"Murdoch Mysteries" All That Glitters (TV Episode 2015) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
There isn't gold in them thar hills...
miles-3310825 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Constables Crabtree and Higgins are talking outside Police Station 4, when a man staggers up to them, collapses, dropping his hip flask, and struggles to say, "Eagle flight… I have been… murdered." Inspector Brackenreid suggests this may be a reference to the Eagle's Flight brand of whisky, which, as a connoisseur, he says is awful. Another of Brackenreid's talents comes to the fore when he shows Murdoch and Dr Ogden a painting he has just completed. Murdoch likes the frame, while his wife loves the impressionistic and original use of colour. The Inspector explains his pink trees arose from a combination of his artistic vision and the fact he had run out of green paint.

The dead man is identified as Edward Graham, a land surveyor who was working at the behest of the Ontario Government to assess a route for the planned Northern Ontario Railway. A map and a note among Mr Graham's effects points to a meeting with "CAM". Murdoch keeps the appointment, and CAM turns out to be Charles Arthur McCool, a Member of Parliament, who is mightily offended when Murdoch's information that Graham had been carrying a large amount of cash comes across to him as an accusation of corruption.

Dr Ogden sees a poster advertising a painting competition, and without telling him, she enters Inspector Brackenreid's painting, for which he could win $10. The Inspector isn't best pleased, and goes to the gallery to reclaim his work, but a painter at the gallery persuades him to permit the painting to remain in the competition.

Soon Murdoch and Crabtree are on a train bound for Northern Ontario, but they will have to trek through the forest to reach their destination of Haliberry. Crabtree has brought his pillow along, to ensure a good night's sleep. They encounter several characters on their journey, including Jagger Brown, a prospector, and Mack, a feisty woman who takes a shine to Constable Crabtree. When night falls and the party must make camp in the woods, it is quickly clear that Constable Crabtree is even more terrified of the local wildlife than he is of Mack. It is also clear that Jagger Brown is no country boy, when he finds a root vegetable that he thinks is a parsnip, but which the party's Indian guide, and later Murdoch identify as water hemlock.

When they reach Haliberry, the policemen break into the hotel room which Edward Graham had been renting, and there discover a sheet of tracing paper with several unexplained symbols on it. The trouble is that it is not clear how the sheet should be laid over the place the map, or what the symbols signify. Murdoch tells George to lock the map and overlay in his room for safe keeping, and then join him in the bar. In the bar, they meet Harold Richmond, a man who bought up a lot of land in the region, based on where the railway was, he believed, likely to be routed, but stands to lose a fortune now that Graham's survey proposes a different alignment, through an Indian Reservation. They also meet Frank Gowdy, Graham's assistant, who tells them that Graham's plan to take the railway through Indian land had made him many enemies in town. He also tells them of a woman with whom Graham had been involved, though when he had left for Toronto, she had followed him, "mad as a wildcat". He points to her across the bar. It's Mack, who doesn't seem too put out by the news of Graham's murder.

Back in Toronto, Drs Ogden and Grace are trying to identity the substance used to poison Edward Graham. Eventually they narrow it down to water hemlock George retires to his room, only to find the door forced and Mack, waiting in bed for him. Next morning, she claims she didn't break into George's room, but that the door was already open, which she took to be an invitation. She claims to have seen Jagger Brown coming the other way along the hallway. When challenged by George, Jagger runs off.

So, is Mack or Jagger the poisoner? Or is it someone else in this town? Will Brackenreid be a great success in the art world? What did the dying words of Edward Graham mean? Why did Graham change the railway's course?

This humorous episode is as full of intrigue as any fan could wish, and it reunites Murdoch with his prospecting past. Sadly, it ends on a true, but unhappy, point of history. The Murdoch Mysteries continue to educate, as they entertain.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
my fave so far!
katherinemch26 August 2021
This episode was a strange mixture. There were several moments of sitcom-esque cheesy humour. The ending made me cry, but over stuff that is worth focusing on, not gratuitous tearjerking. And yet the most notable detail was that the atmosphere was so delicious I see myself rewatching this to sooth myself whenever I feel off. There is a rustic setting, you see, so the lads are in rugged clothes I covet, and there are many lovely serene settings like the forest and a rooming house the peaceful hallways and rooms of which will be my happy place in any future meditation lol! Definitely my favourite episode!

But they name the chubby, brash, butch-but-hot brunette character "M. McCarthy"? I sometimes get the feeling a writer uses placeholder names while getting episodes started, often using a famous name to create an instant vibe, and then they neglect to swap in realistic names for the final product. It is annoyingly distracting, like recently a duo of worthless ex-cops were "Applebey & Perkins", like the duo of almost-food purveyors one sees near every highway offramp in the usa. I suppose the writer was trying to express their nature as bland, low quality, spending most of their shifts on coffee breaks. But the benefit of the "ha ha, cute." you get from seeing such wacky names is outweighed by the harm the distraction factor does to suspension of disbelief.

One other thing to note- I found it fascinating when Murdoch was interacting with a rep of the local tribe. His stoic demeanour and uninflected speech can seem awkward contrasted against flamboyant European manners (like how Ogden giggles and smiles whenever she has to say something she thinks the person she's talking to will not like), but transplanted... His usual qualities seem dignified and respectful when paired with the similarly stoic Native man's style. I think the scene illuminates Murdoch's way of interacting, which is helpful perhaps to those like some recent reviewers who misinterpret his lack of facade as hickish and his stoicism as wimpiness. He's just unaffected and employs a poker face. That's quite different from being too shy or inexperienced to express oneself! Seeing him with the Native guy made me think, if Murdoch was written as Native his measured speech and placid facial expression wouldn't raise any eyebrows at all. Like our calibration of judging whether his persona is weird or admirable changes just because of race, hm.

And was this our first time learning that he was once a lumberjack, presumably for quite a long time since he traded with the local tribe enough to know their language? Cool! This guy has had diverse experiences! Apparently competent at physical jobs as well as at mental ones. Impressive.

So this episode made me "get" and like Murdoch a bit more than I already did. I think this season they have set a goal to make all the characters more multifaceted and explain them, which is a welcome evolution to me.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed