- Bay Kennish: You ruined everything.
- Emmett Bledsoe: I know.
- Bay Kennish: No, you don't know. You ruined us. You ruined every other relationship I'm ever gonna have. How am I supposed to fall for someone else when you do things like that?
- Emmett Bledsoe: I don't want you to fall for anyone else.
- Bay Kennish: But I need to. Because I can't be with you.
- Emmett Bledsoe: We were bigger than my one mistake. We are bigger.
- Bay Kennish: No. No, you don't just get to sleep with someone else and pull the "we're meant to be" card."
- Emmett Bledsoe: I didn't handle things right. I know that.
- Bay Kennish: Yea, I'd say sleeping with my brother's girlfriend and my childhood enemy while I was off talking to your parents about how to help you is not handling things right!
- Emmett Bledsoe: I am so sorry, Bay. I hope you know that.
- Bay Kennish: I do know. But... you ripped the fabric apart. You can't just tape it back together with words.
- Emmett Bledsoe: Then I'll wait... until I figure out how I can.
- Bay Kennish: So, I heard you have a new lady friend.
- Toby Kennish: I do. The lovely Jenna has been keeping me company.
- Bay Kennish: You sure bounce back fast.
- Toby Kennish: Oh, it's not like Simone and I were written in the stars or anything.
- Bay Kennish: Those would be some pretty messed up stars.
- Toby Kennish: It's not like Simone and I were written in the stars or anything.
- Bay Kennish: Those would be some pretty messed up stars.
- Alex: [reading Kathryn's book, about Emmet] He rode up on his motorcycle looking like a deaf James Dean.
- Bay Kennish: Do you know how nice it was to not be the girl who was switched at birth for a few weeks?
- Patrick: I'd rather be in a relationship where both people choose to, not because getting out of it would be a pain in the ass.