"Outlander" The Wedding (TV Episode 2014) Poster

(TV Series)

(2014)

User Reviews

Review this title
19 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
This was by far the most realistic 'lovemaking' scenes I've ever seen. Honest, erotic, sensual and romantic, all at once
banat572 October 2014
Warning: Spoilers
*SPOILER* *SPOILER* *SPOILER* *SPOILER* *SPOILER* *SPOILER*

The episode was filmed in a non-linear structure, so we get the ending first, and through flashbacks we see the start and the middle. I actually loved it. It was nice to have Jamie's point of view, even though it's Jamie telling Claire of what he did to prepare for their wedding. We finally see two strangers get married and while we know and can tell that Jamie is in love with Claire, we know that she's only infatuated by him, but not really in love. She is having a hell of a time accepting the situation. Her guilt is eating her out, and watching Caitriona Balfe play that guilt is fascinating! These are very complex characters in a very complex situation and throughout the episode I focused on their faces as the story developed, and I have to say, sometimes words are not necessary at all. If you have actors of this caliber and know how to use them, the end result is brilliant! Watching Claire's struggle with her feelings for Frank and her growing attraction for Jamie, all in her face? I can't even put into words how sad it made me feel. I was heartbroken for her. The lighting throughout was soft, hazy and then it just got a bit brighter as we unwrapped the bride, which followed with more mood lighting in the church and the bridal chamber. And speaking of the bridal chamber let me say this right up front. I have never, ever seen an erotic scene filmed in such a way that it made my heart stop and flutter. It was pure magic watching two people not have sex but make love. Thanks to Anne Kenney's writing and Anna Foerster's direction, not to mention Sam and Cait's acting, we were able to see and relate to what both of these characters went through on their first night as husband and wife. What starts off as an intimate, yet awkward consummation, by the end of the night turns into a passionate love-making for both. This was so well done that every moment of awkwardness of their first time, sweetness and wonder of his, sadness of her realization that despite loving another man she still enjoyed making love to this one, came across as real. I honestly didn't expect to see a man enjoy his pleasures to the fullest. In the past, it's usually all about the woman, going on about it 'down there' while you don't even see the dude. Here, there were hardly any shots of Claire, while we only saw Jamie reach his 'happy place' and it was glorious! How often have you seen a man's first time so honestly and accurately portrayed? It was downright refreshing to see the vulnerability and honesty of their sensuality. This was by far the most realistic 'lovemaking' scenes I've ever seen. If you watch their faces you'll notice that the camera captured their expressions so beautifully, that at times I felt like a voyeur of a very intimate, private and even sacred ritual.

Claire's internal conflict is written on her face throughout the episode as she struggles to reconcile her feelings of guilt in betraying the man she loves, while being forced to marry a man for her safety and consummate the marriage. You can see all this with barely any dialogue.

As she 'deflowers' him, she feels guilty; second time, she takes the initiative; third time, as he makes her a gift of his mothers pearls, he declares that she's as precious to him as they are, they slowly make love. And we know that this woman has just fallen in love. Suddenly, this kid with no responsibilities but to himself, who's on the run, hiding in the stables, slowly becoming a man and taking the responsibility of a wife. He literally become one as he loses his virginity, and as much as it was awkward for us to watch it, it was much more for him as he's trying to figure it all out and make sure that his wife was well pleased as he was. His facial expression of wonder and joy goes away quickly as he realizes that she may have not liked it as much as he did. But all is well again as they get to trust each other and their second time his wife takes over and teaches him what true pleasure really is. For him, their third coming together was as significant as hers. Giving her the scotch pearls that are so precious to him because it's one thing he has from his mother, and telling her that she's as precious to him, probably wasn't an easy thing to do. He may as well have told her he loves her for crying out loud! Throughout this night, he's the one that is more vulnerable than she is. And he's the one keeps on giving to her all that he has, his name, clan and his family. He offers his body for protection, which is his life, if necessary. Unlike Claire, he holds nothing back. This doesn't go unnoticed by Claire, and that's what brakes her heart and her resolve to 'only do her duty'. She's touched by Jamie's recollection of every second of their wedding, comparing her to the sun coming out after the cloudy day. And here we thought women are romantic! He continually goes out of his way to make her feel safe, and she in the end accepts everything he offers and gives as good as she gets. Well, that is until the morning after she accidentally finds her 'other' wedding band and holy crap but that face just broke my heart. Besides the dress, which was stunning, kudos to Terry Dresbach; music was as sensual as was their love making, thanks to Bear McCreary; the direction, acting, lighting it is all brilliant.
65 out of 70 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Starz Delivers the Wedding and Much More
VickiHopkins21 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
The Scottish referendum to depart from the United Kingdom did not pass on Thursday, September 18, 2014. However, millions of women passed out on Saturday, September 20, while watching Outlander, Episode No. 7, The Wedding.

Fainting episodes, heart palpitations, and profuse sweating can be attributed to Jamie Alexander Malcom MacKenzie Fraser. The marriage was consummated (multiple times), and Starz made sure to give its audience what they wanted. They did warn viewers with "N=Nudity" and nudity we got.

It was a great episode, only put together a little oddly. Rather than making it sequential, it bounced back and forth from here to there, which I found a bit unsettling. Nevertheless, it starts with Claire and Frank deciding to wed in the spur of the moment, and Claire admits that after a while you forget your life in the past. Whether she truly does is another matter, because Frank's ring only comes off her finger and stuffed down her bulging bosom just before she weds Jamie.

The wedding scene starts with the kiss after pronouncement of husband and wife, making you wonder if you were late for the wedding. It quickly moves to Claire and Jamie alone with one task looming ahead of them -- the consummation. However, instead, it turns into hours of sharing, drinking, and talking, flashing back and forth between scenes. Jamie tells Claire about his family, expounds stories, and admits he married her to keep her safe from Randall. His chivalrous confession of promising to protect her with his body as well is endearing.

Everyone downstairs is enjoying the drunken reception of booze and food, along with a cat nibbling at the table leftovers. The purpose for the crowd hanging around is to await word the bride and groom have done the deed. Rupert and Angus burst into the room at Dougal's orders at one point hoping to witness something. Nothing's up yet, so Jamie kicks them out.

Claire appears extremely nervous and out of sorts in many scenes. Their time together is awkward at first. Jamie finally kisses her and tender moments of undressing one another occur. Well, after another kiss, Jamie loses it and sort of attacks her body from behind, but she turns him around and he ends up on top of her in bed. It doesn't take long to lose his virginity, but Claire doesn't look like she's really enjoying the experience while he enjoys his first time with a woman. Afterward, he asks her if she liked it, but she doesn't say anything. He just figures, like the men told him beforehand, that women don't care for it. He admits that he thought it was always done from behind like horses do it, and Claire has a good laugh.

As the evening progresses, it's more flashbacks that include Jamie's conditions for marrying Claire, which included: (1) a church wedding by a priest; (2) a wedding band; and (3) Claire must have a wedding dress. Obtaining each of those items were lighthearted moments as to how they came about. As they recall the wedding together, Jamie and Claire tell each other how they felt. The conversation is used for viewers to finally see the wedding itself. Jamie is extremely handsome in his full Scottish regalia, and Claire is beautiful in her wedding gown.

The wedding vows are touching, but it's not without blood as Dougal slits their wrists, binds them together, and their blood mingles. Those romantic words are spoken by Jamie and Claire: 'Ye are Blood of my Blood, and Bone of my Bone. I give ye my Body, that we Two might be One. I give ye my Spirit, 'til our Life shall be Done.'" The remainder of the episode focuses on the lovemaking between Jamie and Claire. She finally relents to her situation and her shy nervousness dissolves. Her boldness with Jamie teaches him a few tricks, as she pleases him in ways he never dreamed.

The episode ends with Claire the next morning picking up her wedding dress and Frank's ring falling to the floor from the bodice where she shoved it before the wedding. It rolls across the floor, falls into a crack, and Claire picks it up and places it back on her finger on her right hand. She then looks at both of her hands and the two rings declare she belongs to two different men. It's quite the thought-provoking ending.

I dare not give this episode anything but a ten, even though it bounced back and forth in timeline.
36 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Jamie and Claire get married and Claire tries to reconcile her two husbands and two lives.
karencbooth20 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
* * * SPOILERS AHEAD * * *

'Wedding Day' is the penultimate episode of Outlander's first half-season, and heads (and loins) are surely exploding across the Outlander-landscape, as Jamie (Sam Heughan) and Claire (Caitriona Balfe) get their first crack at marital relations after a hasty wedding ceremony. This is, in fact, as fine an hour of rich storytelling as we've had all season. Director Anne Kenney suffuses much of the hour with a heavy sense of melancholy, as Claire gamely tries to reconcile her old life with her new one. Even as she sits in a wedding shift not of her choosing, with a new husband who is a stranger, she knows the details of her old life are beginning to slip away.

Truth be told, tonight's wedding seems quite leisurely compared with Claire's wedding to Frank — that one being the definition of impromptu, with the couple ducking into the wedding registrar's office on their way to dinner after just a minute's discussion. Claire and Jamie's wedding narrative is wisely told out of sequence, beginning abruptly with the kiss at the end of an unseen ceremony. It's startling, but very effective, and the lead-up to that kiss is told over the next hour in flashback while the hours tick by. It also teases out two big reveals: the wedding dress, which is spectacular, and the *ahem* good times that eventually get underway. Hang onto your kilts, more about that later.

The production design tonight is terrific, both for what is there and what isn't. The brief 1940s sequence, which opens the episode, is almost colorless. Even Claire's suit and hat are a pale dove gray, adding to a general feeling that this time is not where her future lies. The 18th century scenes are shot mostly by candlelight; every scene aglow with warm colors that reflect the Scottish landscape. Combined with Bear McCreary's wistful violin score, the effect is deeply beautiful.

But the look on Claire's face as she pulls away from Jamie after their kiss tells a different story. Despite the gallant gesture Jamie has made to protect her, and the beauty at hand, this is a hell of a weird thing that's happening. It turns out that she hit the whiskey pretty hard the night before, and had to be pulled together rather unwillingly by a small army of clan members. She doesn't even know this "lad," and she blurts out despairingly, "I can't marry you, I don't even know your real name!" when they stand before the priest. For his part, Jamie needs a fair bit of convincing himself. He agrees to the wedding, of course, and several clansmen are dispatched to meet his wedding demands: Ned (Bill Paterson) is sent to a brothel to find a dress — which is hilarious — and Angus (Stephen Walters) and Rupert (Grant O'Rourke) head to the local blacksmith to have Claire's wedding ring made from a key. Murtagh (Duncan Lacroix) is sent out to track down a Fraser plaid for Jamie, and almost gets sentimental for a moment in the stable, allowing that Claire's smile is as sweet as Jamie's mother's once was.

Back in the post-ceremony wedding suite, Claire and Jamie are awkward with each other, and the pressure to consummate the marriage hangs heavily in the room. When they finally get to it … well, it's quick and clothed and not terribly satisfying. "That's it?!" scream the Outlander masses across the land. Ned's contract is technically fulfilled, true. But there's more whiskey to be had, and more conversation into the wee hours. Heughan and Balfe have genuine chemistry, and are inhabiting their characters fully here, as they begin to laugh and let down their guard. The true (emotional) consummation of the marriage is sexy, poignant and very intimate. It will replay on many a DVR in the weeks to come, I have no doubt.

