Ian offers to bake cookies with Graham, but Graham is uninterested. Ian decides to instill holiday cheer in Graham. Mike has to work on Christmas Eve when he and Annie already had plans for the night. Eve wants to celebrate Hanukkah.
As a snowstorm threatens Mike (Michael J. Fox) and Annie's (Betsy Brandt) annual Christmas gift competition, Ian (Conor Romero) worries that his parents have given up on making the holiday magical for Graham (Jack Gore), and Eve (Juliette Goglia) decides she'd rather be Jewish.—Anonymous