. I hate to use the example. But if you have seen an 80's porno film. It has that feel and production value and a dare say porno music. The main actor is kinda terrible. Like a bad version of Chris Hemsworth. It could so much more. It's a modern take. Give it a shot. Currently on Peacock. Maybe others. The story is changed quite a bit. For example. Scrooges uncle comes to invite his newphew to dinner. Bob is scrooges female assistant. Tim is Bobs husband.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Not Very Good, in fact terrible.
officerdonb22 December 2019
I normally try to watch all versions of a Christmas Carol and at one time my family collected any version that was on VHS or DVD and if it wasn't available we could always record it, as my late mother was really into it. I even had made up a list of every version that came out so we could collect them and bought her the book a duplicate of Dickens original book. I've only come across one version I thought was worth (one revolving around trailer park trash) This just doesn't do it. It's trying to be a darker version with trying to use some of the original lines, it just doesn't work. If they changed the writing, settings, and the terrible acting maybe it would it work as this doesn't.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Boring! Boring! Boring!
christosyr23 December 2019
I never bored so much in my life watching a film! I tried hard watch the half of it but I gave up! Why on Earth they make such horrible film which is a great story from Charles Dickens! I have seen modern versions and I liked them but this is beyond bordone! Very bad acting! Don't waste your time watch it! So horrible!
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not a Humbug.
TheWalkingDood24 December 2018
Charles Dickens 'A Christmas Carol' is a classic. It's been told in many different ways and formats. From book, radio, the stage, the big screen and beyond. From Muppets to CGI, through comedy and through tragedy, there's even musicals. This version doesn't fail to impress.

A Scottish retelling has old Scrooge the boss of a distillery in modern days. With Bob Cratchit his faithful employee, and her ill husband Tim.

Shot on a budget but with good camera work and pretty decent acting all around. The colours are dark and gritty but it makes sense when Ebeneezer comes to his senses and his world lights up. Stuart Brennan emotes pretty well as Ebeneezer and he had me cheering for him in the end. Keeps to the Dickens spirit and is well worthy of a watch at Christmas..... Oh; and it stars the gorgeous Bonnie Wright too. Extra half star for that.
8 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A surprise!
sarahstevenson-2200125 December 2018
Well this was a Christmas Eve surprise. We just put this on for something in the background as it was a cheap rental for a new release, but ended up glued to it. Fast paced throughout. Well acted by most characters and very well directed. Low budget but there are some stunning shots of castles and landscapes. Well worth a watch this Christmas especially for the bakery scene. Up go the thumbs.
9 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
modern, HILARIOUS, christmas carol remake
aaronlwarne25 December 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I watched this after a drink with a friend on xmas eve, and at first we thought it was just a bad, low budget movie. We then realised it is actually unintentionally extremely funny.

Firstly, the guy doing Scrooge is stupidly over the top (sometimes nick cage level). Every other reaction he made, I burst out laughing. Bob Cratchit is a woman but they decided not to change the name for some reason, so he just calls her Bob.. Instead Of tiny Tim being ill its Bob Cratchit's husband Tim who has cancer.. OMG IS THIS FILM FUNNY.

The dialogue is utter nonsense at times which was great xD. At one point some girls are collecting money for a heart charity and scrooge suggests instead of money the ill people should get arsenic or perhaps... electric shocks from cattle prods. (did I miss something? it made no sense LMAO).

For some reason lots of people are dying young in this movie: Marley is about 30, Ginny from harry potter is in this (great acting btw) and she dies young, Bob cratchit's husband is dying, scrooge sees his future grave, which makes sense in the original cos he is old but in this he is about 30. In modern Britain why is everyone dying? There's also a weird scene with a random youngish guy that was laid off from his job and is now just limping around picking up pennies for survival, which would make sense if it was 1819 not 2019.

Scrooge is a complete caricature, outrageously unbelievable, insanely heartless rich guy. special effects are from the 90s. Generally the acting and lines were not good. But that made it too funny!!

Definitely watching this movie again. Why had I not heard of this movie?? good for drinking games. Entertainment level: 11/10!
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A good retelling!
beachpatricia8 August 2019
This movie was a great retake on the classic. It was a modern version and I really enjoyed watching it. The acting was great. The film had beautiful scenery also. Listen carefully. The music is awesome.I am glad I happen to come across this movie. I will add it to my go to movie list for Christmas time.
6 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Best modern-day version
info-412-76017425 December 2018
For years I've searched for satisfactory modern-day versions of this movie.

I was fearful that maybe this movie wouldn't make the jump to modern day as such things like debtor's prison are a thing of the past.

But, glad to say this movie was really, really enjoyable as a modern-day version of A Christmas Carol.
5 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Christmas Carol with Stuart Brennan
pcm-6895129 November 2021
This is kind of off best but still very good. One review said it was boring but it still gets the message across in a different way. I have seen about all the versions but this is different.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed