"Extant" Extinct (TV Episode 2014) Poster

(TV Series)

(2014)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
The plot has twists and turns but does not make sense
jackdmenendez10 April 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Contains some spoilers: This show has potential and I wanted to give it more stars; I really did, but I couldn't even though the show is very watchable and can be entertaining, it is also stupid. The plot, as long as you don't think about it, contains some twists and turns that are exciting. We do care about the characters and the writers are trying to explore some interesting ideas about the future. Unfortunately, there is a big problem. To understand the problems first understand that the show has two major themes. One theme is beautiful humanoid robots, Humanics have been created by humanity and the show explores their potential for good and bad depending on how they are used or misused. The story around the robots can be cloying at times, but it is not a show stopper. The other major theme is an Alien invasion. There are gaping problems with this theme.

So this is the spoiler: the aliens spread kind of like a virus through sexually transmitted spores that create alien babies who grow up in a matter of a few weeks or months and infect others. The sexual transmission takes place in single's bars through one-night stands. The viral spread of these aliens is understood by the military who are keeping the existence of the aliens a secret. Yes, this is disturbingly contrived given the powers and knowledge of the aliens, they could easily figure out a way to spread themselves in a more efficient way than picking up women in bars, but then where is the fun in that? The bigger problem is that the military and major characters spend all their time trying to hunt down and kill the one original alien, who happens to be Molly's (Berry) son when they know there are already tons of other aliens around happily spreading the alien spores through sexual exploits. That's like trying to cure a cold by killing just one virus when there are billions already infecting your body. Maybe there is a good reason to go after the original alien but, the main characters and the military don't know that and yet they concentrate on killing this one alien with drone strikes and everything else in their arsenal as if that will cure the Earth. The aliens are clearly highly intelligent, but no one tries to talk to them; it's more like hunting zombies with glowing eyes than dealing with aliens; stupid.

It's too bad, because of the potential here. Lot's of science fiction has been written about aliens who spread like a virus through human hosts and they are all better than this idea. For example, there is "The Alien", and this show kind of rips that idea off with exploding wombs. There are Christopher Rowley's novels about the Vang, which make the Alien seem pretty friendly and simplistic. This TV show though does not even try to make the Aliens and their biology interesting or imaginative.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Why is evolution explained wrongly ?
yishai_n25 July 2014
Warning: Spoilers
In season one episode two, an attempt at explaining evolution was made.

Evolution is NOT "the strongest species survives and the weaker species goes extinct" as the robot in the evolution exhibit explained. Evolution is the survival of the FITTEST! and 'fittest' does not always mean strongest. The Neanderthals were stronger and may have even been smarter (larger brains) then the Homo Sapiens and the reason for there extinction is not as explained. Is it so hard to get a evolutionary biologist to advise on a show about evolution and extinction.

Regardless of that, I must say I am loving the series so far. I hope it runs its course and doesn't get canceled as so many science fiction series are canceled lately.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed