"Supernatural" All Dogs Go to Heaven (TV Episode 2010) Poster

(TV Series)

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
I really enjoyed this one too
MissTofu28 March 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Jared, Jensen and gang put in some credible and masterful performances again. In particular, Sam and Dean's personalities play off sharply in this episode and many moments are really fun to watch.

At first sight, this episode seems extremely bland, with nothing to offer. On a closer look, there are themes of surveillance and voyeurism which parallel and also intersect at a certain point. At what point does surveillance warp into voyeurism? Does it occur by incident or accident or does anyone even care? Traits of ownership, family and protectiveness permeate these themes. I was left wondering as well: who is the true guardian here? Lucky or the woman he watches over? Or are both guardians of one another in their own way?

The contrasting takes on the theme of savior must not be missed either. A monster who looks after a family in his own way versus a cold and ruthless hero whose job is to track a case. When overlapping with the personality of Dean Winchester, these contrasts become even more vivid. At one point, I even wondered who was the real monster here: Sam or Lucky?

There are many other themes present in this episode too but I'll leave them for you to consider: family, what it means to be human, bonds, acceptance versus abandonment, etc.

Again, the monsters in this episode are very humanised and some of their finest moments shine in the later half of the episode as the buildup results in some tight tension and thought-provoking, disturbing or even humorous interactions.

The cinematography is also rather fun to watch and I'm reminded how sophisticated the episodes have evolved over the seasons. There are some very clever shots that alternate from a human's and a monster's point- of-view. Also, I'm sure some might disagree but I thought some of the scenes were full of emotion from the players involved. There were also some really cool and awesome action scenes. Made me feel like I was watching some gangster flick. :P

As for the music? I miss the rock but I don't mind the different style, either. The cinematography and the music made for some very intense action scenes.

Finally, I love how Lucky's situation was resolved: open-ended as things often happen in the real world. One has to wonder how these experiences would impact him though.
18 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I like Lucky but I wish this was followed up on
CubsandCulture31 March 2020
The skinwalkers are one of the more successful monsters in terms of effects from the show. I know they are just dogs but they end up feeling more realistic than say werewolves. Lucky's story is both really creepy, unnerving and also a little sad, touching. He is one of the better one off characters from the show's run.

Soulless Sammy feels forced in this episode Like he went from being Sam but a little off to full-blown utilitarian/psychopath in one episode. The excuse that he is done pretending is too slight to make the change fully believable. This hampers the episode somewhat.

Through the thing that bothers me the most is they never followed up on the skinwalker packs as a source of concern. The episode puts enough stress on the issue that feels like it should have come back and to date it hasn't.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Very Enjoyable...
essentialdiva12 November 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I'm not going to spoil the episode for anyone who's not yet seen it, but I MUST say that I absolutely enjoyed Jared's performance in this one. Not to discredit other episodes because he is a VERY good actor but he reminds me of the "evil" Sam in (one of my favorite ep.) "Born under a bad sign" when they were badgering "Lucky" for answers. Jensen's performance was amazing as usual, but was there ever any doubt? Dean's softer side was so refreshing, but my heart goes out to him in his quest to get his brother's soul back... and Sam confession in wanting it back. I just hope Crowley is true to his word about giving it back, considering his betrayal to Bobby about his soul, but I'm sure the boys will come up with something... They always do. (Total J2 Fan) I LOVE THIS SHOW!!!!!!!!!!
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of the Best Episodes
claudio_carvalho20 November 2012
SPOILER: Crowley bosses Dean and Sam and sends them to Buffalo, New York, to capture an Alpha werewolf that is killing people. Crowley would return Sam's soul if they succeed and bring the Alpha to him. Soon they discover that the killer is actually a skinwalker posing as the family dog Lucky that loves his owners Mandy and her son. He kills those that threaten the family to protect them.

Dean and Sam catch Lucky and they discover that there are thirty skinwalkers living as family dogs and ready to transform their families into an army of skinwalkers. Now Dean and Sam want to destroy the pack and the Alpha.

"All Dogs Go to Heaven" is among the best episodes of Supernatural. The story recalls the first episodes of this series, simpler and with lots of fun. My vote is nine.

Title (Brazil): "Todos os Cães Vão para o Céu" ("All Dogs Go to Heaven")
16 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Skinwalkers
zombiehigh1817 December 2011
Warning: Spoilers
After the last "Family Matters" loaded episode, I don't mind a filler episode. But Man, I like soulless Sam, Seeing Sam as this tough cold uncaring person Vs Dean's softer self is quite amusing. (Ironic change of character since when we first met those guys five seasons ago, Dean was the cold shoot first ask questions later person, while Sam was the softer sharing and caring good guy) Jared Padalecki always seemed to have a lot of fun doing out of character performances on Sam, I enjoyed both the possessed Sam and the Lu-Sam-fer performances very much before and Now I'm enjoying this new version of him.

Dean is still very reluctant on working for Crowley and still resists the idea, But when Crowley threatens Little Sammy (Even if he is not really little Sammy any more), It's only then that Dean has to go with the flow, Yet it's quite a relief he is not willing to jeopardize innocent people's lives in the process. He knows Sam is lying about being the same person he once was and asks him to drop the act, But he is also not giving up on him.

Sam is clearly now more true to himself and to Dean than he ever was, His mean (but hilarious) way of treating Lucky as well as his declaration that he would double cross them if tables were turned comes out sadly funny. He is now indeed a dick and he knows that very well. He confesses that he is better off with no soul because it makes his life and his job easier, he doesn't care about anybody, even Dean, Yet he knows he is missing something. May be his life won't be that easy with an intact soul but he is willing to get it back anyway because it seems the right thing to do.

Do I feel bad about Lucky? The answer is Yes and No. He is a monster, a pervert and he killed people in cold blood (Yes he was protecting his loved ones, but it is still murder) But at the same time all he wanted is to loved by some one, Who in the world wouldn't want that! Sadly but real enough, he didn't get his happy ending. I love dogs, But after this as Dean said, I guess I'll never look at them the same way again.

Finally, Sniper Dean!!!!! Not bad;)
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Kinda gross?
shwetafabm20 June 2020
Idk just the idea of a dog/human thing is ridiculous to me but not in a good way. This episode also didn't have any humour to it except ofcourse the wonderful Crowley.
1 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed