I love this show and always loved Stana Katic as an actress. However, her acting in this episode is a revelation. The only word to describe it is "outstanding"
4 Reviews
Outstanding
samihalo18 July 2020
Not the usual Castle
Jackbv12315 January 2022
This episode steps away from the usual formulas that have made this series so great, and yet it achieves greatness without them.
Castle is less the juvenile. The family bonding is not as much a part if it all. He does get one big clue from family. The banter is largely missing because Beckett is incapable of it for most of the episode.
Stana Katic shows a different side of her acting skill and it's marvelous. Beckett is still drawn into herself, but her facade cracks and crumbles so the viewer can see her at her most vulnerable.
I do love the episodes where Castle shows his brilliant deductive skills and he's on fire in this one. Even so Beckett is totally the center of the story.
Castle is less the juvenile. The family bonding is not as much a part if it all. He does get one big clue from family. The banter is largely missing because Beckett is incapable of it for most of the episode.
Stana Katic shows a different side of her acting skill and it's marvelous. Beckett is still drawn into herself, but her facade cracks and crumbles so the viewer can see her at her most vulnerable.
I do love the episodes where Castle shows his brilliant deductive skills and he's on fire in this one. Even so Beckett is totally the center of the story.
Minus the comedy
lor_22 November 2011
I have mixed feelings about this "Castle" segment, not a jump-the-shark outing but clearly a departure from the series' various premises. The IMDb leads off with "Comedy" among the show's genres, but by design there were zero yocks this time out.
Also missing in action are Castle's family, his mom & daughter who add so much life to the series, probably a calculated scripting ploy. Instead we have intense, quite melodramatic focus on Beckett and her life-sapping neuroses recovering from a near-death shooting, and having to hunt a sniper on the loose in Manhattan.
Stana Katic carries the story -she looks different (careful makeup & hairdo work to achieve the effect) and her acting is strong. I was surprised to see that Jon Huertas was elevated in effect to the male lead -Fillion was present and doing his thing, but faded into the background a bit as Huertas asserted himself and literally saved the day.
There's nothing wrong with trying for a serious tone in a series like this, and I particularly appreciated the strong scenes of Katic and her shrink, which pointed towards further examination of the depths of Beckett's character (especially her mania for resolving the case of her mother's killing) in the future.
But eliminating of the banter, romantic innuendo, light touch and self-mocking tone that has made "Castle" a fan favorite was a mistake in my opinion. It would be like tacking on a late '40s entry in the Nick & Nora theatrical THIN MAN series done in classic film noir fashion -one could imagine William Powell pulling it off (just as Dick Powell proved to be an unlikely but memorable film noir hero), but what a horrible idea that would have been!
One more criticism: if the writers are serious about getting serious, I wish they would take the time to beef up or spotlight Penny Johnson Jerald's character. She is merely functional, barking out orders and presenting a strong facade, but this is purely 1-dimensional. Obviously her "24" role of the president's wife was a career peak, but more significantly it permitted her the chance for bravura acting, shading and creating a villain of Shakespearean depth. To waste her in a token "tough-talking boss" walk-through is ridiculous.
Also missing in action are Castle's family, his mom & daughter who add so much life to the series, probably a calculated scripting ploy. Instead we have intense, quite melodramatic focus on Beckett and her life-sapping neuroses recovering from a near-death shooting, and having to hunt a sniper on the loose in Manhattan.
Stana Katic carries the story -she looks different (careful makeup & hairdo work to achieve the effect) and her acting is strong. I was surprised to see that Jon Huertas was elevated in effect to the male lead -Fillion was present and doing his thing, but faded into the background a bit as Huertas asserted himself and literally saved the day.
There's nothing wrong with trying for a serious tone in a series like this, and I particularly appreciated the strong scenes of Katic and her shrink, which pointed towards further examination of the depths of Beckett's character (especially her mania for resolving the case of her mother's killing) in the future.
But eliminating of the banter, romantic innuendo, light touch and self-mocking tone that has made "Castle" a fan favorite was a mistake in my opinion. It would be like tacking on a late '40s entry in the Nick & Nora theatrical THIN MAN series done in classic film noir fashion -one could imagine William Powell pulling it off (just as Dick Powell proved to be an unlikely but memorable film noir hero), but what a horrible idea that would have been!
One more criticism: if the writers are serious about getting serious, I wish they would take the time to beef up or spotlight Penny Johnson Jerald's character. She is merely functional, barking out orders and presenting a strong facade, but this is purely 1-dimensional. Obviously her "24" role of the president's wife was a career peak, but more significantly it permitted her the chance for bravura acting, shading and creating a villain of Shakespearean depth. To waste her in a token "tough-talking boss" walk-through is ridiculous.
Alex is REALLY annoying
nemesis-8829 March 2022
Sure, the entire NYPD cannot guess what painting it is. But instead of the experts in the numerous NYC museums, it's Castle's daughter who suddenly exclaims "chiaroscuro". The most annoying detail is that she mispronounces it as "kyaro-suro". And then immediately gives the wikipedia definition of the style and comes up with two names, one of which is of course what they were looking for. Meh.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
