"Call the Midwife" Christmas Special (TV Episode 2015) Poster

(TV Series)

(2015)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
O the TV
gkeith_126 December 2015
Warning: Spoilers
TV as a character appearing in this episode. Go to the end. Spoiler. Sister Monica Joan is happy a new TV is in the house. She says it is the key to modern life. She had really tried to go home for Christmas, but they say you can't go home again. She was missing for days, but found her old family's mansion now occupied by what looked like hippie squatters. Or ban the bomb idealists, anyway. She gets rescued, and goes back to that place from which she ran away.

TV dominates. The church is supposed to be the setting for a televised Christmas special starring the children's choir, but the kiddies are out ill. The sisters and nurses end up doing the singing. The producer said he didn't want anyone looking poor, but I wondered wasn't this a series about a poor neighborhood? He should have gone to a posh neighborhood, complete with high tea and crumpets. The children were out sick anyway, banished with their poor parents to offstage, anyway.

No wonder ppl say this show is worse than Downton Abbey. DA has expensive production values, even thougih it talks about impoverished titled aristocrats. CTM talks about poor people, diseases, filthy njjasty non-anesthetized childbirth and lack of medical attention in some cases.

CTM denizens are way poorer than the servant/downstairs class in Downton Abbey. DA looks all fancy, but most of the ppl in Call the Midwife are way nicer. I still like Call the Midwife, and Mr. Selfridge, way better than Downton Abbey. I only watched Downton Abbey to see Shirley MacLaine, and she hasn't been on that much.

TV and Christmas trees. Too commercialized for stuffy old-time nundom, but so-called dotty Sister Monica Joan got her stubborn way and actually got both. Dotty indeed. Perhaps she knows a thing or two more than some others.

Children dying of measles. Absurd. Children nowadays get measles vaccine as part of early childhood. 1950s children had measles, but I haven't heard of its being fatal.

Dr. Turner a sweetie, as usual, but I gagged when he offered the cigarette to the father-to- be. Yuck.

Patrick (Turner's son?) got taller and had a deeper voice. I did know he was a musician.

Sister Evangelina decorating a Christmas tree. It looked nice. Nice town snow and Christmas decorations.

10/10
2 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Statistically improbable.
fh_310 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Patsy seinf Delia from the bus while Delia simultaneously sees Patsy in the bus on a busy street in London is nearly statistically improbable.
0 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I am disappointed with this episode- SPOILERS
mrspractical12 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
After a long wait for my "Call the Midwife" fix, this episode did not satisfy. The most glaring problem was how mean Sister Evangelina was to not just Sister Monica Joan, but to everyone! Yes, she has always been gruff and opinionated but she usually isn't so intense. The second gripe is that no one really called her out on it. I expected after the first few outbursts that she would have a one-on-one with Sister Julienne, but everyone pretty much let her spew with no admonishment- they just cowered in her wake.

The plot seemed unrealistic, also. Would the BBC really want to film a Christmas special in Poplar? And the caricature of the producer/director was too much.

Did I miss something as I thought Tom had moved to another parish? But he is there convincing the sisters to allow the production as well as possibly developing an interest in nurse Barbara, who is as interesting as watching paint dry. Please don't let this happen! If anything he must reconnect with Trixie. And Barbara, being a nurse, did not handle the child's fever on the Christmas light watching trip well at all.

Some positive points were all the interactions between Fred and Violet. I loved her sewing the split seam in his Santa pants. Also, Sister Monica Joan's adventure to go home was well told and superbly acted, as was the side story of Patsy.

I guess my overall complaint is the episode did not utilize the characters as well as it could have, ignoring some main characters all together. For example, couldn't they have at least thrown a line in commenting on Chummy? You would think Sargent Noakes was single the way they presented him.

Yes, I know time is limited and it is just a t.v. show, but I think they could have done so much better.
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed