- Henry Morgan: Every person who has lived long enough has something in their past that must be forgotten. A moment when they failed or simply went right instead of left, and that simple choice changed their life for the worse. So we cover it up and forget, but deep down, we know it will come back to haunt us.
- Jo Martinez: The question is: what did they find?
- Lucas Wahl: [Imitates pirate voice] Gold! They found gold
- Henry Morgan: Lucas! Please
- Lucas Wahl: [normal voice] Oh, come on! I've been waiting all morning for that moment
- Lucas Wahl: [Looking at human bones] Talk about a cold case
- Henry Morgan: We found these remains in our victim's warehouse last night. They were from a 200 year old shipwreck. Let's find out what happened to him
- Lucas Wahl: 200 years old! I guess there are no
- [pirate voice]
- Lucas Wahl: aye witnesses.
- [Henry looks at him, normal voice]
- Lucas Wahl: Okay, I'm done
- Lucas Wahl: Hey, got a package for you. Looks cool
- [Henry opens it and sees gun which most likely killed him for the first time]
- Lucas Wahl: Nice gun
- Henry Morgan: Yes. I, eh, requested it from The Explorer's Club. It was found on the shipwreck that Rick discovered
- Lucas Wahl: I know
- Henry Morgan: You know?
- Lucas Wahl: Yeah, I read it on your Explorer's Club Journal here, right? They did a whole photo spread and everything. Kind a cool
- Henry Morgan: You read my magazines?
- Lucas Wahl: Sometimes
- Henry Morgan: Ah. Well, thank you, Lucas. That'll be all
- Lucas Wahl: You know the flint lock pistol took over a minute to reload and its accuracy was only 15 feet. Kind a lame gun, honestly
- Henry Morgan: Yes, well, how interesting...
- Lucas Wahl: I mean, how much of a tool would you have to be to get shot by that? Right? You could just duck down or like jog away at a moderate pace
- Mike Hanson: [Knocking at the door, knowing that Jo is inside too] Mr. Monroe? This is the NYPD. Please, open up!
- [listens at door]
- Mike Hanson: Oh man! Marvin Gaye
- Henry Morgan: What does that mean?
- Mike Hanson: Doc, please! There's like a 70% chance they're... you know
- Henry Morgan: On a first date?
- Mike Hanson: Yeah, this could be an epic mistake!