Beyond the sex, there's something interesting going on here. Instead of indulging a romance- novel trope of the gallant man sweeping his new bride off her feet, we see a modern woman taking the sexual reigns on her wedding night, showing the ropes to her virgin groom. This subtext of a strong female character taking charge, even when circumstances have her at a disadvantage, is consistently well played in Outlander. It's one of the reasons why so many women have loved the Outlander books since the first one debuted in 1991, and why the show continues to gain ratings traction.

Captain Randall (Tobias Menzies) may be placated for the time being, but Dougal (Graham McTavish) slinks around at the last minute, menacing Claire with his unwanted attentions. Claire may have gained a handsome young husband with excellent bone structure, but danger is never far away in this strange land. In the early light of the next morning, her first wedding ring shakes loose from her wedding dress, where she had tucked it away before her wedding to Jamie. The final shot of 'Wedding Day' is of Claire's outstretched hands -- each wearing a ring from two different husbands --  her face shattered. As with previous episodes, there is much to watch and rewatch here (aside from the obvious) -- nuanced performances, and exquisite attention to period detail. This is great television, ye ken?

Also published at www.geeksunleashed.me
34 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Mesmerizing
lluca-4774821 May 2020
An episode which is the peak of the chemistry between the 2 lead actors. Also, best love scenes on any screen, perfectly integrated in the sophisticated story. Acting was amazing.
23 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Wedding to Drool Over
brizosdream29 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
I've watched the whole series now, and I can honestly say I love the wedding episode the best. It's not without flaws but overall they did a wonderful job with the wedding and the wedding night sex scenes between Jamie and Claire. Sam Heughan and Caitriona Balfe are just perfect for their roles, both are gorgeous to look at and they act just as I would expect Claire and Jamie to act. Sam with his perfectly muscular body, those wonderful expressive eyes and mouth is my male image of a perfectly gorgeous man. Caitriona, besides being exceptionally beautiful, her smile is contagious, and when she looks at Sam, there is this chemistry between them that is electrifying.

The wedding night was some of the most seductive sexually romantic scenes I've seen on TV in a long time. This part was I'm sure very hard to act in front of a camera crew and stage hands, but they both did it like no one was in the room but them. This is a real tribute to their extraordinary acting skills and should keep all those fans very happy rerunning it for the 6 month hiatus the show will be on.

The actual wedding was shown to us in a mired of flashbacks. Perhaps too many flashbacks as others have noted. I would tend to agree here. The actual wedding with Jamie coming out of the church viewing his potential bride who was incrementally lit with sunlight as he describes his feelings seeing her for the first time. Then there is Jamie dressed to the hilt looking the most gorgeous specimen of Scottish manhood. Who could resist, even Claire with her before wedding doubts succumbs to his charm with a big kiss at the end of the ceremony. The speech in Gaelic "Blood of my Blood.. " right from Diana Gabaldon is such a wonderful part of the wedding ceremony.

As good as this segment was it was missing some of the important lines from the book that gave meaning to some of the scenes and might have explained the shortness of the first sexual encounter. When Jamie is talking about what the lads had told him the night before the wedding they left out the most important line – "that they had told him to finish quickly as women generally do not like it" and Claire's response to that "the slower the better for most women". Also there was less of Claire showing Jamie how to please her as the night progresses. In the TV version he seems to learn all this by osmosis.

Scenes I just loved: Jamie and Claire undressing each other, Claire on her toes kissing him, Jamie picking Claire up and carrying her to the bed, Jamie giving Claire his mother's pearls, the sunlight on Claire's wedding dress

Scenes I liked: Murtagh's talk with Jamie, Dougal making a pass at Claire on her wedding night

Scenes I didn't like: the whole priest thing, Claire and Frank in front of the registry office, Angus and Rupert crashing into the wedding chamber, Ned in the brothel.

Overall, however different it was from the book, because of the Jamie and Claire scenes in this episode I thought it was the best of the episodes we've received from the TV series to date. I hope they continue with this romance in future episodes.
25 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
It was good if you didn't know the book version which was better!
mcampbelljh121 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
So how was it? I guess that depends on whether or not you've read the book version or not. As one of the 25 million who have, I'd say this was a great episode one of the best in the series so far; however it was also one of the best parts of the 1st book so a high bar has been set. Honestly, it was great seeing the wedding night on screen. I thought the acting by Sam and Caitriona was fabulously sensitive, seductive and very well acted. As a book reader however, I thought the script lacked many things I thought was important to the story. I don't know why the screen writers think that they can write lines better than Diana Gabaldon (they can't). They missed important lines and nuances that the book had in it and seemed to make scene changes for no good reason.

The changes the screen-writers made to the original story turned the wedding night scene into a series of flashbacks. I have to ask why this approach? I guess to break up the sex scenes into 3 separate scenes instead of one long one. But does that format work? I have to say not as well as the book's version. In the book they make love 3 times in one night; each time it builds increasing on the passion they feel as Jamie (a virgin) learns more and more about love making from Claire. It all happens in one scene, where they are becoming more intimate with each other as the scene progresses. The flashback version breaks this up and loses that aspect of the wedding night. So although I did love the sex scenes in the show honestly listening to the audio book was better.

The flashbacks broke up the entire wedding and they missed quite a lot of things the book had that makes a difference to the way the viewer understands the story. Below are some examples of the scenes from the book that were either changed or omitted.

1. Walking to the church, Claire realized it was the same church she had married Frank in 200 years later; Instead of this church scene they have a flashback scene of Claire and Frank in front of a registry office (why a registry office and not the church?).

2. When Jamie and Claire are talking on the wedding night and she asks him why he married her. In the book Jamie said "Before I tell you Claire there is one thing I ask of you … honesty and I'll promise you that as well, We have nothing now between us save respect perhaps and I think that respect has room for secretes but not for lies. Do you agree? And she agrees". This is very important speech in the book that was totally omitted from the screen version. That speech sets up the basis for Jamie and Claire's relationship in their marriage and has implications further on in the book

3. When they are making love Jamie asks her "Did you like it?" She says "yes". Then he says "Murtagh had told me that women generally do not care for it so I should finish as soon as I could" and Claire says "What would Murtagh know about it, for most women the slower the better". Or when Jamie thinks he's hurting Claire. The script-writers left out the part where Claire explains that women have orgasms too and that's why she's groaning, not in pain but in ecstasy. These are really important lines showing how Claire helps Jamie on that night to becoming a better lover and it also helps to explain why the 1st time was such a quickie. Breaking that whole night up into a mired of flashbacks in my opinion was a mistake.

4. In this episode they have Rupert and Angus going out to buy a ring for Claire. In the book Rupert forgets to get a wedding ring and Jamie takes his father's "ruby ring" off his hand and gives it to Claire to use as her wedding ring. He then promises to get her one as soon as possible. Why is this important? Well, further down the road there is a big scene in the book when Jamie goes out to get that special wedding ring for Claire. So what do they plan on doing down the road cut another great scenes from the book.

5. Then we have Rupert and Angus charging into the honeymoon room to see if the marriage had been consummated making some ridiculous gestures to Jamie about it. The book has a rather tender scene where Jamie tells Claire that the wedding would not be legally binding until they consummated the marriage. So instead of seeing a touching scene with Jamie and Claire we get this clown scene with Rupert and Angus.

Don't tell me they did this because of time, I don't buy that. They added new scenes that would take way longer. Did we really need seeing Ned buy the wedding dress in a whore house? Sure we get a few more flashes of bare breasted women but totally unnecessary to the wedding preparations. There were many more instances I couldn't fit in this review but the bottom line is yes, I loved the wedding episode but I also feel if they had followed the book's version it could have been better.
25 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Don't compare book to TV ....
MazzyMayhem-117-5445113 December 2021
Ok, we all know the written word, and certainly Diana Gabaldon's, cannot be beaten. However, this episode is beautiful. Tender, loving, sweet. I have watched it three times now - love it 💕💕
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Outstanding!
mmelendez-2484322 February 2019
Best show out there for sure, nothing else compares to it! I can't wait for season 5, until then I'll start watching it from the beginning. I can't get enough of the characters Claire and Jamie.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Beautiful and moving
floranocturna4 December 2020
This has to be my favourite episode from the first season so far. The wedding of Jamie and Claire was excellently handled, different from the book, but the flashback-style worked really well. The chemistry between Jamie and Claire was amazing and one could feel the sizzling in the air and Claire's blooming feeling for her new husband but also her feelings of guilt over her former-but-somehow-still husband Frank.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
WOW!! Claire and Jamie...just beautiful
birdsonthings11 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Banat57 wrote the BEST review of this episode. I DO NOT understand the negative reviews for this episode. I absolutely LOVED it. From the first time Jamie and Claire met when he had to share his horse and covered her in his plaid kilt because she was shivering cold, I knew they'd eventually become a couple. At least I hoped so from episode 1. They are my favorite TV couple of all time. That's even including all the great couples from Game of Thrones.

I'm blown away at how intense and beautiful this episode developed. As the episode starts, I found myself thinking, well this episode is the typical boring first time sex scene. Because Jamie was kind of one and done and their first love making was very awkward. Also, there wasn't much revealed of the wedding scene.

But as it progresses, MY GOD. The chemistry, their slow build up of romance, Jamie's sweetness and sincerity, the music, Claire's guilt, the eventual total giving of both characters. It was amazing. Just too beautiful to describe. All this made everything seem believable, that they loved each other from the first time they met. It was also so sweet how Jamie recalled every moment from their wedding. And he's a virgin?!!! Yes!!!!!! How insanely lucky was Claire?! Jamie is smoking hot, as well as such an amazing gentleman despite his drop dead looks. The story development was amazing.

I love this episode. It's the epitome of true romance. I don't care what any negative reviews say. I absolutely absolutely LOVED it. Will be watching it a few more times. :)
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
1x07 review
jackDee-5656514 October 2020
This was a greatepisode , the chemistry was fantastic between Claire and jamie , the only downside was the story didn't really progress except the wedding really
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Very boring.
jeroen-10620 November 2023
So far I can appreciate the show, but this episode was a stinker. Drawn out scenes with soft erotic content that was boring to watch. Nothing really happens except establishing a new relationship between Claire and what's-his-name. And obviously a stronger bond with the clan. But there was zero story progression or character development. At least not in relation to the running time.

Perhaps this show is more directed towards women who read a romantic novel they purchased at the airport? I'm not sure what it was trying to do.

Anyway, hoping for more and I'm happy to forget this waste of time episode.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Houston, we have a problem
ivaaanmgh2 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
There is a thing... when Dougal and Claire are coming back to the group at the final of episode 6, Dougal says Claire to marry Jaimie, and Claire asks Dougal if he talked this with the lawyer and he said yes, it's all ready for the marriage. And recently Randall ordered Claire to see him again. So, when in this episode Jaimie remembers when they agreed the marriage, the lawyer already knew Randall ordered Claire to see him again... How??? If the marriage when Claire and Dougal were going back to the group was already agreed? Unless Dougal was a witcher and he already knew what Randall was gonna do with Claire or simply he lied to Claire... The rest of the chapter was good, it's just I wanna get out of doubt. Or is it me or is that series' mistak, uhm
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Extreme Awkwardness! Longest hour I've ever experienced watching a show
nlytnd_112 June 2021
This may have been the longest hour that I've ever experienced watching a TV show before and all I could figure it's because this episode leaves the viewer in a perpetual state of extreme awkwardness throughout 90% of it. As a result, time moves similarly as if you were to place your hand on a hot stove for 51 minutes

I'm not exaggerating... I'm flabbergasted that the episode is only around 51 minutes, because it felt like 3-4 hours.
8 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
If there was a 0 star i would gave it to this episode.
najimoumou17 March 2022
If there was a 0 star i would gave it to this episode. Empty and boring episode. Very long adult scenes which doesn't make any sense.. 1h full hour of awkwardness. ZERO.
6 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Boring!
UzeyirSiy12 May 2020
The most boring thing I've ever watched in my life
13 out of 61 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Finally! A women's romance for men!
lorasadtomato8 April 2020
Jesus. After all the eye-rolling, the laughing AT the writing/direction, the whisper-screaming at the screen "really?!", it was finally this horrendous episode that had me quit for good. I read the books with almost the same reaction, so it's not entirely the screenwriting/direction's fault- in a sense, it's pretty impressive that they were able to capture so much of what the book accomplished. ALSO I will happily admit that the team's ability to visually recreate the scenes was truly impressive. I repeatedly recognized rooms I'd only read about before, which I don't remember happening to me so much in any other films from books I'd read. BUT-- the first sex scene was easily the worst male-gazed bastardization of what could have been an awesome scene I've ever seen. The show has been thus far awful with regard to being so ridiculously male (only a problem when you're knowingly writing for an audience of women), and the first sex scene was no exception. I won't go into it much, but suffice it to say that 30 seconds of our almost fully covered hero unfeelingly jabbing at what we are to guess is a falls below the standard of a great sex scene BY ITSELF. But then to follow that up with the woman who received that short, orgasm-less treatment with almost no pre-or post-stimulation professing to have LIKED IT was maddening.. I just.. Come on. ((Side, but just as angry note: There was more time spent on the old lawyer in the brothel scene than on the scene that's been built up to for the entire series! There was (or at least felt like) ten times more time spent on the unnecessarily gruesome lashing scenes than on the sex scenes! Who TF is this for??)) Regardless of what these poor women who rated this episode 10 stars consider to be a good, erotic, sensual, romantic, etc. sex scene, the standard should be much higher. And, if possible (spoiler alert: it's possible), it should not be so baldly, laughably written and filmed through the lens of men- as it's a show with a predominantly female audience. Okay, I'm done- I really needed to get that out. Thank you, anonymous audience.
8 out of 57 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Took Claire 7 episodes to cheat on her husband......trash show
Belnick23 May 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Claire wait for her husband thru the entire "#¤"¤ war!! the war! world war 2..... 1 episode see her getting comfortable with her husband again, the sex is starting to flow again as husband and wife and then she is swept away, 6 episodes after she have sex with another man..... Why did Claire not wait 10 seasons? or at least 5 seasons before betraying her husband?

This show is most likely from some liberal trash author/writers that think cheating in marriage is empowering lol 6 episodes, that is how long it took for her before getting impregnated by another man, she did not try to get home for 5 years....she was way to horny and wanted sex........which is weird considering her 5-10 year abstinence during the world war 2. This is why every other episode after season 1 episode 07 are null and void....a shame, production value seem ok and acting ok, but Claire is a like 16 year old teen that just think about sex,it is so ridicules considering she was born in the 1920s....... had she wanted to sleep with any guy for lets say 3 full seasons? then I would get it, she had worked for 3 years to get back home and now felt it was impossible and decided to remarry......but 6 episodes ??? that is nonsense, there were trashy girls back then ofc, but they were not as common as today and claire was not written as such a girl in the start....she waited so many years for her husband and then they just "#"#" her character and she gets impregnated by her not husband by getting "married" to husband number 2 These cuckold stories in hollywood is getting more and more common
10 out of 85 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Cheating is never Ok
althafahh11 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I hate this show its all the same old drama where wife /gf instant got connection with someone and had affair and everyone call her victim the writer's and director's just throw time travelling, fantasy, politics,Ghost, period time, future whatever plot is they want to throw some other bs in story to make affair as good as possible, lol. Especially in this series o my God it's all like women don't do anything wrong the lead actress is right on everything if we show her first husband as good day then we can't portray her affair as romantic so we directors and writers have to make him abusive AH so then the affair and Claire treatment to her first husband after coming back will be seen or shown as justified.

Lame propaganda show.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed