For the Birds (2018) Poster

(I) (2018)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Filmmaker says "For the Birds" is really more about The Human Experience
jtncsmistad1 June 2019
The riveting new documentary "For the Birds" is a story that leads us down several roads. Obsession, marital struggle, love and loss are among the moving life experiences touched upon most poignantly by Director and Co-Producer/Editor Richard Miron.

Miron brings us into the profoundly unusual world of Kathy, a wife, mother and grandmother who over the course of several years has amassed over 200 birds on her property in rural eastern New York state, much to the chagrin and suffering of her husband of more than a quarter-century, Gary.

I had the opportunity to talk with Miron about his film, which consumed five years of his life including two devoted to editing. I started off by asking him how he originally found out about Kathy and the birds she calls pets. He tells me it all started as a senior project in college focusing on animal rescue and rights. He was working as a volunteer at Woodstock Farm Sanctuary (which plays a prominent role in the film) when he first met Kathy following up on a neighbor's complaint about the deplorable conditions at her home. It was then that Miron says a long-term relationship with this odd yet compassionate woman developed.

"I felt for everybody in the story and I really cared about Kathy. And I know she really loved her animals."

Miron says the thing that surprised him most during and after his intimate immersion in this ever-evolving story was bearing witness to the enormous power of change.

"The story morphed from being an animal rescue story to being more about this marriage and the way this couple loved each other in such a complex way over 25-plus years. The capacity for change. The capacity that Kathy has to turn her life around when she was really at rock-bottom."

The final image Miron leaves us with of Kathy in "For the Birds" inspires a decided feeling of hope. For change, certainly. But ultimately for a future more closely shared with her precious family. And, as damn hard as it will be, apart from the flock of feathered friends that will forever hold a place of empathy and love deep within her healing soul.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Hard to watch
jarymokin18 September 2019
Warning: Spoilers
This was hard to watch. Reminded me of someone i know that has the same animal hording problem. What I couldn't understand was the people from the SPCA were volunteers. Why didn't they volunteer and help her clean up her place? That really bothered me. It's OK to volunteer and help take the animals but not help where it's really needed with the poor hording lady. Why didn't they help her get running water and clean the place up? They cared more about the chickens, which by all rights are just food, than they did about the lady who is a human.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A feat in vérité filmmaking
stanleycarter-3933212 September 2019
This film took me by surprise not only by its story but how it was told. The filmmakers managed to balance perspectives and empathy in what clearly was a complex interpersonal drama. Kudos to them for avoiding the traps of oversimplifying or stigmatizing Kathy, her husband, or the sanctuary-and instead offering a rollercoaster of compassion and insight. I won't forget this film.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Enablers
naejadnama10 September 2019
It looks like the closest people to Kathy turned away for their own sanity. Someone needed to real this one in. Over all The filming was great and the story was told very well. The psychosis is so sick. It's like maybe medication, therapist, or someone saying no could have changed Kathy and Gary's lives.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
An extra long episode of Hoarders, but with chickens
maccas-5636723 October 2019
Basically "Hoarders" but with chickens. That's all you really need to know, because it never really rises above that. It never delves into the psychological "why" of Kathy's hoarding of chickens - as a result my interest came and went as frequently as the SPCA workers.

There are quite a few hard-to-watch scenes here involving cruelty to animals. This documentary is sure to divide a lot of viewers and asks questions like - do you sit on Kathy's side of the fence? or the animal rescue workers?

Kathy's love for her birds is clear, but whatever mental illnesses she is dealing with make this love somewhat misplaced. "For The Birds" manages to contain both tragedy (and somewhat) triumph, yet nothing here struck me as memorable.

Oddly, it's the second documentary about chickens I've seen this year. I'd recommend "Pecking Order" instead.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A stunner.
paulmurphy-2523120 January 2023
What a magnificent film.

It's a heartbreaker in so many ways - the animals, the woman desperately trying to feed them and care for them, her husband who is increasingly frustrated by the imposition of them on his life and finally the caring people from Woodstock Sanctuary.

They are the true heroes of this film.

They have seen the effects of hoarding of animals before and they see it again in this case.

They know the main subject of the film means well, hoarders usually do - but it's the animals who suffer.

How they manage the situation - with plenty of care and compassion and their dealing with a woman obsessed with her animals is the heart of the film.

So too the relationship between the woman and her husband.

It all packs a big emotional punch.

Highly recommended but tissues a must.

One of the fine animal rescuers later died after the film was completed - what a sad loss.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
MY DAD WAS IN IT
SpongeStudios10 May 2022
It was absolutely hilarious watching the parts where my dad was in it, and it felt unreal at the same time. Overall its a great documentary and worth the watch on netflix.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed