"Madam Secretary" Standoff (TV Episode 2015) Poster

(TV Series)

(2015)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Stunning Lack of Creativity
championbc-99-500524 August 2016
I wish that someone who writes in Hollywood would actually go to Texas before pretending to know anything about this state.

I don't think Texas has had a governor who even remotely resembled Caleb Lockwood since the 1930s, and his nickname was "Pappy." Texas governors wear nice tailored suits, have college educations, and understand the law and diplomacy.

We have had Republicans and Democrats, liberals and conservatives, in office for my whole lifetime, and none of them would have done what this one did, even the most conservative of the lot. We do not believe in crossing international borders and stealing prisoners, and if some vigilante group (looks more like Idaho to me) were to steal a prisoner from Mexico and bring him here, our governor would not set up carnival booths and exploit this thing in the media.

Most likely, the governor -- any governor from the past 50 years -- would have personally called the secretary of state and asked for help in resolving this international incident.

This series is fabulous! The writing is (usually) excellent. I love this entire series, and I know that even the best of them have a "rotten" one here and there, but really? Who is the unimaginative, lazy person who actually thinks that Texans elect fat "Boss Hawg" types of politicians to parade around in street clothes, using exaggerated accents, and talk like they are on "Smokey and the Bandit?" I still gave the episode a "6." Most of them, in my opinion, are worth a 9 or a 10, but they need to can the persons who wrote this caricature in, and while they are at it, get rid of whoever it was that cast the actor for the governor. We have not had an overweight governor in my entire lifetime, and they all have dressed the part, even the ones I didn't particularly like, such as the one right before the man we have now.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
This is so funny it makes my sides ache.
travinitrav23 November 2021
Whiners in 2015 complaining a texas governor would never behave in this manner must be very curious as why texas and a few other republican dominated states have done absolutely atrocious things during the god-awful Trump Years.

Anyway, the episode is actually solid because it accurately portrays how the state department can be maneuvered into bad situations by individual states and other government agencies. Once again Beth does a fantastic job negotiating rocky terrain, but at this point its all very formulaic and tiresome. Utterly amazing that week after week the Secretary of State encounters a problem that can also be solved inside a week. The concept starts to wear thin. But its still an entertaining hour of television regardless.

Its a good episode for regular fans but casual viewers can probably skip this one, nothing particularly exciting or important happens.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
flat, unconvincing, infantile
davidbland-175-8008384 January 2015
The previous 11 episodes of Madam Secretary (through Nov. 30, 2014) all were characterized by mature, intelligent, convincing and realistic scripts, both in the writing and in the delivery by the actors.

Tonight's episode ("Standoff," Jan. 4, 2015) fell flat on all those points. The dialogues were flat, infantile and convincing, which may reflect a change in writers. Added to that, however, was the corresponding failure in the delivery of tonight's script by the actors — the same actors that had performed in a consistently outstanding style in ALL of the previous episodes.

How to explain that fails me. Is it the appearance of a new director, or were the actors themselves challenged beyond reasonable expectations to make gold from the leaden script of a new writer?

Perhaps the answer will be obvious in the next three episodes, which were written by three writers of earlier shows, although two of the three upcoming shows do rely on new directors.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed