"Downton Abbey" Episode #5.1 (TV Episode 2014) Poster

(TV Series)

(2014)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
As we return to the Abbey, as usual drama awaits behind every door, in every field, and mischief is constantly on the mind.
Amari-Sali27 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Bless the existence of the internet for otherwise I would have to wait who knows how many months for this to come to America. Of which I refuse to wait for since while I'm not the hugest fan of period dramas, Downton Abbey is an exception. For with its sarcasm, wit, and a bit of naughtiness, I find myself enjoying English aristocracy. Though, like many I'm sure, I mostly watch for Maggie Smith.

Topic 1: Times are Changing - Daisy

As the years go by on Downton Abbey so does the culture of England change, of which those upstairs and downstairs either greet it with welcoming arms or turn their nose up. Though of all those uncomfortable, or loving change, Daisy is perhaps the one person who really is trying to not let the times change her, but her change with the times. For with life working under Ms. Patmore becoming less and less likable, she is starting to think about the farm that is left to her and how can she manage it? Leading to her buying a few books to brush up on her studies. Something which largely isn't approved of nor understood.

Topic 2: A Person's Secrets – Edith and Ms. Baxter

With Edith's Marigold safe in the home of Tim Drewe, and her having access to her, her constant visits lead to Tim's wife Margie to become slightly jealous. Something worrisome for Edith since she is growing increasingly attached to Marigold and doesn't want what looks like an inappropriate relationship keeping her from her daughter. But with Tim in pursuit of keeping Edith and her daughter close together, and give his wife less reasons to worry, he comes up with the idea that Edith can be some aristocrat doting on Marigold for she has a great interest in her.

Edith aside, the real mystery worth noting is Ms. Baxter's. For with Thomas having blackmailed her for who knows how long, and him getting increasingly aggressive about finding something to use on Mr. Bates, it seems less and less Moseley will be able to save her. However, while physically incapable of stopping Thomas, he does tell Ms. Baxter to just come clean with Lady Grantham so Thomas can't hold any power over her. Leading to her revealing she stole from the former lady she worked under, went to jail, and that she never gave the jewelry back. All of which is worrisome for Lady Grantham, but while she has to think about Baxter's future at the abbey, Thomas presents himself as someone nearly asking to leave. For with her seeing he was possibly trying to blackmail Baxter, and never mind he recommended a criminal to work in her home, he is in deep trouble. However, with Edith accidentally causing a fire, and Thomas saving Edith and alerting the house, he quickly rebounds from being put out the house.

Topic 3: Love, Lust & Marriage – Tom Branson, Mary, James, Ms. Cawley and Mr. Moseley

To begin, let's speak of Mr. Moseley and Ms. Baxter's odd little relationship. With her being partly oblivious, so it seems, Moseley is doing his best to find ways to get noticed and be appealing. Which includes dying his hair, among trying his best to protect her from Thomas. All of which helps his case, but him being timid makes it so not much happens between them.

And in a way, Tom being timid is also keeping him from his own happiness. Though, as noted last season, like Mary he shares a bit of inability to move on from his dead spouse. However, like Mary, the person who has come to take up their time their spouse would have had reminds them of why life is worth living. For while Mary is all but ready to become Mr. Gillingham's lover, and eventual wife, Tom is just really starting to understand how much Ms. Bunting could lead to him rediscovering the passion for life and politics he once shared with Sybil.

Though with Ms. Bunting curious, and critical, of aristocracy, she rubs a lot of people the wrong way when Rose decides to play match maker and invite Ms. Bunting to Lord and Lady Grantham's wedding anniversary. Now, how does she rub them the wrong way? Well, she mentions her thoughts on World War I, questions why Mr. Carson was chosen over Lord Grantham to be chairman over a committee for a war memorial, and all this among Lord Grantham's friends, family, and the friends of his children. So, needless to say, her being rude and embarrassing, on top of Thomas snitching how she was in the house while the family was in London, makes her practically detestable to Lord Grantham.

But not to Ms. Crawley. For, as seen last season, she has really taken to Tom almost like he was her son. So, as Ms. Bunting puts her foot in her mouth, she tries to offer support for having an opinion. Though, like with Mary and Tom, when it comes to her personal life, specifically Lord Merton's pursuit of her, she too is a bit timid and not direct. Though with the Dowager as her confidant, and she realizing if Lord Merton is serious it would give Ms. Crawley a prominent position in the county, it seems she is all but willing to sabotage their courtship for reasons maybe mentioned last season, but I honestly can't remember.

Leaving James who, with a former employer named Lady Anstruther, has been exchanging letters, phone calls, and she seems quite taken with him. Though it isn't love so much as her loving the validation that comes from a young man looking at her as attractive. And with her being quite aggressive, she comes to Downton and is caught in bed with James by Lord Grantham. Leading to James being dismissed.
18 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A big step up after London Season
skinnybert16 September 2023
Wow -- do we really have nothing but ten-star reviews, broken only by one three-star? Neither is accurate, nor useful, so here we go:

The good news is that the writing quality has returned. Make no mistake: it's still largely a high-concept soap opera, with melodrama abounding -- and you'd better not ask how it is that a book belonging to Edith's employer is found in the house ... unless you're the sort of person who would bring a book on German grammar to a party, when your main reason for being there is to see the Lord's daughter. Also, the whole Baxter-Barrows drama feels a bit forced, and the Bates business is being dragged out to no real advantage, in typical Downton Abbey fashion.

But never mind all that: Robert James-Collier is fine (once again!) as both villain and hero, Maggie Smith gets some lines she can really deliver with incomparable relish (as does Penelope Wilton, to a lesser extent), and there are two very good party scenes, where relationships are changed and interesting things are said. If the episode concludes with an event clearly designed to allow certain interactions to happen -- well, they had to happen somehow, and it mostly works if we don't question what happens with Gregson's book too closely.

In sum, a good solid episode: neither a favorite nor an embarrassment, with some delightfully piquant dialog -- a distinct improvement over the here's-our-plot scripting that dogged much of London Season. Speaking of dogs: Isis gets three scenes in this episode, and is specifically mentioned twice (though off-camera). And if I didn't mention how fabulous all the clothing and hair is -- Elizabeth McGovern never looked better than the early scene of her coming down the stairs. Beautifully shot and she looks born to dress that way. Equally, Allen Leech is the very picture of a dashing young man in his dinner outfit. That's just the two actors who stood out to me in this episode.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
More Secrets To Reveal
jpismyname5 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This episode is the best since Season 4. It starts with Lady Edith visiting her illegitimate daughter at her adoptive parents' house. Edith is depressed that she is away from her daughter. Poor Edith, luck must find her someday.

Then there's Jimmy, who is getting love letters from his former employer. I really can't stand Jimmy, he's just as despicable as Thomas. No wait, Thomas is slightly worse. I really regret feeling sorry for Thomas when he was about to be dismissed. I wish Carson really did that. Anyway, now Thomas is hungry for some shocking news about anyone else in the house so he bullies Miss Baxter and asks her about her knowledge of Anna and Bates' secrets. Miss Baxter, a kind woman, refuses. I'm glad they didn't decide Miss Baxter to be some sort of like the new Miss O'Brien. Thomas is enough now.

Of course there's also Lady Mary, who must be really lucky in love. Tony Gillingham is courting her again and Mary admits that she loves him, but is unsure because, you know, Matthew.

But then my favorite parts are the scenes involving the Dowager Countess arranging luncheon to be like some matchmaker for Isobel Crawley and the doctors who court her.

And then sweet Daisy wants to be a grown woman now, and that is by learning numbers in order to run old Mr. Mason's farm. I really like Daisy's character development. From a kitchen maid who barely knows anything but to light the fireplaces and be told what to do, to know being an ambitious, good cook who can make up her own mind now.

And then the secrets are revealed. Miss Baxter tells Lady Cora the truth so that Barrow can never bully her anymore. She was a criminal. She was a theft who got imprisoned for three years, and she did not return the jewels. Cora, a kind woman as she is, decides to keep Miss Baxter for a while until she decides what to do.

Then the fire at the end. Thrilling, suspenseful, then Robert catches Jimmy and his former employer doing it in the guest's bedroom. Jimmy is dismissed, good riddance I must say.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Well Developed Episode
Hitchcoc25 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
So many things go on here that it's hard to do justice to all of them. First, we have the pain that is Edith's as she negotiates the situation with Marigold, he daughter. We have the continuing saga of Thomas and Baxter. We finally learn what is going on...almost. There is the underhanded effort of Violet to keep Mrs. Crawley away from the stuffy landholder guy. We have further evidence that Robert's power is diminishing. Miss Bunting is invited to the anniversary party by Rose so she can be Branson's date. This leads to some very tense moments at the dinner table. There is a near disaster at the conclusion of the episode. Daisy continues to spread her wings, much to Carson's dismay. Jimmy commits the ultimate crime within the estate--caused by his own stupidity. Finally, eavesdropping, even accidental, which is a sport at Downton, makes Mrs. Hughes privy to some startling news.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Getting so Gooood
Lord and Lady Grantham are having marital problems of their own, although Robert is largely oblivious, to the point of forgetting their anniversary. It seems that Cora is getting tired of being less of a character than an occasionally convenient plot device a bewildering choice from creator Julian Fellowes, since Elizabeth McGovern is considerably more talented than some of her co-stars, Hugh Bonneville included. What this says for the Countess' future is uncertain but since McGovern's band, Sadie and the Hotheads, have been touring a lot lately, the Earl might want to pay more attention to his wife unless he wants to lose her to Spanish flu or upcoming guest star Richard E. Grant...Meanwhile, you wouldn't think that such an already-bloated cast would need any addition, but it seems that, having adjusted to life as a single father and proxy aristocrat, Tom is now in the market for a love interest. Spirited socialist teacher Miss Bunting seems to have wandered in from a different series altogether where she plays the spunky, iconoclastic lead - she clearly thinks she's being charmingly modern, when actually she's just the rather rude love interest of a less-than-interesting character. Poor Tom - he even gets upstaged by his daughter, who has taken to calling Lord Crawley 'Donk' in a misplaced attempt to remind us that he's a family man. Then again, since one of his grandchildren is currently being raised by a pig farmer who moonlights as a fireman, that's the least of his problems. We're spoilt for choice here, with both Anna Chancellor and Harriet Walter making blink-and-you'll-miss-them appearances, both doing what they do best. Chancellor plays arch and sexually predatory Lady Anstruther and Walter is stuffy but wry as the Dowager's old friend Lady Shackleton, introduced and quickly discarded as a potential suitor for the Isobel-smitten Lord Merton. Both actresses could easily carry weighty subplots on their perfectly sculpted shoulders, so perhaps they just happened to be visiting the set and Julian Fellowes decided to shoehorn them into the script.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Worse and worse. As good as s1 and 2 were, s4 and 5 are abysmal.
sogoodlooking17 April 2022
An expansive look at the breadth of English life during its first two years collapses after World War One into the trivia of women's most melodramatic concerns.

What an utter pity. Even poor Bates, DA's very own Job, again facing execution, is sidelined in favor of Anna's apprehensions. Ugh.
1 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed