Secret Sharer (2014) Poster

(2014)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Adventure on the high seas Warning: Spoilers
I have the fondest of memories of Jack Laskey as Orlando in the Globe's production of As You Like It circa 2010 opposite Naomi Frederick's Rosalind. It was so full of guileish charm that I was utterly gripped by their roundabout romance. It so happens that production is available on DVD from the globe and it has its own IMDb entry here. Laskey's character in this film is not so far away from Orlando with his out-of-his-depth nervousness perfectly balanced with a need to assert himself as the new captain of the rust bucket cargo ship that has been stuck in port for six months and is being used by the motley crew as cheap apartments. Konrad, Laskey's character, has been suddenly promoted to captain beyond his years and he knows there is something strange about it. So does his oddball crew who suspect he will deliberately wreck the ship to get the insurance, wrecking them along with it, just to make things look convincing. With this tense atmosphere in place they embark on a journey. Konrad wakes one day to find that the crew has dropped anchor and is sailing away on a dinghy for some unscheduled R&R. While left stranded alone on the ship during the night a naked Chinese woman, Li, climbs aboard mermaid-like from the sea. Konrad takes her to his cabin after she passes out and there she recuperates without much care to put any clothes back on and Konrad is understandably enticed, agreeing to help her. The next day the captain of a nearby ship boards and searches the ship attempting to find the woman claiming that she is a murderer. With the stakes now raised considerably higher he keeps her presence a secret from the crew who return soon enough which means he has to share his food rations with her and she becomes the secret sharer. Once it becomes clear that Konrad will indeed be expected to scuttle the ship, Li becomes pivotal in forming an escape plan and winning the crew over.

There is so much to admire about this film.The performances of the actors are especially wonderful with Laskey cunningly developing from a yes man, keen to impress the man known only as "the Boss", into the captain of this soul without tedious histrionics. Zhu Zhu as the stowaway Li exudes mystery as she changes slowly from traumatised suicide attempter to a more confident and often rather petulant collaborator and lover of captain Konrad. Her vaguely American accent only adds to the sense that this is a woman with a past, a past we will never know about. The rest of the crew are all excellent, each with a distinctively drawn portrait, if with somewhat broad strokes. The Director, Peter Fudakowski , seems determined to keep things simple with few flourishes. The camera lingers, at first on the shimmering sea and then on the perpetually naked body of Zhu Zhu, who is, as it were, reborn in Konrad's cabin having left every stitch of her former life behind, and this lingering of the camera reflects the dreamy focus of Konrad and leads us into his seducements with the sea and her. It is subtly done and nicely balances the writing with the direction, but since both were the same person it is not so surprising. The balance is further developed when Konrad's budding romance is contrasted with a suspicious crew on the verge of mutiny. The dialogue is uncomplicated among the lovers and often hilarious among the crew, providing a window onto the world of gigantic cargo vessels.

The critical reception of this film has been generally less than buoyant with only a few seeing what I saw, chief among them Allan Hunter of the Express (4*/5). Whilst I can accept the limitations of the film (it's a bit "Mills and Boon", the ending is half baked and doesn't make sense) still some of the criticisms that have been leveled against it seem picky at best. This negative attention may have prevented the film finding its audience (there is one) since it seemed to sink without trace, scuppered by critics. Its a pity because its an entertaining, uplifting and beautiful film.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Sweet, romantic and entertaining film
johnneydorff18 May 2021
I felt compelled to write something just to remove the idiotic 1 star troll "review" displayed as the header by an individual that had not even watched the movie. I found the film very sweet and humble and thoroughly enjoyed it. The basic premise of the film was only "inspired" by Conrads short story, it makes no claims to be anything more indepth. Just a nice solid entertaining flick on its own.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A complete violation of Conrad's story
johnr-0588818 June 2016
I have not seen what I assume is a television adaption and would strongly recommend against anyone bothering with it as a sacrilege. This is Conrad's first and best work as it sets the narrative style ('freezing diachronic tension into a synchronic pattern') and existential dilemma (ontological insecurity) - our narrator repeatedly states that he has no self-knowledge - explored in his subsequent work. There are no females in the story. The ship has not been abandoned by its crew. The 'secret sharer' - Leggatt - is Capt. Lingard's 'doppelganger;. The question is the young captain's crisis in taking the first action of his command - an act that could result in shipwreck and the loss of his crew when he encounters Leggatt - an actual murderer - and hides him in his L-shaped cabin (divergent choice). Academics argue Conrad's intention: semiologists (from Jung) would have archetypes - materialists (from Reich) would have our (non-retrospective first person narrator) in a fugue state. Among the latter are those who would argue that Leggatt is entirely imaginary - which I dismiss as the Captain of Leggatt's vessel comes aboard in search of his fugitive first mate. Anyone interested in this fascinating and complex work should read Bruce Harkin's 'The Secret Sharer: Economical Personal Narrative' in 'Conrad's Secret Sharer and the Critics' - 1962; John P. Conger's 'Jung & Reich: the body of Shadow', and R.D. Laing's 'The Divided Self'. Let us hope that an adaptation will eventually come into competent hands.
4 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A beautiful movie adapted from a Joseph Conrad novel
paulas-247-73078110 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Had the good fortune to meet the filmmaker at a private screening of this movie. Secret Sharer (2014) is a story about a young ship officer who is promoted to captain for the purpose of taking commission of a cargo freighter whose wayward crew has taken control making it their floating possession. Orders are to return the vessel from the waters off the coast of Thailand to a port in China. Upon arriving aboard, the young Captain is faced with complete indifference to his orders, and the motley crew is breaking all the rules: women, alcohol, laziness and potted plants everywhere. Just as he's able to brow beat them into begrudging action, a mysterious and beautiful naked young woman appears under cover of night and boards the ship, an apparent escapee from a nearby vessel - who we later learn is accused of murder. Near drowned she collapses in the arms of the young Captain who is immediately captivated. While attempting to determine her true background he conceals her in his cabin, bringing food from the ample galley of his now curious shipmates who note his sudden change in attitude, and plot to win him over to their purpose, which is to do anything that will allow them to remain on this conscripted "houseboat". When orders from the owner arrive instructing the Captain to scuttle and sink the ship, he follows his code of honour to determine a solution to everyone's problem, just as an approaching storm carries the film toward its conclusion. The exquisite cinematography, music, casting choices and sensitivity of the actors will keep you spellbound. To learn the story is adapted from a Joseph Conrad novel at the end during the discussion was an added bonus. This is a gentle, beguiling and sensitive film filled with human frailty, passion, humour and morality through the lens of a mariner's code of conduct. A must see. Mixed English and Chinese language with accompanying subtitles.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A modern twist on a classic tale.
ABBFilmCritiques2 December 2023
A lovely story set in a gorgeous setting. This film was recommended by a friend and despite the film critics reviews did not disappoint. From someone who has not read the original book the story highlighted the value of human kindness, was stunning to watch in HDR with vivid colours of the natural landscape and had actors who fully committed to portraying their characters stories.

The film also has excellent music masterfully highlighting the emotions of every scene and sharing traditional Polish, Cuban and Chinese styles of music. Using a real ship meant that all the scenes and operation of the vessel were realistic and as a viewer I felt immersed in a long seas' voyage.

This is a great film to watch with my friends and family so I would highly recommend watching it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed