Many of the reviews have mentioned the Kurosawa reference and it is true that this does have the basic structure of The Seven Samurai. Unfortunately, the build up to the bandits attacking the town lacks suspense. The episode does nothing to convince the audience that maybe Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Ahsoka are finally over their heads. In fact, they have handily beaten the same mercenaries before! The battle itself is resolved quickly which makes it nothing to write home about.
My biggest disappointment is that The Clone Wars once again brings up an interesting moral dilemma and then throws it away for a much more boring and predictable plotline. I love the following exchange in the middle of the episode:
Anakin (to the bounty hunters protecting the farmers)- I'm sure you are good at what you do, but you are in way too deep
Bounty Hunter- Says the peacekeeper who fails to keep the peace
Kenobi- The rift in the galaxy is not our fault. If more worlds would stand up for themselves against the Separatists, this war would have been over long ago.
This exchange reveals an interesting aspect of Obi-Wan's character which is that he partially blames innocent worlds for not fighting back. This also makes Obi-Wan seem like kind of an ignorant, arrogant jerk. Many ordinary people do not have the time and resources to resist a heavily militarized invasion. How many farmers submitted to the Separatists to protect their families and move on with their lives? Is it cowardly to not want to essentially commit suicide by taking on a force much stronger than your own? That the village could be trained enough to take on thugs in one day is not realistic at all and the fact that it costs Obi-Wan, Anakin, and Ahsoka nothing to stay and help dodges holding Obi-Wan accountable for his ideology. At the end of the day, there are no consequences one way or another to Obi-Wan looking down at defenseless peasants. It makes Obi-Wan feel out of touch, but I was disappointed that the episode did not commit to the logical end result of that ideology. (I am not saying Obi-Wan needed to be punished but that either he should change his mind and change OR the villagers should suffer from his lack of intervention, but with perhaps the ambiguity that it was perhaps for the greater good. Something along these lines).
0 out of 0 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink