- After the homecoming dance, the liars try to sort out the devastation; "A" isn't the only one sending Aria texts as tensions rise in the Montgomery household..
- Open at the dance with the other three girls trying to find Emily. They hear her phone and follow it to the chemistry lab where they see the broken glass and blood. Cut to Toby (with a cut face) sitting in his car in front of the ER with Emily in the back unconscious.
Aria and Spencer tell Emily about what they found in the file. The two girls think Toby must have killed Alison, but Emily isn't sure it adds up.
A cop tells Emily's mother that Emily was dropped off at the hospital by Toby, who then disappeared. She seems surprised Emily was there with Toby. Toby returned home the previous evening to drop off his family car and promptly left on his motorcycle.
To this point Emily has said only that she was injured by tripping at the dance. Spencer and Aria want them to tell the police everything other than the file. Aria's parents aren't speaking to each other. After the other two girls leave, Hanna tells Emily that A sent her the picture of her and Maya kissing. Emily is worried about what a relationship with Maya would do to her friendships.
Spencer shows up at the club to talk to Alex. He is still upset about what Melissa said and only agrees to get her a second chance if he gets to plan their next night out.
Aria tries to call Fitz but has no luck. Her parents' marriage is clearly dissolving and it is bothering Mike. Sean sends her flowers with a note thanking her for "keeping him company."
Jenna pays Emily a visit. She is worried about Toby and thinks Emily might know where he is. The police are looking for the file and Jenna thinks there could be trouble if it "falls into the wrong hands." Based on the fact that she has kept quiet about what Alison told her at the hospital, Jenna thinks Emily owes her the favor of getting back the file.
Hanna goes to the yearbook office to take king/queen photos with Sean. While she waits, she talks with Lucas about the dance. Sean arrives and is still clearly pissed about being left the previous night. We see Hanna has Jenna's file in her purse but doesn't answer her phone when Emily calls.
Emily's mother comes into her room and asks about Toby. She's clearly upset Emily went with such an undesirable character.
During the photo shoot Sean and Hanna can barely stand next to each other. Before leaving Sean snaps at Lucas a few times.
Aria's father Byron tells her that he is going to move out.
Emily's mother finally leaves her room which allows Emily access to her cell phone. She tries calling the girls as they pull up to their secret meeting spot in the woods. Aria misses the call as the three girls take the file.
Hanna wants to burn the file; Spencer and Aria think they should turn it in. After a minute of so of yelling Aria grabs the file and tosses it into the river. Immediately after returning to the car Aria sees a text from Emily telling her "whatever you do, don't destroy that file."
Spencer is convinced they won't hear anymore from A. Alex texts her that he has to blow off their do-over date since he has to work. Spencer doesn't but it since the country club is closed Mondays.
Aria finds a sub in Fitz' room. The woman doesn't know when he'll be back.
In the hall Emily tells Jenna that the file has been destroyed.
Hanna goes to see Lucas who wanted to show her possible pics for the yearbook.
Spencer goes to the club and finds Alex is, in fact, working. Spencer takes off her jacket and starts to help.
Aria confronts Sean about sending her flowers. Aria assures him that Hanna loves him and hasn't talked about another guy for year. At this point we see Mike in a fight with another student.
Hanna and Lucas seem to be hitting it off. He shows her funny internet videos and their hands accidentally touch. He tells her he thought Alison was "straight-up evil." They bond on the issue.
Inside a locker in the club kitchen Spencer finds a picture of herself with devil horns. She's upset, but Alex assures her it was done by another member of the staff. He reminds her there are jerks in all walks of life but she walks out.
Emily tells Maya she wants to give their relationship a chance.
After a meeting about Mike's fight, Byron and Ella bicker in the school hallway. He thinks they should be focusing on their kids' troubles and he should stay in the house. She wants him to leave.
Aria goes to Fitz' apartment. Using the key under the matt, she goes inside to hear a answering message from another school referencing his upcoming job interview in New York.
Sean comes over to Hanna's place to help her with homework. Hanna seems to notice that she doesn't like his sense of humor as much as Lucas'.
Spencer returns to the country club kitchen. She and Alex dance, which turns to making out.
Aria wistfully remembers Fitz.
Emily drives by the Cavanaugh place and sees Toby's crumpled motorcycle outside. Jenna is sitting on the stops crying.
Aria suggests to Mike that perhaps their parents separating is the best thing at the moment. He's still very angry.
Byron continues to want to communicate with Ella. She's not interested.
Emily tells Spencer and Hanna about Toby's bike. While they sit there Emily gets a text from A: "Thanks for getting Toby out of my way."
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content