Nina (TV Series 2015– ) Poster

(2015– )

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
I needed something to occupy my head during a project
mrsbryan-714836 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Naturally, reading subtitles slowed down my project, but I don't regret watching and am glad I saw the two seasons worth of episodes. There are more, but can't find them in USA sources.

Got started on this on local PBS station, an 11 pm offering. Saw more on PBS Passport via Walter Presents subsection.

Agree with other reviewer that the "rookie" nurse is given too wide latitude and authority in this hospital (apparently because her father and former hubby are powerful here), that she had sufficient training as a student physician in a former life to be a heck of a nurse now and can brainstorm in a diagnosis session, that hospital financial issues are contrived and the top administrator reports to mysterious irrational decision-makers, that the ward is considered a top medical facility yet is perpetually endangered by staffing shortages and money issues, and that the chain of authority shifts so oddly.

Nevertheless, I got involved in each medical case, each interpersonal swing of fate, each emergency. Nina's house is often filled up with other persons and though the home interactions are of course very forced; there were at least 2 medical on-the-spot emergencies in these two seasons that occurred for Nina on the street enroute to the hospital, I accepted all this. What the heck, who cares?

The two teenagers episode is still on my mind. Although their mischief-making seems preposterous, nevertheless the boys were riveting enough to affect me. Other topics include forgiveness, friendship, parenthood, aspirations and reality, secret alcoholism, and a lot of oddball diseases. Dr. Proust apparently has carte blanche to test theoretical diagnoses over and over again, but the actor's crazy bipolar-ness of being diabolical yet being kind kept me going.

The overtired staff, the sexual activity on the sly, the de-compressing after work, well, I accepted all of this. Dorothee is a wonderfully wacky character, another unbelievable nurse but in a much different context than saintly Nina, and played by a woman with a remarkable silly smile.

I hope to find more episodes and find out what happens to the head nurse.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Silly if you prefer reality
BeatriceBG1 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
If you like your run-of-the-mill soapy medical drama, you may find this perfectly watchable.

I suffered through the first episode and decided to move on. This is not at all how a new grad nurse's first day in a hospital would be. One minute she's in the ER, the next she's in IM, the next she's at the hospital security office, next she's in the OR, next she's in the medical records archives, next she's telling an adult patient she was adopted... She doesn't seem to have any particular job duties other than running all over the hospital doing whatever she feels like doing.

The show tries to take itself seriously and yet it's implausibility gives it an air of ridiculousness. Normally I like the Walter Presents recommendations, but this one was a flop.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
No connection to reality
img54-113 February 2024
Possibly the least realistic hospital show ever. Bad writing, over the top acting and treatment of nurses, patients and even doctors that would never happen. Or is this just France?

The characters behave strangely and the situations are unbelievable. The main character makes the oddest choices and never any consequences. The peripheral characters happily take advantage of her poor choices and she happily lets them. Her mother, her roommate Leo, her daughter, her ex husband, the other doctors...all completely annoying.

Surprisingly I am still watching, but I am fascinated by bad TV that I don't have to pursue.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed