"Murdoch Mysteries" The Murdoch Appreciation Society (TV Episode 2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Stabbed?, Smothered?, Poisoned? Killed, definitely
miles-3310823 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Constable Jackson is patrolling the park early one morning, without a care, whistling 'the British Grenadiers', when he spots an elderly man asleep on a bench. Assuming he is a vagrant, he goes over to wake him. It is then that he discovers the man is dead with a stab wound in the chest. Jackson raises the alarm and is soon joined by other officers, and Dr. Grace, who was doing her morning calisthenics in the park. The only other witness that early in the morning is Nigel Barnes, a birdwatcher. At first, he says he didn't see anything but then recalls a man in a long coat with a beard. Dr Grace finds that the dead man had a key on him and three pages torn from a printed book. Detective Murdoch observes that the man has dried blood on his index finger, whilst the doctor notes there is a general lack of blood around the bench and she concludes that the man was killed elsewhere. The bird spotter stays just within earshot, unconvincingly fiddling with a camera on a tripod.

At Police Station 4, a man called Owen Hume has asked if he can speak to detective Murdoch by name, and tells Murdoch that his employer, patent lawyer Randolph Sampson, has not been seen for two days. After hearing Sampson's description, Murdoch takes Hume to the morgue, where he confirms that the body is that of Mr Sampson.

Back at the station house, detective Murdoch brings inspector Brackenreid up to date with the case. There appears to be no motive for the killing, Mr. Sampson is the most ordinary of men; indeed, the only clue of any substance is the pages torn out of the book, a novella by Mark Twain, those pages being 39, 81 and 146. Murdoch wonders where Constable Crabtree is, and Inspector Brackenreid says he has gone to medical school in order to look into the disappearance of a corpse, that of Professor Andrew Richardson. Dr. Dempsey from the school is conducting a research project concerning the brains of highly intelligent people. It transpires that it is very difficult finding people willing to donate their brains for research. Also, for the purposes of the research, the brains must be fresh to be of use, so the loss of the Professor's body is critical to Dr Dempsey, who may even lose his funding as a result.

Dr Ogden, meanwhile, is meeting with her fellow suffragettes to discuss ways of furthering their cause, since their petition has only attracted 100 signatures to date. In a flash of inspiration, she wonders if there is any reason a woman may not stand in the imminent provincial election. The women decide to seek legal advice.

Murdoch follows up the clues from the torn book pages. He visits Belair Books, where the proprietor, Mrs Dewar, says she only had one copy of the book, which she sold to one of her regular customers, Annie Cranston, who works nearby, at Minnie's Tea Room. Pursuing this lead, Murdoch goes to the tea room, and finds Miss Cranston, who is a waitress. She cannot help, as someone stole the book from the tea shop before she had read all of it. Another waitress, Ruby Rosevear, had been eavesdropping, and tells Murdoch that she recalls a man with a beard acting suspiciously on the premises, and returns with Murdoch to recreate the man's face using Murdoch's facial samples device.

Murdoch believes he has found an encoded message in the pages from book; he believes they are an invitation to building near the docks. Accompanied by Inspector Brackenreid, he visits the building and finds it to be the scene of foul play. There is a bloody knife, and a trail of blood spots, which they follow to a message written in blood, saying, "BLUE SKY". Going on from that building to Mr Sampson's office, Murdoch uses the key found in the park to open Sampson's desk, which contains a file for BLUE SKY, but the contents have been torn out.

Back at the morgue, with help from Dr Ogden, Dr Grace discovers that Sampson was dead from being smothered before the stab wound was inflicted on him. How could Sampson write a message in his own blood if he was dead from suffocation already? Pioneering lawyer Clara Brett Martin confirms to the women's group that the election rules do not preclude female candidates, though she suspects that, were a woman to win, she might find doors slammed shut.

When Constable Crabtree returns from visiting the widow of Professor Richardson with a photograph of her late husband that shows Professor Richardson and Mr Sampson are in fact the same person, it throws the whole investigation into disarray. The news from Dr Grace's investigation into the corpse is that, as well as being smothered and stabbed, he was also being poisoned.

The two facts Murdoch is clear on are first, that someone wanted the Professor dead, but who, and why? And second, that there has been a conspiracy to waste his time by making him look into the death of a man who never was. What will he do about the five who have been leading him a merry dance? On top of that, who can the women get to stand?

An impressive episode, for sure.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Assumptions & Appreciation + Revenge = Murder Most Foul!
Natale-cipollina3 March 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The episode begins most innocently when a Constable comes across a man on a bench in the park with his coat on backwards-The Constable assumes the man to be asleep - the man refuses the order to move on when the Constable discovers he is dead... This story has some interesting clues and plot turns and one obvious hole - regarding the two cases that seem to divide Detective Murdoch's and Constable George's interests. The side story line of Mrs. Murdoch regarding her and her friends political reforms moves that along to a clever discovery of a legal oversight in Canadian law which shows how assumptions are never to be ignored! One can almost say that this point seems to hold for the main storyline as well- for the one glaring plot hole is only possible because Station #4 has two cases that they assume to be separate! There are red herrings thrown in that Detective Murdoch is able to see through once he and George realize their two cases are indeed linked- and the assumed first cause of death is discovered by Dr.Grace and confirmed by Mrs.Murdoch to be a deliberate misdirection! Again the principle that assumptions are to be questioned and probed in order to get to the truth! It is also a very satisfying episode showing how the most innocent of inspirations from Detective Murdoch's escapades allow for a villain to exploit those who 'appreciate' the genius of his efforts! The final scene - gives one a surgery but still satisfying end to the episode.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed