The Brittany Murphy Story (TV Movie 2014) Poster

(2014 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
28 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
2/10
"Where Is This Going..."
nammage6 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
"Where is this going..." was my initial thought about 30 minutes in. I like to preface by stating: I am a Brittany Murphy fan, and have 17 of her films on DVD; my favorites being "The Ramen Girl (2008)", "The Dead Girl (2006)", and "Don't Say a Word (2001)".

I do not really care for Lifetime films, mainly because they usually over exaggerate the elements of the characters; whether they are based on real people, or not -- this film is no different.

Everyone has seen this film before because it's the same as every other exposé on a celebrity's life in made-for-television productions. And, in that vein...there's no heart to this film. Whether it focuses on the minute details of Brittany Murphy's life -- the good/bad -- is irrelevant because, like most films of this accord, it primarily focuses on the tragedy of the person's life rather than on their life as a whole.

It starts you off in that vein: "The mysterious death of Brittany Murphy" with a fading voice of "Was she poisoned?" Which, from then on, is the focus of her story; the tribulations in her life: she was the "fat" girl, she's attacked by paparazzi (yet the guardian angel throughout is her future husband as a photographer/paparazzi), everyone is out to ruin her, she's the poor little hurt girl, the best friend since childhood she may have to let go etc.,

Don't get me wrong -- it does show some good moments in her life but it's all mainly in the beginning, and the rest is just one huge drama after another.

The music doesn't help. A cross between elevator music, and what you'd hear in a lackluster bar/pub.

I did come in with low expectations based on past experience in watching these types of films; and perhaps that's a detractor, and then again, perhaps not because the further it got towards the ending the evermore it got over-the-top dramatic. Some lives are dramatic but it seems with these "Hallmark" type films -- that's all they ever are; and that's fantasy.

2/10
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
A Clueless Movie Biography
wes-connors8 September 2014
Perky student Amanda Fuller (as Brittany Murphy) acts poorly in a high school stage show. Nevertheless, she is seen by a TV ad producer and quickly becomes successful making commercials - they say it's because she looks average. Hoping to become a real actress, Ms. Fuller demands single mom Sherilyn Fenn (as Sharon) move from New Jersey to Los Angeles, CA. Very quickly, Fuller's "Brittney" lands a guest-starring role on "Murphy Brown" - then, she is off and running. Now a big TV star, "Brittney" wants to be in films. So, she becomes a sensation in "Clueless". But all is not well. Fuller's "Brittney" receives a smile from a young model-type hunk on the set, but he calls her a "chunky monkey." In spite of her pounds, Fuller lands in bed with hunky Adam Hagenbuch (as Ashton Kutcher)...

Photographers swarm around "Brittney". One of them tells her the paparazzi are not real friends - that's quite a revelation...

The "Clueless" star eventually learns photographer Eric Petersen (as Simon Monjack) was correct. Over the years, they become chunky chums. All of it ends up in the teaser scene we see opening this movie. We're told this TV and film star was possibly poisoned. Yet, during the running time, there is no poisoning. That's fine, but don't suggest it again in the closing. One of the big problems with this biography - and there are many - it that the star is the most uninteresting character in the drama. Her mother and "Simon" are more interesting. Director Joe Menendez and his crew occasionally move the players around well, but it's all episodic - there is no connecting tissue. The star's rise seems to happen overnight, and no particular skills are shown. We are left to wonder why this person warranted a movie at all.

** The Brittany Murphy Story (9/6/14) Joe Menendez ~ Amanda Fuller, Sherilyn Fenn, Eric Petersen, Adam Hagenbuch
13 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
If you like Brittany Murphy, please don't watch this
infernal-eternal5 February 2015
What a disgrace. This movie might be all right if it had no connection to any real people (though it would still be a poor one), but as a biography of Brittany Murphy it's almost unwatchable. Everything is bad.

What's with the choice of actress? She doesn't look anything like Brittany, she doesn't act like her, she has no charisma (which Brittany had plenty of)... What's going on? Some other characters in the movie look and act more like Brittany than Amanda Fuller does. Chloë Crampton who plays her friend would have been a better choice. Watching that round face, I had to constantly remind myself who it's supposed to represent because there was just no resemblance.

I don't really know anything about Brittany's real life, but I really doubt she was this lame when in the movies she was so cool. It just doesn't add up. I feel like Amanda Fuller has never even seen any of Brittany's movies.

Acting is overall pretty bad. A biography of a famous person should not be a B movie with poor actors.

The movie completely fails to build up atmosphere for emotional scenes, so they just end up looking artificial and ridiculous. Crappy, boring music doesn't help either. Everything feels fake. Cheap melodrama.

A girl with a really bad wig representing Alicia Silverstone wasn't even funny.

Brittany's biography deserves a decent script and cast. This is just a bad joke.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Wtf??
yunks118 September 2014
Before watching the movie I thought all the negative reviews were coming from disgruntled family, or super fans that wouldn't be happy with anything. Boy was I wrong! All the harsh comments were totally deserved. I won't stoop to the level of name calling, but I am empathetic toward those critics. It was a total casting catastrophe. A. Fuller was so far away from resembling Brittany Murphy that it wrecked the credibility of the rest of the movie. I would only recommend wasting the time to watch it if your curious to see how bad it is yourself. Don't don't don't take anything in the movie as factual, and pray that a true biopic is released as soon as possible. I don't know any of Britt's family or friends but I feel terrible that they have to see her defamed so horribly.

R.I.P. Brittany Murphy
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
22 Minutes I will never get back
jennyrose3137 September 2014
I will say right up front, I only watched 22 minutes of this atrocity. I gave up when they got to the Alicia Silverstone "character". Seriously?! They couldn't find ONE SINGLE BLONDE ACTRESS to play the part? Instead, they appear to have grabbed some girl off the street and plopped a really, really, really bad blonde wig on her head. Did I mention how BAD the wig was. This movie is just a complete failure. Amanda Fuller sounded more like Tai from Clueless than Brittany Murphy. Frankly, the girl who played Morgan looks more like Brittany. Do yourself and your brain cells a favor and skip this steaming pile of garbage. I would have given it 0 stars if that was an option.
26 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Oh My Lord!
tenore657 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
I am a 68 year old Italian male, and I was a huge fan of Brittany Murphy. The first time I saw her was in "The Sidewalks of New York." It was a lovely New York City slice of life type story. I loved everyone in the movie, and I loved the story lines. Brittany, in my estimation, stole the show. She was so talented and so beautiful, yet had the look of the proverbial girl next door that you would love to hang out with and chew the fat. But I must say that I look more like Brittany Murphy than Amanda Fuller -- fat, untalented, with a double chin and baby fat that made her look bloated. That, and she couldn't act her way out of a paper bag. What was Lifetime thinking? I usually love Lifetime movies. I love "chick flicks," so pardon me if I'm gay. I can understand that when portraying famous people, there is usually a stretch in finding someone with all the looks and qualities of the subject matter. But this girl looked and acted nothing like Brittany. Poor Brittany would turn over in her grave. Are all young, blonde, talented actresses dead or involved in other projects? I was a HUGE Brittany fan, and this is nothing more or less than a disgrace. I just can't understand this bomb. And Eric Petersen as her love interest? Did anyone else think he looked a lot like Miss Piggie?
27 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Disappointed..
handsomedevil1988-104-54027311 September 2014
Shame on the director and the writer , they didn't even mention 8 miles in the movie nor picked an actress who even slightly resembles Brittany . Brittany wasn't chubby or that ordinary looking , she was pretty and charismatic with a nice smile . Couldn't the director at least pick a decent looking blonde or something ??!! , no he made the effort to find an actor who looked like Ashton Kutcher and forgot about the leading character . Amanda Fuller lacked performance and looks on that movie about a very special talent that the cinema lost . The whole movie lacked excitement , it was supposed to be one of them movies that moves you or touches you but for me that never happened . Movies about biography should be written and directed very carefully and honesty to deliver for the audience the real story with all its feelings and emotions . Disappointing !!!
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Did they even try?
dustyoldbones25 August 2015
Saw this film tonight on TV and decided to watch it because I am big Brittany Murphy fan. I watched the entire movie and was blown away.

The actress looks and acts nothing like Brittany Murphy in anyway. I doubt if you could hire someone who could do justice to Brittany's magnetism on a small budget, but you could at least hire an actor with a similar face/body shape. My god, I shouldn't have to keep reminding myself that this is supposed to be Brittany Murphy on screen.

The actor playing her husband was creepy as all hell, when he came on screen i though "okay, this is clearly the manipulative creep in the story" and it seemed like it was going that way. Nothing really came out of that though, so why hire an actor that the audience dislikes the entire time he is on screen? The intimate scenes were disturbing!

This movie was made in 2014, and yet they leave her extremely suspicious death to 4-6 minutes of screen time? followed by a direct quote from Wikipedia as a epilogue?

Rest in peace Brittany, I'm sorry they did this to your life story.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The worst bio movie EVER
tishco2 May 2016
Warning: Spoilers
The only redeeming factor of this movie is the guy who plays Ashton. There is no mention of some of her greatest movies. There is no mention of the guy she was engaged to. There is no mention of the band she was singer in. There is no mention of all the movies she was doing voice over for, while apparently battling drug addiction forced on by a creepy looking husband, that didn't look a thing like the real husband.

All in all, the only facts were the dates and even those were so general you couldn't follow the story line.

It was so sad when we lost this bright star and the movie should have done her honour. Instead it looks like it was put on by kindergarden kids with access to a trunk of old wigs and trash bag of rags and cast offs.

Sherilyn Finn played a great mommy dearest and the fact that they didn't make her go to the emergency room, that they didn't know CPR (even though they were doing it on a breathing talking husband when he had a heart attack) and stuck her under a shower? when she had apparently arrested. Did they think she had overdosed? A very Hollyweird response to drug overdose.

All together, you can listen to it like an old radio play but don't try and watch it. They couldn't even get a blonde to play Alicia in Clueless, she has a mop on her head.

Bad, bad, bad. Did I say bad?
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
2 thumbs way down
msquinn-122644 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I have heard about this film for awhile and hesitated to watch it after hearing such bad reviews, but gave it a shot anyways. Like most, I was a Britney Murphy fan. She had this bubbly sweet personality, this contagious laugh and was able to play any role. Let's start with the casting shall we? Whomever is in charge of casting for roles, should be fired, like now. The girl chosen to play Britney didn't even resemble her in the slightest. I forgot through out the film that I was watching a bio pic because I couldn't see Britney at all. She sounded more Jersey than anything which Britney didn't and where was that great Britney laugh? The eggs were awful. And I feel they didn't give to much insight in her life. Just all the drama. They made it seem as if she was a D list actress who nobody knew, like she was struggling for roles, when she was in so many great films. Films I grew you loving to watch. How can one forget Riding in cars with boys? Or girl interrupted or Uptown girls so on so forth. They skipped years at a time and you couldn't catch up. If you have not yet seen it I don't recommend it.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Worst movie I have seen in years
Klaaatu6 November 2014
Warning: Spoilers
There are a few issues with this terrible movie - not to mention I won't get that 1+ hour of my life back.

Story -----

The story is so superficial that they completely left out major parts of her life and turning points in her career. The fact that they left out the best role and major turning point of her life (8 Mile) is completely mind boggling.

They literally took a five paragraph news article about her life and death and put it on screen point-by-point like a checklist. There was no real narrative in the movie, including her husband's checkered past as a footnote, which may have been the reason she made a lot of the later decisions of her life.

Actors ------

The main actors were completely miscast and not able to bring us into believing that they were who they were supposed to be. On top of that, they wore the worst wigs ever and every time I looked at their faces all I saw was the bad wigs.

This leads us to the heart of the matter:

Director --------

The director did not have the foresight to see, direct, or prevent any of the above problems. There was no real narrative other than a point form list of things to show in the movie, without some of the major points forgotten.

I realize it can be hard to squeeze a whole life into a TV movie, but they could have spent a lot less time on some of the things they showed in the movie.

This was a by-the-numbers biography that looked like it could have been a documentary re-enactment rather than a true drama.

The fact that they put a footnote at the end about Simon's death, which should have been integral to the story is a crime that no director should ever commit. The fact that he died in the same place and manner as his wife only a few short months later points to the fact that he was heartbroken and possibly afflicted with whatever killed her.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Too Much too soon? ***1/2
edwagreen11 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
While it is true that Ms. Fuller could not compare in looks to the late Brittany Murphy, it is also true that she gave a very memorable performance relating to the late star. As her mother, who wanted freedom for her daughter, Ms. Fenn was also quite good as well as the guy who played the con-artist producer she married.

This is literally examining the familiar theme of too much too soon and how it affects people who achieve stardom very quickly.

The Ashton Kutcher role came off as real heel here. This personality and attitude certainly didn't have him coming off in the best of ways.

Amazing that she kept to herself, was a doting daughter and did not jump out all the way for the Hollywood life. Better off had she remained in New Jersey and had led an ordinary life.
0 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Amazing
michellepowell-4418212 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Great movie. If that is what really happened they let her died. mother and husband should be in jail
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
The joy of bad biography
Reaper28 January 2017
Finally, a Lifetime Original Movie achieves Ed Wood-Tommy Wiseau levels of awfulness. The Brittany Murphy Story isn't merely offensive to Ms Murphy's fans, or to lovers of good biopics; it's awful on any level you can name. This movie features production values lower than you'll find in most home movies, and dialogue pulled from a Victorian melodrama (example, the line "broken hearts strewn on both sides of the Atlantic" -- really!).

Amanda Fuller looks and sounds nothing like Ms Murphy, but that didn't stop the producers from casting her. Sherilyn Fenn answers the obscure question "what happened to the hot girl from Twin Peaks" with a firm "Believe me, you don't want to know." The Simon Monjack character vacillates between deserving a halo, and deserving a long stretch in Leavenworth.

I can't remember having more joy watching a DVD, but then again, I have a strong streak of masochism.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Doesn't capture Brittany Murphy in any way and gives zero insight
juneebuggy13 March 2015
This was pretty terrible, even by Lifetime standards. I think the biggest problem (amongst many) was the girl who played Brittany Murphy (Amanda Fuller). Not only did she looking nothing like Brittany but she doesn't embody her in any way; speech (that cute scratchy voice), mannerisms, hairstyles, or clothing. Just a very dry performance that could have been done by anyone.

Honestly they did a better job casting the Ashton Kutcher lookalike than Brittany, you could at least tell who he was supposed to be. The dude playing Simon Monjack (the husband) was cast well too.

I also never felt like this was "the true story" or that I gained any insight whatsoever into her life, it all just felt like speculation. Her initial rise to stardom was interesting, I guess but it seemed to happen very quickly, almost glazed over with the movie focusing to a lesser degree on her career and more on her relationships with Simon and her mother -who figures prominently throughout.

She meets Simon early on, he's suggested as creepy and even criminal. I actually remember being shocked when I saw pictures of the man she'd married -what was that all about? There are hints of struggles with weight, heart problems, self esteem and paranoia regarding the paparazzi.

Ultimately this doesn't tell an interesting story or capture Brittany in any way. Her death is left a mystery, as is her marriage to Simon and how he also died. 2/24/15
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
It started off okay
ivegonemod23 October 2014
Warning: Spoilers
I thought the movie was okay during the parts set in the 90's. I was enjoying it, but by the time the story got to 2001, the pace really slowed down.

I always liked Brittany Murphy as an actress. I thought she had such a unique presence. She was endearing in Double Jeopardy with Joe Penny.

I think Amanda Fuller put a lot of effort into taking on some of Brittany's quirky mannerisms, and she did a good job on that end. Unfortunately, I don't believe she was right for the role.

Amanda seemed much taller than Brittany, even though they were about two inches apart, and while Brittany may have been bigger earlier on, she became quite slim and stayed that way. Amanda was still pretty large when the movie ended.

They did a good job on casting the role of Ashton. Sherilyn looked downright awful as the mother. The casting for Stacy Dash from Clueless was horrific. It was another case of any black face will do. The girl playing Alicia Silverstone clearly had a big ugly wig on her head.

Overall, I was disappointed.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Biopic on a budget
darmstrong118 October 2014
After reading a lot of the other reviews I was shocked at how mean people were being about the casting. These are real people, makes me a little sick. The casting wasn't great but I thought they did an OK job, Brittany Murphy was a star because she had the talent and looks, those are hard shoes to fill. I thought the lead role was cast well, the woman could act, I didn't need her to pass as a double for her character.

The story was sappy, but hey this is a Lifetime movie, we knew what it was going into this. Let's not pretend we were surprised how this played out.

The movie was OK, I gave it 4 stars. Probably won't ever watch it a 2nd time but it was a decent way to pass some time. Wouldn't mind seeing this story get a real treatment with a real budget.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Infinitely Worse than Lohan as Liz
sandy-34010 September 2014
They've got to be kidding with this actress playing Brittany! She looks NOTHING like her, she's too big and heavy, her face is chubby, her hair is all wrong, her voice - it's just ridiculous! Of all the actors that might have been chosen, why her? Poor Brittany... she would have been so disappointed. I'd just like to know how they got funding for this movie with that girl in the lead role! Brittany was sparkly, funny and bubbly... not to mention her gorgeous looks. This girl sounded like she had a sinus condition, her face was too round and pudgy and she was talking in that hoarse voice trying to emulate someone with whom she had ZERO resemblance. I didn't think anything could be worse than Lindsay Lohan playing Elizabeth Taylor... but, boy, was I wrong! It was just plain laughable when this so-called actress as Brittany in the film was told that she's young and beautiful! She should be embarrassed by this casting decision and her awful performance! I saw her in an interview before the airing of the movie justifying her role, even though she was already aware of the disgust people felt about it.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Do not bother
PippinInOz12 December 2015
I stumbled on this film one day and for about thirty minutes was completely spell bound at just how awful it really was. Serious reviewers have made much of the bad wigs - which should tell you everything you need to know! If you are in the right frame of mind you will belly laugh, which seems a very sad state of affairs when you consider this is supposed to be about a young woman who died much too young.

There is one particular scene which is, frankly, bonkers. A better treatment would be put together by a fifteen year old film student.

Look away ladies and gentlemen - nothing to see here.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Negative 10 Stars.... :-( This movie hurt my heart.
CookieBitz2 March 2017
I could not watch the whole movie, I played some PC games while the movie continued in the background. She looks nothing like Brittany and does not capture a single thing about her. The acting is horrendous, just as bad as the script. I would feel beyond ashamed for having any part in this movie. So sad. :-( I remember watching Brittany in Drop Dead gorgeous, her scenes were the best parts of the entire movie <3 She could play a serious role just as good as that funny role. Save your time (and your heart, mine is still aching from the few minutes I tuned in and out for) and go watch one of her movies instead.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Just a step above awful?
tay-sedai11 December 2015
I did actually manage to watch this whole movie, but it was a painful experience. I saw another review that mentioned how the girl playing Brittany looked nothing like her - she may have had the curly hair that Murphy had during the filming of Clueless, but that was about the extent of it. It was pretty awful to watch.

Having recently seen that fabulous documentary film about Amy Winehouse, I can say that this movie was worlds and worlds apart from the Amy one. Then again, the Amy one was full of actual documentary footage. This one was a really awkward telemovie that shouldn't have ever been produced.

I saw that Murphy's father called it 'trashy' - I couldn't agree more. I think Murphy deserves something much better.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
So, so bad
babaobabe8 September 2020
I accidentally cach this at TV. I am aware it is low budget movie, but this is abomination. Not even gonna talk about how it doesn't have much to do with facts. Or that actress don't have the slightest resemblance with Brittany. But that "acting"... Just horrible. So bad, that is unwatchable.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Low budget Television movie
croutube8 February 2020
This movie is not that bad as most user reviewers write. Its biggest flaw is a very low budget impression. It looks as they spared on every detail, even on number of actors because they repeated the same actors who acted tabloid reporters many times. It seemed weird. Also, they just jumped on her biggest events of her life without any plot, explanation or scenes. Like they wanted to shot everything "in house", to avoid great, complicated scenes. I think that in those circumstances, actors did very good job and their acting is very good. This is obviosly low budget, television movie.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Disgrace
singaporesling7627 November 2015
WTF!!! This movie was beyond bizarre. A travesty. I loved Brittany Murphy in Clueless, The Ramen Girl. She (unlike this 'actress') had talent, perfect timing and star power. It saddens me that they have cheapened her life story and produced a thoughtless, badly researched piece of crap and tried to pass it off as a "movie." An appalling waste of 1 hours and 25 minutes of my life. Sherilynn Fenn I am particularly appalled with you! There is something to be said for movies that add or educate This movie was none of this. An Appalling Mistake. Given I have to do 10 lines I shall repeat. And whats with the 4 minute death scene??
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
the slaughter her she would turn in her grave
lovele-4987518 November 2015
Omg i can't believe they did this to poor Brittany she would roll in her grave very unfortunate they botched her story Amanda fuller the actress imitating Brittany voice was not the best the girl is pretty but looks absolutely nothing like Brittany so way of bass. The like alike for Ashton was pretty good . I'm just so disappointed Brittany deserves much better tribute to her name then the cast and not so great acting. SOME DIRECTOR PLEASE REMAKE HER STORY WITH RESPECT AND decency in memory of Brittany Murphy Amy wine house movie was more better than this when it comes tribute for dead actresses they could of at least put some real photos of her in the end of the movie
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed