Storyline has been outlined by other reviewers. I wish to add the following: If the scenes in which Murdock is interrogating Inspector Giles were scenes in a movie, actor Nigel Bennett would have received an Oscar nomination for best-supporting actor. Under questioning by Murdoch, Giles obfuscates, defends and finally breaks. He reveals how his true love turned out to be a lie and how it destroyed his willingness to ever love again. Bennett's portrayal of Giles at this moment — his face pained and his eyes slightly tearing — were heartbreaking and true to his stoic character. Bennett is a rare bird and a pleasure to watch. Bravo also to the writers of this episode. Makes me wonder why Giles is being written out of the series? I know he is incarcerated, but somehow bring him back, perhaps as someone the detectives consult with from time to time or as a private investigator.
P.S. I do not know Bennett and have never seen him act before Murdoch. However, I am a 53-year-old classic movie buff and a Shakespearean play lover. I have seen every episode of Murdoch on Acorn and Netflix multiple times. So, I feel like I am a fairly good judge of acting ability.
P.S. I do not know Bennett and have never seen him act before Murdoch. However, I am a 53-year-old classic movie buff and a Shakespearean play lover. I have seen every episode of Murdoch on Acorn and Netflix multiple times. So, I feel like I am a fairly good judge of acting ability.