"Outlander" The Gathering (TV Episode 2014) Poster

(TV Series)

(2014)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Over the Rainbow Packed Episode
VickiHopkins31 August 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Episode four, The Gathering, is filled with fine-looking Highlanders swearing their allegiance to the clan MacKenzie at Castle Leoch. Our laird is looking a tad handsome with his hair pulled back and dressed in his finest, along with the rest of the male attendees in kilts. Once again it is an outstanding episode filled with so much that I can barely take notes fast enough to remember all the fine tidbits. Humor abounds in much of the episode, but it is toned with moments of pain and death.

It begins with Claire running through the woods appearing as if she's escaping, when in reality she's playing with a group of children scoping out the territory outside the castle grounds. She falls on her back and ends up looking up the kilt of Angus Mhor. He straddles above her head and peers down and says, "Something catch your eye there, lass?" The camera looks right up the kilt, but it's too dark to see! It is the first of many lighthearted comments coming from a group of rutting men looking to "settle their cock to roost for the night." Claire spends the majority of this episode planning her escape. Geillis visits Claire obviously aware that she is preparing and warns her that she would do well to remember that the Highlands can be a dangerous place. Undeterred by the warning, Claire continues but meets multiple obstacles during the evening.

When Mrs. Fitzgibbons dresses and drags her to the festivities of "The Gathering," she passes by Diana Gabaldon in her cameo role, who sputters a few words in such a thick Scottish accent that I didn't understand a word she said. The men begin their pledges and once again the laird speaks Gaelic and Murtagh translates for Claire. You've seen one pledge, you've seen them all, so Claire leaves. She gives a spiked bottle of port to her tag-along, a bottle of horse dung to Leary to win Jamie's heart, wallops Dougal over the head with a stool, and stumbles and falls upon Jamie in the stables during her grand escape gone wrong.

Finally, she gives up at Jamie's urging and returns to the castle to watch the remaining pledges, including Jamie's non-pledge to the Laird, but his sworn obedience. (All sorts of back story on that scene, so if you need more read the book or watch the episode.) Things are friendly between Claire and Jamie, and the smoldering looks are far and few between this episode.

The next day Claire rides out with the men who are in her words out to "kill a hairy pig," which turns into a near-death experience for her and a disaster for two men. One of the men, Jody, is ripped to pieces by a boar and lies dying in Dougal's arms. It's a very intense and moving scene, where Dougal sees a part of Claire that leaves a positive impression. She lets her skills as a nurse comfort a man facing death.

After the emotional scene, Dougal returns with his men and comes upon a group playing a rather rough game of stick ball apparently called "shinty." Obviously, looking for a way to let go of his pent-up emotions, he grabs a stick and joins in the game. It's a testosterone filled, stick-wielding competition that looks more like a brawl. While watching the colliding sticks and flying bodies around the turf, you can see the obvious tension between Dougal and Jamie behind each whack and jab between the two. I won't tell you who won that battle, only to say that it didn't sit well with Dougal that he had taught Jamie how to play the game so well.

The episode ends with Dougal approaching Claire the next day stating as a matter of fact, which she doesn't deny, that she has seen men die before from violence. He thanks her for helping him take Jody to a peaceful place, but then tells her she is leaving with him in the morning to travel the countryside collecting rents from the tenants. Claire sees it as another opportunity to find the right moment to flee back to the future.

The only very odd thing about this intense episode is that the background music in places is from the 1940's big band. At first, I thought I was hearing things, but it sounded terribly out of place. It came at portions while Claire was thinking of her life in 1943, but walking through the castle. The sound track wasn't exactly my cup of tea with modern tunes playing in a 1743 backdrop.

As someone who has only partially read and skimmed much of Outlander, I don't find very much to balk about as far as the show not closely following the book. I am not that emotionally involved in the story as some fans (gasp) but am enjoying the television version nonetheless. Starz is taking some creative liberty with the story, such as the ball-whacking game in tonight's episode. In an interview with Yahoo TV, Ronald Moore stated, "I wanted to realize the book, not change the book. But it is not a democracy. It is a piece of art...sometimes that means adding scenes or cutting and tweaking them." In conclusion...well done.

Most tender moment: Comforting the dying man.

Most humorous statement: Claire to Leary. "Tap your heels three times and say there's no place like love..." Or words something to that effect, after giving Leary instructions to sprinkle the horse dung in a love potion incantation to gain Jamie's heart.

Most disturbing moment: Blood and gore from the boar hunt.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
1x04 review
jackDee-5656514 October 2020
Outlander 4th episode was a good episode building from the previous episodes, this season is quite impressive
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Our Heroes Thankfully Hit the Road
jmansmannstjohnslrev26 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I have to say, I was very happy at the conclusion of the episode when Dougal announced that Claire would be joining him on his trip to collect the rents. While the set design at Castle Leoch was certainly impressive, the monotony of castle life was beginning to permeate and was evident in The Gathering.

I hate to complain about the episode too much, there were some interesting tidbits, the gathering ceremony itself, Jaime's navigation of his warring Uncle's desires for the future of the clan, Claire's meticulous planning and cleverness in seeking an escape, Gellis Duncan's "friendship" with Claire and her curiosity regarding Claire's background. Yet while the episode produced some nice moments, it lacked any moments that will stick with you in the long run, that you will look back on at the end of the season as a defining moment in itself. Rather, this episode largely set up plot lines for future episodes.

In terms of the negative, Claire is almost violated for the second time in four episodes, and in this episode, it seems somewhat unnecessary to have it happen. The incident with Dougal is seemingly forgotten at the end of the episode and contradicts Dougal's previous statement in episode 1 that he doesn't hold with rape. While I know an incident like this was taken from the books, it just didn't make much sense and didn't really do anything to further the story. This was indicative of a major problem in season 1, wherein it seemed that Claire was almost raped in every other episode, to the point where it was happening so often it began to lose its desired effect. There was no need for it here.

Another problem with this episode that rears its head again in later seasons is that the episode struggled with Jaime and Claire being largely absent on the screen together. Episodes 2 and 3 were largely compelling because of the interaction between Claire and Jaime. With them separated for most of Episode 4, and with Claire having little connections with other characters at this point in the series, there was far too much narration.

But thankfully, our protagonists hit the road for a much needed adventure outside of the castle walls.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent Show, and Keeps Getting Better!
Lallybrochlaura3 September 2014
Having now watched the first four episodes multiple times, this is the strongest episode so far. The production quality continues to astonish, and the acting is superb. In Episode 104, "The Gathering," we see Claire and Jamie each come into their own strengths as they grapple with challenging circumstances. Caitriona Balfe as Claire is magnificent, and Sam Heughan as Jamie is a phenomenon. Both are giving star-making turns in Outlander, and the material is giving them plenty to work with. A stellar supporting cast and historically-rich sets, locations, and costumes makes this series fascinating to watch - and each show worth multiple views. Highly recommended to those enjoying historical and political drama, action-adventure, and stories of love and family.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Superb
lluca-4774824 May 2020
Superbly achieved and acted. Now it becomes addictive. Claire's role is gorgeous and well defined. I am glad she didnt make it back to Frank.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Everyone is a bumbling nincompoop compared to Claire
theflamingeagle28 June 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This episode solidified a distinctly unsavory tone for our heroine. Apparently the writers are trying to make Claire into a kind of superwoman who is beyond humbling. Even her follies - or should I say folly - are cast in such a way to make her appear more irreproachable. In a scene where the object of her new infidelity is seen kissing another girl, Claire writes off her embarrassment not as jealousy of the woman - after all how could someone as noble and inerrant as she be jealous of a such a ridiculous girl - but of their intimacy that she can't share with her temporally displaced husband. Yeah, who are you kidding, dear?

For a prisoner she is unaccountably taken seriously. Any of her guards or "hosts" will unaccountably snap to her attention even though she speaks in a barely audible hush. Later, during a boar hunt, she writes off the threat posed by a boar, which she terms a simple "Hairy Pig." When it goes onto kill one and maim another, she scrambles to save face by accusing them of not taking the threat of the boar or their lethal tusks seriously. Later still, she mocks the beliefs of the native Scots as ignorant and infantile even though she herself was just teleported through a rock to get where she was in the first place.

Then we have the new love interest. He has apparent telekinetic abilities, able to detect Claire's plot to leave as well as a plot to have him killed. The way he gets out of it is inventive, if not implausible.

This episode gets its four stars based on the death scene and the costumes alone which help one to forget, much like the stash of the borderline alcoholic, nymphomanic protagonists stash of port wine.
6 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
not bad but...
eulchen510 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
well, I have read the books about 15 years ago and prior to watching the first season of this I re-read the first book again. Let me first say they didn't do terrible with the TV show, but I also think they didn't do really good. I do have a problem with some details, like, why is Jamie clean shaven most of the time, even when they are out in the wild for days?

And as for this episode in particular, I really have trouble seeing the chosen actor playing Dougal McKenzie. Sorry, but the books clearly stated a rather dark man, especially described with "long russet hair". In this episode we have this scene where Dougal, himself rather drunk, first rescues Claire from other drunken Highlanders trying to assault her. Then Dougal himself makes an attempt on Claire, and in the book this scene is very intense because he lets go of her and tells her she should run off before she has to pay a higher price. This scene was intense in the books because it left the tension of both characters until Claire left the scene, and it showed that Dougal could have done something he decided he wouldn't do, and it in the book it showed Claire that she indeed is at the very mercy of these men.

So why on earth did the writers of the TV show decide to change that scene in yet another unrealistic superhero-scene for Claire, when, unnecessarily, she takes up some wooden stool and beats someone like Dougal McKenzie unconscious? What was that about? Why? It left him look like an idiot. A tall Highlander, experienced in close combat in any situation, and because he is a little drunk he easily gets beaten over the head by a small, petite woman? No way.

It's the same by the way with the actor who plays Murtagh. Good actor, no question, but absolutely not the Murtagh described in the books. The book character is rather old, small, slim and wiry, not a rather tall, strong, goodlooking guy like the actor they chose. Why?

So,sorry, but I just can't get my head around why they picked a bald actor for playing Dougal and, quite often in the TV show now, why they changed certain scenes unnecessarily like here.
5 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed