Reply 1997 (TV Series 2012–2013) Poster

(2012–2013)

User Reviews

Review this title
14 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
KTV drama at its best!
cremea8 March 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Reply 1997 aka Answer me/to 1997. Korean TV drama. 16 Episodes. Summer of 2012.

SPOILERS AHEAD!

Story: Teenagers go through their final school years on the way to young adulthood. As adults, they reconvene in 2012 for their 15 year class reunion; while there, they all reflect on their past while their history together unfolds via back story. It's primarily a life story drama about growing up.

A half dozen high school kids or so are focused on throughout this show (some more than others), along with one young teacher, and one set of parents. The vast majority of the story is told from 1997 to 1999 and takes place against the backdrop of the birth of K-Pop. The kids meet at high school, become friends, experience awkward first loves, graduate, drift apart, move on in life, etc...The remainder of the story flashes forward in time periodically until it arrives at the present, where you eventually get to see what happened to everybody involved.

KTV shows come & go at such a rapid fire pace that it's virtually impossible for a viewer to figure out what's actually going to be good and what's not until a show is well into its compressed run time. Fortunately, it's fairly easy to determine if a show will be suitable to your own personal tastes right away, and I must say I quickly developed a fondness for this particular one. "Reply 1997" doesn't have an overly famous cast, a huge budget, or a massive pre-air marketing campaign to prop it up, so it has to work a little a harder to prove itself, and figure out how to find an audience along the way. It basically has to rely on smart storytelling, and subsequent word-of-mouth, in order to be successful, and it did all of this, and then some, really well.

Clearly, the best thing this show has going for it is its creativity and intelligence. It's quite well written, and the way it implements a multiple time line is highly effective; subtle hints are dropped at the current day dinner party during each episode, then it flashes back to the past to see how things came to be in the present. This method of storytelling serves to successfully further the plot while keeping you interested in the story & characters along the way. This show also refuses to pander to viewers; it's completely devoid of one-note characters and typical antagonists, and it does not rely on being overly formulaic (which is a frequent problem that is inherent to this industry). Its willingness to openly deal with oft addressed topics in a thoughtful, and often hilarious, manner is rather impressive as well.

The late '90s/early K-Pop theme is frequently focused on throughout this show, despite the fact that it's somewhat irrelevant to the true heart of the story. This is all implemented exceptionally well however, and while this show could have succeeded without it, it is certainly better off for including it. There's a good deal of nostalgia involved as a result (from an array of props, to the soundtrack of that era, to cameos, period references, and so on), and, everything is nicely woven together into one seamless tale; none of it ever feels out of place, or tacked on, just for the sake of making it part of the overall story.

The cast is pretty solid at getting their jobs done, and they're all afforded well rounded roles. While not unrecognizable to most fans of the Korean entertainment industry, this is primarily a very youthful cast without years & years of experience in this field. Several of them are current K-Pop industry crossover stars as well, and the irony of having several actual K-Pop idols portraying high school kids obsessed with K-Pop is not lost on me. The lead role is reserved for Jung Eun-ji (of APink fame); she could use a little more seasoning going forward as a drama star, but she is way ahead of the curve already and makes for an oddly charismatic and impressive young actress for someone who's relatively new at this. Everybody gave nice performances throughout, and they were equally believable as both high school kids and their future 30 year old counterparts. The two parents are even given diverse parts as well (which is rare for these shows); there are usually only a handful of the same tired old roles available to K-drama parents/elders (i.e. usually you're either: a rich manipulative ass, a drunken deadbeat dad, a poor sick mom, etc). Here, the parents are refreshingly portrayed as regular people going through their everyday lives as a normal middle aged/middle class couple. In many ways, the parents practically exemplify what the entire spirit of this show is all about.

Summary: All in all, this is a quickly paced and very effective series that I have virtually no complaints about whatsoever. It features a simple and approachable story that should resonate with a wide range of viewers; young/old, Korean/not Korean, male/female, it doesn't really matter. Engaging, smart, funny, poignant; this is a perfect example of how good KTV dramas can be when they aspire to be more than just "stylishly status quo".

Bottom Line: A real gem for K-drama fans that's not to be missed! 9 out of 10 stars!...HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A K-drama you won't want to miss
TychoB10 January 2014
Every once in a while, amidst the multitudes of Korean dramas which employ all the stereotypical clichés such as Cinderella story lines, hapless women who have tear ducts the size of the Pacific Ocean, and men fighting over mates like gorillas, a show such as Reply 1997 comes along to provide viewers with a breath of fresh air. I recently undertook a marathon session of this drama after many recommendations from friends, and I don't know why I waited so long; everything about Reply 1997 is believable, relatable, and most of all entertaining. This drama will transport you to 1990's S. Korea, as several high school students wrestle with the ups and downs of life while dealing with one another. Reply 1997 will make you yearn for the good ol' days of your adolescence, as well as reminisce about the golden years of S. Korea. I guarantee that you go straight to your computer and make a playlist of most of the songs that are wonderfully woven into the drama.

Many different and surprisingly complex themes are explored in every episode; many of the experiences portrayed are those that you or someone close to you have probably gone through, and this drama recognizes that real life happens. One quip I had with Reply 1997 is that some of these themes could have been developed a little more, such as that involving Joon Hee. Another issue I could see arising is that viewers who are not familiar with the pop culture of 1990's S. Korea could have difficulty catching onto some of the references made. This is minor, however, as the top-notch acting and stellar writing more than make up for this.

Seriously, just go watch this thing. The only regret you'll have after you're done is that you won't be able to watch anymore episodes.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
One in the reply series I would not recommend
leahcubed21 January 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Shi-Won (Jung Eun-ji) is a fangirl in the 1990s of a boy band called H.O.T. Flash forward to her at 33 years old and nearing a reunion, her and her 5 friends in high school recall what was like for them all back then. Yoon Yoon-je (Seo In-juk) is the younger of two brothers who grew up with Shi-won when his parents died. Shi-won's parents were best friends of Yoon-je's parents and became like mother and father to the two boys when their parents died. Yoon Tae-Woong was in love with and fiancée to Shi-won's older sister who died tragically. Tae-Woon later shows romantic interest in Shi-won. Yoon-je also loves Shi-won but feels his brother, who sacrificed so much for him, should not bear heartbreak again so he puts his feelings aside. Friendship, love triangles and flashes back to the 90's lots of interesting elements.

I was very lukewarm about this one. I found myself waiting for it to get over. I didn't hate it but I didn't like it either. It was a little bit like the United States television show "How I Met your Mother" in that it started in the future and had you wondering who Shi-won's husband was. They kept teasing you with it and you couldn't figure out which one of the guys she was married to. Then in a series of extended flashbacks you get the story slowly throughout the episodes. Of course there are love triangles and side romances and also bromances and all of that was good. It ended the way I like them to end where I knew what was going on with all the characters. I did not particularly like the type of relationship the two that wind up together had. It was the sort of bickering and fighting that makes you wonder if they even like each other sort of relationship. The chemistry was there but the way they portrayed the relationship was hard to envision them lasting long term. One of the side couples would have been cute but they were constantly breaking up or saying they were going to break up which made them not seem that into each other either. It made me wonder what the writers idea of a good relationship is. It focused a little bit on the fan girl angle but I didn't feel like I knew a whole lot more about that after having watched this. There were also some weird things like when the sister died I had to read some other reviews to even figure out that that was Shi-won's sister. They never showed the sister as a really being part of the family they always showed her doing things other than with the family. Then when she died suddenly and unexpectedly there was really only one passing comment about it made by the dad. And the fiancé, Tae-woon, it did not really show him going through much grief either. It made me wonder why they even bothered to include that storyline except for later when he falls for Shi-won she wonders and you wonder as well if it's just because she reminds him of the sister. Shi-won even asked Tae-woon if he liked her because she reminds her of her sister and he said that's not the reason. Which, if that is the case, there was no reason to even have the sister be part of the story. To me there were just a lot of elements like that that didn't hold together or add interest. I would definitely not recommend this highly or even to get a feel for the genre or time. If you like movies told In flashback then perhaps you would like this better than I did. One thing it does well is keep you hanging on who she ends up with.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Another Reply!
Van-pumpkinberries13 December 2020
I loved 1988 and I don't think any of the other reply will ever meet up to it.

This 1997 was good, it was a switch from the first two. Shorter but good.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Hallyu!
bobandlulureview14 May 2018
I like series that are set in the past and tell us how life was back then while also giving us a glimpse of events from those specific years. Reply does exactly that! The first installment in the series is called 'Reply 1997'. The story revolves around six protagonists - Shi Won, Yoon Jae, Yoo Jung, Joon Hee, Hak Chan and Sung Jae who are in their senior year of high school and are busy figuring out life after school. The main protagonist is Shi Won played by Jung Eun Ji from the popular K-Pop girl group APink. Shi Won has just one love in her life - H.O.T! She will go any lengths to be a core member of their fan club. She'll skip school to stand in line for their album. She'll run away from home just so she can have a glimpse of her idol. Shi Won has absolutely no clue about life after school because she is just too immersed in her love for her favourite boy band from S.M.Entertainment. She may not be the best of students but she can come up with steamy plotlines about her favorite idol's personal life! What makes this series popular is the fact that it introduces to all its audiences, both international and domestic, to the fact that 'Fan Fictions' have been in existence since the dawn of boy bands. One of the most loved themes of the series is the rivalry between White Angels and Yellow Kies. When Shi Won finds out that her best friend is no longer a White Angel but a fan of Sechs Kies all hell breaks loose. What makes all of this even more funny is the fact that Eun Ji Won who plays Hak Chan is actually a band member of Sechs Kies. Sechs Kies and H.O.T were the first few bands to have such large members in their fandom. The fight scene between White angels and Yellow Kies is nothing but epic but the ultimate climax is when the victor is announced! The series played a very important role in bringing to the fore the foundation of the Hallyu (Korean Wave) that has swept over the world in over two decades and is still going strong. Sung Dong Il and Lee Il Hwa who play Shi Won's parents are portrayed as a couple that's always bickering but there is a definite under current of love that we keep getting a glaring glimpse of throughout the series. Who would've thunk that they would be able to take and make their characters so popular amongst everybody who watched it! Apart from the obvious KPop theme - other aspects of High School life are dealt with very delicately. This first installment has a mystery theme. The story begins in current day 2012 but takes us back to 1997. We learn how the characters met and their relationship with each other is established and we also see how their friendship has progressed from 1997 to 2012 but in the present day of the series Shi Won is pregnant and the audience is left guessing as to who her partner is at the end of each episode.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
loved In Guk for the first time
lmerana25 February 2020
This is the kdrama that I fell on love with In Guk. I don't like eunji but tgey have great chemistry and they sang together perfectly. It was not as great as reply 1988, but it was funny and romantic as well. It emphasized the kpop era of sechs kies H.O.T and Fin. K.L and the lofe of a fan girl.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I watch this because of Seo In Guk
kelly-0734429 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I really love Seo In Guk. This is his first drama but the way he act is excellent. But the back and forth story line makes me a little bit confused. And Shi Won's mom and dad, they were just yelling at each other and the noise...

8 stars because of In Guk :)
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Seo In-guk
ayausama10 August 2020
7 start just for Seo In-guk acting he is really talented, I fell in love with each scene of him
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
So enjoyable!
misswritercreates23 March 2019
I've watched all 3 versions of the reply series and this one is my favorite. I loved the characters and they did a great job! I also loved how we kept going back and forth from present to the past. I highly recommend especially if you enjoy nostalgia shows, this will probably take you back in time. I was pleased with the storyline very much although I also wished this one had a wedding sooner than letting the many years pass but I guess it's just how things worked out. At least the couple who I wanted to get together did! You won't be disappointed either I'm sure!
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Aggressive annoying woman...
chilligrrl30 September 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Seriously, si-won was the most spoiled, aggressive woman who is utterly and completely unlikable. The loser dodged a HUGE bullet there. She strung them on for years, then blamed her husband for "not being careful" and never stopped hitting the poor guy (it takes two to tango, love). The only thing that made this bearable was the cute doctor guy. I wish he was the main character.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good enough
PennyReviews22 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
The first of the Reply series is a classic for the K Drama fans, but surely it's a nice watch for everyone as well. The story focuses on a group of friends who meet again in a school reunion in 2012. While they are at the reunion, we see their lives back in school in the 1990's and also await for the mystery of who the female lead ends up marrying. The story is quite entertaining, with the characters being very funny and cute, and the main romance good enough, although it wasn't a big mystery for long. Probably the only problem with the series was that it had too many references on 1990's culture, but my subs explained fairly enough and I kind of was familiar with some of the bands that the girls were obsessed with. And it was nice to see the early K pop fangirling, where it all began. Fortunately, the back and forth wasn't tiring, as it happened only once or twice in each episode, and mostly in the beginning and ending. So 7 out of 10.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Void of Reply 1988 quality & all of its charm!
noufus18 July 2020
I just finished Reply 1988 and was IN LOVE with it - everything about it! So thought I would watch this next given its high rating/reviews.

I am 5 episodes in and MAJORLY disappointed to say the least. Most characters were super abnoxious and too annoying to even tolerate watching with absolutely no redeeming qualities about them. 70% of the dialogue was stupid arguments about nothing and doesnt add to the story and i felt myself being annoyed all through EVERY episode so far. These 5 episodes could have been half of one if they removed the bickering fluff. I also find myself not caring/interested enough in any character or what happens next or to anyone.

I feel like I gave it a fair chance and I am glad i won't be hearing people scream and fight about nonesence anymore.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Cute Teenager Relationship
11ovz116 September 2021
I watched this right after Reply 1988. But have to say this is not up to the Reply 1988 standard. However, we can give it a pass since Reply 1997 is the first installment of the franchise and Reply 1988 is the last.

The will they won't they arc along with "who's the father" arc was a bit overplayed. We all guessed who it is from episode 1 itself, so I didn't see the reason for it to be dragged till the last episode.

However, other than that the humanity, emotions, and stories of each character were well played. This is a heart warming drama and the main couple's cute storyline is a bonus!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Not Reply 1988
chad-77665-8729810 May 2021
Unfortunately, perhaps, saw Reply 1988 which is very good (later learned in reading reviews to understand why Reply 1994 and 1997 were so bad that this was the third effort by the writer/directors and they "finally got it right"). Unlike 1988, this series follows superficial characters focused on insipid, high school drivel. Not that the high schoolers in 1988 never act like high schoolers, but in 1988 it is part of their reality, not the focus of the plotlines. In 1994 and 1997 we follow characters who are so superficial that how anyone could care what happens is beyond me. My wife is Korean and even she couldnt get through 1997 (worse 1994). I can only imagine the entire country of Korea must be highly rating this program as the rating is ridiculous. I would have given this a 5 but to redress it's over rating, giving it a 2. Don't waste your time.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed