Bones of Crows (2022) User Reviews

Powerful, but "Indian Horse" tells a more cohesive story

[steiner-sam · 8/10 · 26 June 2023]

It's a drama about the Indian residential school system in Canada. It begins in Manitoba but includes Montreal, Toronto, and London, England. It extensively uses flashbacks from the 1880s, the 1930s to about 1970, and then to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission period.

The film details the multi-generational impact of the residential school system, using the family of a Cree woman, Aline Spears (Summer Testawich/Grace Dove/Carla-Rae). We see her happy early home life in an indigenous Catholic home, her removal to a residential school near Brandon, Manitoba, and her experiences there. Also taken to the school are her sister, Perseverance (Sierra Rose/Alyssa Wapanatâhk), and her brothers, Johnny (Ethan Evans) and Tye (Payne Merasty). We learn the impact of the school on all the Spears children, including Tye and Perseverance. Staff at the Catholic residential include Father Jacobs (Rémy Girard), Sister Ruth (Karine Vanasse), and Thomas Miller (Jonathan Whitesell/Patrick Garrow)

Interspersed are Aline's experiences in the Canadian Forces as a code talker who helped translate military messages transmitted in Cree back into English. We meet her Cree husband, Adam Whallach (Phillip Lewitski), who goes off to war simultaneously. The film shows his service's impact and his reception upon returning home after the war. We also meet Aline's children and see her participation in a First Nations visit to the Pope in 2009, with some startling revelations.

"Bones of Crows" is tough to watch. It reminded me of the film "Indian Horse," but it tries to pack in even more content, which leaves the viewer jerked about with the many storylines. However, it's also potent, especially in the Aline portrayed by Grace Dove. She is excellent, as is Michelle Thrush, who represents her mother.

A White Canadian can only feel shame leaving this film. The very prominent Christian cross is thoroughly sullied. I think "Bones of Crows" becomes too didactic at the end; it should have left the viewer to marinate in the story without the additional testimonies.

Sorry chapter of Canadian AND United States history

[christianepr · 7/10 · 30 June 2023]

One has to feel sorry for that dark historical period, but it is somewhat unjust to focus on Canada only when this was done all over America...

Just Google "human-rights/residential-schools-in-canada-and-the-us"

"Efforts to eradicate indigenous culture in the US began early, with denominations of Catholicism and Protestantism creating missions focused on indigenous education starting in the 1600s. These missions, crafted to convert indigenous people into the Christian faith, burdened their students with unfair education and disproportionate labour."

"1879: A new system developed with the establishment of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School (1879-1918) in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. It was marked by its significance as the first federal off-reservation residential boarding school and further influenced the systems in Canada and Latin America with its philosophy of complete assimilation through cultural genocide and strict military discipline.

Like the missions before, the Carlisle school stripped its students of their indigenous culture by implementing strict rules stating that each student was to take up a colonist name, clothing, the English language, the puritan religion and cut their hair. Maintaining ties to their culture was strictly prohibited, and students would face corporal punishment for breaking these rules. In some cases, older students were forced to physically punish younger students."

Considering that "In the US, the Department of Interior has identified 53 burial sites and expects this number to grow with further investigations of the recognised 408 US boarding schools." chances are that Hollywood will be next to make movies on that subject...

Sad film with an excellent plot.

[LaxFan94 · 7/10 · 26 July 2023]

I couldn't help but cry throughout this whole film because of its sad nature. NO child should have to go through what those poor kids had to go through, NO ONE! This kind of thing never happened to non-Indigenous kids because their families would never put up with that nonsense. But only Indigenous kids were forced to go through with that. Of course, this not only affected the kids but also their families. Some families like the one I saw in this film, were forced to sign away their children's lives. If parents refused to sign, they usually went to jail. This was commonplace in real life as parents hated the very thought of being forced to send their kids to death camps like those darn residential/boarding schools. Anyway, I give this one a 7 out of 10.

Amazing film about dark history of the residential school system

[Brittany224622 · 9/10 · 11 September 2022]

I saw this movie at Tiff last night. Wow, what a truly moving, emotional master piece. From the acting to storytelling to how it was edited this film is truly impactful. It brings insights into the brutal, horrendous acts carried about by the church on innocent young indigenous children who were taken from their homes and places in the residential school system. A dark history in Canada that NEEDS to be told. The performances from Grace Dove was powerful. I encourage anyone to go out and see this film. It was a movie that needed to made with a story that not everyone knows about. I am excited to see what Marie Clements next ventures are.

Touching, a must see for Canadian youth to understand history

[mortelmansbrxstom · 10/10 · 8 July 2023]

Okay it's quite sentimental, it's not always really goodly played and the structure is quite complex (it goes from a linear story line to cursive with plot twist and half a dozen story line to follow)

But! Scenery is beautiful, some photography and image composition deserve recognition, the stories told are touching and heartbreaking. The Mother-daughter feeling is well expressed to say the least.

It's long at moment and some scenes weaken the film but overall it's a touching film about a tragic subject, where people surprises you and the systemic endoctrination that autochtones preoples went trough will not live you impassible.

Excellent movie but film structure is very difficult to follow

[ctp-71890 · 5/10 · 4 June 2023]

I love the film. A part of the natives life from all over canada. It has to be told. Those people suffered a great deal. I lived in a cree/inuit village in northern Quebec. I know what they went thru. Awfull part of our history. But, the movie brings us back and forth in time from beginning to end. I really don't like that kind of structure. If you look at the series called "Pour toi Flora". It is more detailed, better structured and easier to follow. I gave 5 stars but if it wasn't from that structure problem, I would give a 8. This is the kind of movie, people can learn what really happened before. Lets all learn and make sure we are not still doing it, even now in 2023.

Watch to understand

[jay-bird000 · 9/10 · 6 May 2024]

An absolute must watch if you want to have some understanding of what colonisation did and how much it impacted generations to come. It echo's across all indigenous nations worldwide.

As recent as 2022 and it's still being put through courts systems with the hurt being so very real and raw and the healing has barely begun. Whether your indigenous or not so many generational trauma topics are shown here from after war impact, religious atrocities, stolen children, mental, physical, sexual abuse, lost culture, lost family. So many people will have been been affected from any one of these trauma or another even as little as 3 generations ago.

Bring tissues unless your heartless.