The Flying Sailor (2022) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Imagistic, almost mystical interpretation of a near-mythic event
wall175 March 2023
So let's start out with the inspiration here, which is not a spoiler since it's all over the previews and PR for this little vignette: the real-life Halifax explosion of 1917, which was the largest artificial explosion in the history of the world until the atomic bomb was developed and tested. It was a cataclysm that has defined Halifax in some ways ever since, both for the stories of shared hardship and survival and the many little stories -- perhaps apocryphal -- that have spun out of it.

In this particular case, the inspiration was the story of a sailor (the first officer of a cargo ship, in real life, a regular swabbie in this film) who was blown by the explosion quite far, landing with his clothes entirely off. In real life, a number of people were blown far and survived, thanks to the curvature of the hills around Halifax providing landing zones at just the right part of the arc of their flight, although perhaps not so far as the tag on the film suggests.

Exactly true or not, doesn't really matter. In fact, the question as to whether he's alive or dead is central to how to read the film. It's an imagistic montage of life, death, and the universe, not a story per se, a kind of cross between "Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" and the final sequence from "2001: A Space Odyssey" with a touch of that old staple of math class, "Powers of Ten" thrown in.

The animation is lovely and engaging, and the sense of jeopardy is heightened by the literal exposure of the sailor having his clothes blown off (tastefully but anatomically correct in its depiction, nota bene for the squeamish).

The film is in parts that mirror the flight of something blown by an explosion; in the middle is a sort of hanging moment, where the viewer is in mid-air, and whether there will be a second half or a "happy" resolution is very much uncertain. Very nice filmmaking.

This was our second favorite, but among the members of our party who saw it, we differed on the best of the five Oscar nominees, and if we'd used ranked choice voting, this would have come out the winner.

In any event, kudos to the filmmakers for this little gem.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An interesting take on flashes before a death
UniqueParticle18 February 2023
The animation is incredible and music is great I do agree most shorts seem to have great music so maybe that's tedious but well done for sure! Not sure if id agree with the person that gave this a 3 but anytime flashes of images happen in other cinema I love it a lot usually it's different overall this is an incredible short decent for Oscar recognition and probably won't win. The surprise of it all is extraordinary and I always love pianos maybe cause I'm autistic they are a great ambiance to me! The animation is quite impressive more than anything else and I hope some appreciate this odd little short.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"We pretended to believe him"
boblipton19 February 2023
The Halifax Explosion of 1917 is an established fact, with devastation wrought that raised a hue and cry about spies. Amidst the tragedy, one sailor was found more than a mile from the harbor, naked. The story was that the explosion had ripped his clothes off and blown him about two kilometers, with no harm.

That's one explanation, although I can think of others. In any case, his story was accepted, and this Oscar-nominated short form Canada's National Film Board offers it as a cartoon.

In the past, the Oscar nominees for best animated shorts have been plagued with pieces that could have been done easily as live action. None of this year's fall under that curse, nor the one about "animated radio", a lecture with some pictures. Unfortunately, as beautiful as this is, it's not a story, it's an anecdote.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
the cigarette
Kirpianuscus31 December 2023
In Halifax harbour, a colision between two ships. One of victims of explosion - a sailor jump, for two kilometers, pushed by blast. The skin of film - the life flashbacks, from childhood to the life in Marine, conflict against a mate, a game . And , again. Techical, more than interesting. But the end is so brutal than a sort of dessapointment becomes fair.

First , because it has an obscure purpose . To remind the explosion ? Maybe is it enough. To suggest an experience, eccentric , special, strange and a miraculous survive ? It just well works in this sense. Or, maybe, to offer one of stories so loved by inner child inside us . For this, just applauses.

In short, an Oscar nominated.

The only problem for me - the impecable survive, in his mouth, of...cigarette.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Flying Sailor
CinemaSerf22 March 2024
It's probably just as well that the eponymous sailor is long dead for I don't think he'd be terribly impressed with the body these animators have decided to give him! He is strolling the harbour of Halifax when a sudden explosion as two ships appear to collide propels him up into the air, strips him of his clothes and plonks him down in a tree some 3km from the site. As he travels we are treated to some reminiscences from his young life, his sailing career and as his life flashes before our eyes we enjoy a gently engaging score from Luigi Allemano that helps keep things moving. This isn't my favourite style of animation - I prefer a little more natural proportion, and I gather that in truth he kept his boots on too! It's quite watchable, but entirely forgettable - sorry.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Art before substance
mickeythechamp26 January 2023
Road to the Oscars 2023. This short is nominated for 1 Oscar and it´s animated short of course. I don´t see this as anything that special. It´s a very artistic short so maybe it spoke to you more than me. I understand and see the appeal, but after watching it I felt like noting in particular was said and happened and I felt no reason to watch this again.

A sailor caught in an explosion see his life flash before his eyes.

The score is really good here. It´s moving and uses the piano well, although I feel like every single short film dose that. Not to make the score sound worse but I think the soft piano has been done so many times it feels like it´s own trope now.

I liked the clashing art styles and especially the beginning. I found some part of it to be art styles not for me like the way the sailor is drawn but that´s a taste thing.

It´s a short that hits the balance between fun and cartoony and contrasts it with seriousness. The opening and the start of the explosion really sets the tone and uses the medium of animation to its advantage to really subvert expectations.

It´s a short about what happens before we die. Allegedly you see your life flash before you and that´s what we see here. It´s not clear cut or anything, the sailor is seeing small glimpses of his life and nothing that coherent. It works wonders but creates this weird feeling movie without much form. But I guess that's the point. How do you make a life flash before someone without making it weird? It´s a really artistic interpretation first and a movie with any substance second. Personally, this didn't speak to me, but maybe it´ll speak to you. I see the artistic craftmanship here as well done, but it doesn't resonate with me in any way.

Overall, I see the short as entertaining enough, but without saying much. It´s capturing a moment in a beautiful way and uses both music and animation to its advantage, but other than that, it´s nothing too special too me.

Oscar predictions: I haven't seen the other animated shorts yet, but if this is winning it must have been a dull year for animated shorts. It wouldn't make me mad, but just make me shrug.
6 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
What would he have been thinking?
classicsoncall24 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I've never been big on feature length animated films, but when I had the opportunity to see all five contenders for this year's Best Animated Shorts Oscar, I thought why not. Quite honestly, this one didn't really appeal to me, primarily for its artistic style. Supposedly based on the real life story of a sailor thrown clear a distance of two kilometers when his ship was blown up, it suggests images that one would see in the moments before death, the proverbial 'life flashing by in front of your eyes'. Given the subject matter, I would have preferred a short form documentary about the actual event which might have shed some light on how and why something like this could have occurred.

This picture is a contender for a 2023 Oscar in the category of Best Animated Film Shorts. I was lucky enough to catch it along with the other four contenders for this year's Academy Award at the Paramount Theater in Middletown, New York. If not for this limited showing, I don't know how else I would have been able to see it. So, Congratulations to the Paramount for making it available to enthusiastic cinema fans like me.
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The Flying Fatman
jack_o_hasanov_imdb5 March 2023
An Oscar-nominated 8-minute animated short film. I said wow. If an 8-minute animated short is nominated for an Oscar, I must watch it. Luckily it's uploaded on Youtube. I watched. I did not like at all. First of all, although the shooting style is different, it is very obvious that they use this style to win "awards". They did it this way to be "cool". The story is very simple. I didn't know anything about Halifax Explosion. My positive opinion about the movie was about this event. I'm going to investigate about this accident. It piqued my interest. But this movie was not good for me. The Oscar nomination was an exaggeration.
1 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A simple but genius short
zeisler-6192210 November 2022
This short takes a look at the kind of thoughts that might race through a sailor's head as he was carried through the air by a terrible explosion, such as the one that devastated the Nova Scotian town of Halifax in 1917. You may find yourself scoffing at its claims of truthfulness, but people in Halifax really were picked up by the explosion and deposited kilometers away. In any case, the short is moving and beautiful. Special attention should be paid to the soundscape, which combines a beautiful score with all the sounds a sailor might have heard throughout his life, from his childhood in a grimy port city to the moment two ships collided in a harbour, setting off thousands of tons of explosives.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The real event was spectacular, this short film not so much
Horst_In_Translation10 March 2023
Warning: Spoilers
The National Film Board of Canada is an institution that you always find at the Oscars in the animated short category and 2022/2023 is no exception there. However, it was probably the name of this renowned body that helped "The Flying Sailor" to make it among the final five this year. Forbis and Tilby have a rich history with the Academy and they have collaborated on two other animated short films that managed to get nominated in the past and there was always a bit of a ten-year gap you could say. The first nomination came in the first year of the new millennium and Tilby has another nomination from almost a decade earlier. Their newest work we have here has also garnered some awards attention especially in America, but also in Europe. I am not sure why though. These eight minutes were not particularly good. I would say it was both mediocre in terms of story-telling and animation. A bit of a pity. I expected more here. There are no talking characters, so we also do not have any voice actors. What we do have is a man who, as the result of an explosion, was "flying" several kilometers through the air and he lived to talk about what happened.

The by far most (almost only) interesting thing about this film is really that it was based on an actual event. The man you see here existed in real life and survived this catastrophe if you wanna call it that. The film heavily relies on this real-life reference. It is mentioned more than once in this pretty short film (even for a short film it is a short film) that it is not a fictitious work. So if Tilby and Forbis succeeded with anything, then that they made me curious to check out the actual events from back then that were relatively early in the 20th century if I remember correctly. I am sure the family and grandchildren, or maybe those are not alive anymore either, are fairly happy that there is this little film about their ancestor. I am not sure if you could have turned the story into something longer, but if so, you would have needed a great deal of fiction writing and this would have gone against the big idea in general here. That is all then, I assume. Nothing else really stayed in the mind here except maybe that the guy was naked throughout the film. For me, this is the weakest link from this year's Oscar nominees in the animated short film category. I would be shocked if it actually wins. It is also the only one from the quintet with an imdb rating under 6/10 at this point, even if not by much. As you can see from my rating, I think it is still too high. I give "The Flying Sailor" a thumbs-down, even if the title is a perfect summary in three words here of what happens.
0 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Well done! But it's not a history lesson.
wgfaej12 April 2023
Great short on just one storyline of the many available on this horrific event.

If you want to know more about the explosion then search it, there's plenty out there. Don't assume this short is anything but that, a short of one person's story. Don't rate it poor because you want it to be what it's not.

These take a LONG time to make, appreciate that.

I liked the music, the flashbacks, the colouring, the rawness, right down to some gestures the sailor makes. I won't give it away, it's a short after all.

You can watch it on NFB website and youtube. NFB stands for National Film Board of Canada.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Underrated
Rectangular_businessman30 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I personally think reviewers are way too hard on this short, often claiming it didn't deserve its nomination for Best Animated Short.

I for one, has many reservations towards the Academy and the way in which the nominees to different categories are chosen. To be honest, most of the time the nominations for best animated short seem to be picked at random, with plenty of questionable omissions and forgettable winners.

But I don't think this is one of those cases.

In all honesty, I must say I enjoyed this way more than An Ostrich Told Me the World Is Fake and I Think I Believe It. (I recognize the effort made in that short, but I simply couldn't get into it)

There is effort, poetry and beauty displayed here, capturing an instant so unique, so bizarre that it almost seem as something straight out of an urban legend.

But it really happened, and that makes this even more fascinating. More unique and wonderful.

I don't know if this deserved to be win in the category of Best Animated Short. But its nomination was very well deserved.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed