"True Detective" The Locked Room (TV Episode 2014) Poster

(TV Series)

(2014)

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The Tall Man...
TheCornProject27 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Frustratingly, our detectives have hit yet another wall in the case. Armed with damning evidence from the destroyed church, Cohle and Hart decide to scale up their investigation into the traveling revival group. What they find is a church not unlike many churches in the American South. Fiery teachings of the 'old-time' gospel lead by a charismatic preacher named Joel Theriot (Shea Whigham). Observing Theriot's dozens of loyal congregants, Cohle irreverently comments to an irritated Hart that "nobody here is going to be splitting the atom". Inquiring further, Cohle and Hart question Theriot's involvement in the church burning and the whereabouts of his staff members around the time of Dora's disappearance. It appears that Theriot's motivations are all too altruistic as he explains how vandals destroyed the church back in Eunice, Louisiana.

With alibis for all of the church staff, Cohle and Hart attempt to canvass any acquaintances of Dora's at the church. One member describes a tall man who may have attended the church with Dora. The man had a distinctive marking on his face that could have been the result of a burns injury (perhaps a meth lab explosion?). Another thin lead is something that our detectives can ill afford at this pressurizing time. Tensions are further inflamed when Hart finds Cohle talking to his wife while he is not home. The implied anger from Hart here is that Cohle is replacing him as the man of the house in his absence. Insecurity is running deep in the Hart household as Martin fears the prospect of being replaced and Maggie fears the prospect of her husband becoming increasingly less transparent with her. Later when out on a dinner date, Hart rather embarrassingly spots his other lover Lisa (Alexandra Daddario) being wooed by a younger man. Enraged by what he sees as a personal affront, Hart seeks retribution later that night by attacking the man in Lisa's apartment. The action seals the end of his torrid affair with Lisa and forces him to contemplate the future of his marriage.

Back in the interview room, Rust Cohle describes the "the locked room" as the place in our minds where we hide our true motivations and intentions. Cohle has an adept ability to access and comprehend this place when he interrogates suspects. He may not have any viable suspects for this case yet but extensive research into death records has revealed the supposedly accidental drowning of another woman named Rianne Olivier. Under closer scrutiny, Rianne's death appears to have the same trademarks as Dora Lange's murder. Following up on the lead reveals a boyfriend named Reginald Ledoux whom Rianne ran away from home with before her untimely demise. A background check on 'Reggie' reveals statutory rape charges, drug manufacturing charges (meth/LSD) and a current parole violation. Cohle and Hart are like two hungry wolves waiting to pounce on their prey. Have they finally found the prime suspect that will help them crack the case before their time runs out?

These last three episodes have been slowly building up to a grand resolution. What Hart earlier described as the "throw down in the woods". The most crucial question on my lips right now is; Is Reginald Ladoux the 'Tall Man' aka the monster at the end of the dream?

4.5/5
31 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A work of Art
ahmxii28 November 2021
I am glad "True Detective" is not like those other shows, it's slow for a reason, it takes its time; it is not so much about the crime as it's about the characters and social commentary. It requires your attention, it's for mature thinking adults, so if you are bored then you are looking at this show the wrong way and expecting it to be a typical cop show.

This third episode took a turn when it came to revealing more about the conflict of Martin and Rust, every conversation these two have is the unraveling of what this show is about, not so much about the crime but who these two people are and how they live and view the world with the carnival of characters as a backdrop to the murder story. This show may be hard for people who want instant entertainment to sit through because they are so focused on the crime aspect of it and expect to see action, but this is not what the writer is trying to present to you here with these two detectives.
15 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Authenticity the main word
AvionPrince1618 August 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I love the way that they use authenticity in that TV Show: we can really believe that the situations are real and the characters feel really believable and more close to the reality and i enjoyed that: So Good to see that. The case its still interesting to follow and new elements are there: an old case will lead them to a new profile to the killer. Rust maybe have a new girlfriend? Still early to say and im pretty curious about how the woman of the other detective will find that he is cheating and clearly have feeling with his other woman. A nice episode with a case pretty interesting to follow and im curious to see how it will end.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A work of Art that wont be appreciated
BirdmanT727 January 2014
I have heard a lot of negative reviews about this show being too slow/boring since the first episode. For those who were expecting to see an action cop show like "Chicago PD" with some gun fire,profanity, dead body parts, then you have come to the wrong place. Just hearing these complaints about how slow the show is a sign of our times of how people's attention's span is so become less conditioned and more programmed to be entertained every minute of those 60 minutes with some kind of intense violence.

I am glad "True Detective" is not like those other shows, its slow for a reason, it takes its time; it is not so much about the crime as its about the characters and social commentary. It requires your attention, its for a mature thinking adults, so if you are bored then you are looking at this show the wrong way and expecting to be a typical cop show.

"Rust Cohle" is probably one of the most interesting written characters in a television/cable Police drama show I have ever seen as a Cop. He maybe viewed as misanthrope or even a sociopath yet he understands himself and knows who he is to a fault. He said once he is glad he is single and never remarried because he would have wear the other person down and its not fare to them, but that's what makes him right to fit the job. He may view and disdain the human species or human nature, yet a lot what he believes and says is true that for people like his partner "Martin Hart" who claims a family is what brings balance to a man's life, yet he cheats on his wife and lies to himself. Cohle summed up best that their difference as Hart to be a person who lives in "denial", people who deny of what they really want or and live a life of what is expected of them; yet according to Cohle people who are incapable of guilt have a better time in life.

Cohle sees the Merry Go 'Round of life and finds its pathetic, so he refuses to participate, to live this fiction that everyone creates in their head that place Rust calls " The Locked Room", what he views to be a fictions of lies to become a "Person". Listening to him one may think he is insane and detached but he is actually more human than most.

This third episode really took a turn when it came to reveal more about the conflict of Martin and Rust, every conversation these two have is the unraveling of what this show is about, not so much about the crime but who these two people are and how they live and view the world with the carnival of characters as a backdrop to the murder story. This show maybe hard for people want instant entertainment to sit through because they are so focused on the crime aspect of it and expect to see action, but this is not what the writer is trying to present to you here with these two detectives. Had this show been released in the 1970's I doubt it would be viewed as slow or boring, but this how far people's mind are conditioned to think that every show has to have the same pace, the same jump cuts to action, so its a challenge to just sit, listen and think, what an endeavor?.

I remember a film from the 80's by director David Lynch called "Blue Velvet" where the crime element was just a side show to what the film was about and it took years for people to understand Lynch's intention with that film. I think it will take years to look back on this show for people to realize its a masterpiece, a work of Art that wont be appreciated by the mundane minds of today's text/ipod generation who have been dummied down by watching the works and likes of "Tarantino"; the master of "puppet" theater.

So I say Bravo to creator Nic Pizzolatto for not being a conformist and be above the Puppet shows, by challenging his audience to sit up and pay attention and maybe reflect on something that they relate to; he has raised the bar way high with this show !
225 out of 249 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A memorable episode!
mm-394 February 2014
Warning: Spoilers
"The Locked Room" is more of a story episode. The situation of is this a copy cat?, interviews of the who, what, and how? drive the story forward. I found the background of the slimy characters, and the desolate rural Louisiana creates a bleak ambiance. Cohle's intelligence dominates the episode with Cohle's methodical/psychological research for case leads. A big break is created through Cohle's research while Hart is creating marital problems. Hart's personal problems over lap into Cohle's life when Hart's wife is digging for information if Hart is cheating and makes a play for Cohle. I believe Hart's wife is looking for revenge for hurting her using Cohle. The Locked room leaves the viewer hanging with the two detectives looking for a big lead! I wonder if the back and forth in time with present interview of the two other cops is going to turn the story into the present? A strong story with strong character with a memorable ending.
23 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Intense moments of character!
and_mikkelsen1 July 2023
This was yet another episode driven by our main characters, who they are and their world view and philosophies! This is when two very different people clash and are forced to work together!

This episode also shows that no one is perfect and I loved the themes portrayed in the episode! Yonestly a lot of it is strangely deep and meaningfull in a weird way! Some of the conversations really makes you reflect on things and perhaps even your own life!

The lead actors are doing a wonderfull job with some amazing and memorable scenes!

I also have to talk qbout the last part which propably will forever by printed in my mind as to how twisted someone can look and appear!
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
1x03
formotog1 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Another really good episode. Yet again it was filled with philosophical genius from Rust. Almost every line that comes from his mouth is quotable and the truth about life. He is a truly fascinating character. Marty top revealed more about himself, and the difference between the two is that Marty has himself convinced that he's no bad man, whereas Rust fully embraces the fact that he is. Marty's complete hypocrisy is actually funny to watch. He completely embodies the typical insecure "alpha" male who believes he does no wrong. The ending to this episode was chilling and certainly beckons a big development in the case. Until now, the case has been slow and the only two characters we really know are the two main characters. As the case develops, so will they, which is why I'm very excited by that ending

Mid 8
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Rust: People incapable of guilt usually do have a good time.
bombersflyup19 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The Locked Room is engaging the whole way through, though in retrospect not a lot happens. The story does progress, but still has much personal stuff. I mostly enjoyed the pair taking in the sermon, everything Cohle says is on the money.
12 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
8.75/10, Getting ALOT Better
dcdude-269887 July 2023
This was definitely another great episode of this season. So far, this is still very unpredictable, even at the very start of the season. My favorite characters in this episode were again, Rust, Marty, and Maggy. My favorite things about this episode were the Protagonist, the Cinematography, and the music. This was the last episode until the very highest rated of this season and the entire show, so I wonder if it lives up to that rating or if there is a better one. I'm still wondering if this will be one of my favorite seasons of television or not, but who knows? I don't think this is better than Chernobyl Season 1 so far, but I don't feel to need to repeat the question again.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Another Poorly Structured Episode with Too Many Plot Strands
lavatch9 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Finally, the two detectives are making some headway in their murder investigation. Still, Episode #3 blends too many plot lines in a lackluster program.

The most interesting part of the series is the lives of the two detectives, as opposed to their tracking down a serial, occult murderer. Hart has a complete meltdown when he becomes jealous of the personal life of his mistress, Lisa. On the other hand, the troubled detective Cohle has clearly withdrawn from the world after the death of his daughter, channeling his pain into his work.

Cohle's ability to conduct an interrogation draws upon his intuitive skills. Time, death, and futility are his guiding principles, which he effectively deploys on the job as a homicide detective. But he is hopeless on a date with young woman, as set up by Hart's wife Maggie. The trouble at school experienced by one of the daughters of Hart and Maggie is suggestive of the family dysfunction coming from Hart's infidelity and lack of time spent at home. Maggie believes that her husband has "low expectations." But she is in the dark about her husband's philandering.

The episode closes with the detectives on the trail of a "monster" named Reginald Ledoux.
8 out of 106 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed