"The Sarah Jane Adventures" The Nightmare Man: Part 1 (TV Episode 2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Ambition and Anxiety
boblipton13 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Luke has gotten into Oxford a year early and even as he prepares to go away, he starts to dream for the first time, only to have nightmares... until it turns out that it is an alien entity that wishes to take his place.

Of the four modern DOCTOR WHO series -- DOCTOR WHO, TORCHWOOD, K9 and THE SARAH JANE ADVENTURES, the last, with its aim set squarely at a juvenile audience is often the most successful replication of the original series. With the limitations on language and subject imposed by its authorities, it must tell its science fictional stories purely in terms of symbols. Although it often fails because of its mechanical uses of those symbols, every once in a while it tackles its subjects as more than kiddy adventures.

It does so here, with its lurking subtext of separation anxiety. Luke wants to go to Oxford, but is fearful of leaving his safe home environment -- a seemingly bizarre assertion considering their regular involvement with all sorts of alien monsters -- and the first episode plays with the possibility that this is normal anxiety. It is only with the cliffhanger that we find out this is real.

The second half works just as well with its scenes of personal nightmare -- although no one shows up without their pants, which is what happens in my nightmares -- but some expert staging, lighting and camera work maintain the bizarre and disquieting atmosphere -- and the message that runs throughout the series that ordinary people can save the world.

Appreciating this sort of story is something that most adults outgrow -- if the despair of age can be considered adult. Even if you can't, perhaps your kids can. You can enjoy it for the technical excellence -- and the pleasure and hope it brings your children.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Follow Your Dreams
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic23 January 2020
Review of both parts:

This story features a found footage format which provides a bit of variety in style and has quite a scary horror aspect that adds thrills. As a big fan of horror elements in Doctor Who universe stories I find this a real positive.

The story involves Luke planning to head off to University and includes touching and thoughtful observations of teenagers separating from their family and friends to head off to follow their dreams. But Luke becomes plagued with nightmares - having never had dreams of any kind before - of 'The Nightmare Man' who feeds off Luke's fears and anxieties.

The Nightmare Man is a creepy villain played by the excellent Julian Bleach (who has played Davros in several Doctor Who episodes). The threat posed is menacing and the way it is interwoven into the drama of Luke leaving home is clever. Lis Sladen is a superb actress and as well as her usual wonderful performance we see her again prove she can transform herself into very convincing, different roles as we see her as an unsettling, frail, old lady.

Tommy Knight had been a great member of the young cast since the pilot episode and it is sad to see him preparing to leave. As always his young friends are also brilliantly acted.

There are a few scenes less impressive than the rest but overall this is a very good story.

My ratings: Part 1 - 8.5/10, Part 2 - 8/10. Overall - 8.25/10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Bleach shines in this series opener.
Sleepin_Dragon4 January 2024
Luke has progressed so rapidly at School, that it's been decided he can get into Oxford a year early, but just days before he's due to set off, he starts having nightmares, nightmares about being rejected by those that love him.

This is a really nice series opener, I'm sure we've all experienced a nightmare or two in our lives, and it doesn't really matter at what age, they're unpleasant, the idea that there's someone or something behind them, great idea.

Those nightmare sequences do look really great, they are creepy and sinister.

It really does feel as though things are changing, they none of them look like kids anymore, both Luke and Clyde look so much older.

I just love Julian Bleach, he's been a wonderful Davros, and he's excellent as The Nightmare Man, there's almost something of Pennywise about him.

Girls Aloud - Untouchable, great track.

8/10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed