Journey to the West (2021) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Heartfelt and Contemplative in the End
alisonc-16 August 2023
Tang (Yang Haoyu) has devoted his life to the search for extraterrestrials, both as the editor of a magazine devoted to space exploration and as an explorer himself, following up on leads that take him to remote spots where people claim to have seen aliens. As his efforts to keep the magazine afloat are failing, he hears of a mass sighting in a small village in the mountains, and he recruits three others to help him investigate. Once there, he finds an eccentric young man who appears to be the conduit of alien communication, if only he can find one specific location....

This is billed as a "mockumentary" and serves to send up one of the foundations of Chinese literature, which involves a man traveling to the West to locate and bring home Buddhist teachings; here, the tale seems at first a more pitiable and hollow version of the story, but as it develops it becomes something much more, ending as a meditation on the Universe itself. Be warned, however: as a "mockumentary," the filmmakers chose to use hand-held cameras for filming much of the movie, so if you are subject to motion sickness, this movie might not be for you. While I was at first put off by this, by the end of the film I felt very touched indeed, and I'm very glad I saw it.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A interesting find!
mikeyspikey2 February 2024
A well made heartwarming film, interspersed with a whimsical undertone and aptly curated scores. I am searching for similar pieces but at the moment would kind of place it like a feel-good outdoorsy The Office in a different cultural setting. I thought the english translation of the title could be renamed a little better as its namesake is a popular Chinese novel; despite the characters making appearance in the film and the train journey west from beijing to chengdu. Glad to see that it has won several awards and accolades. The director of photography a did a good job in capturing south-western china.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Really sincere
domspencer-4880112 July 2023
It's a really humorous film that treats it's characters with grace and understanding. The humor may not be for everyone but if you are a fan of mockumentaries ND sci-fi it's 100% worth watching. The movie is also a love letter to western China. Having traveled through almost all of China's western provinces, it was so immersive to relive some of these forests, mountains, and country villages. I love that the movie doesn't sugar coat the area and instead showcases the natural beauty of the region. It's also a gorgeous film as it seems like it was shot on location primarily and really made use of the mockumentary format to make an extremely immersive movie for how goofy it is. Overall I think it's really fun and very heartwarming watching this odyssey of a movie.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Indulge in self-expression
e-47824-259601 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Director Kong Dashan says he is obsessed with self-expression. It is difficult for me to det aside time to watch a movie.

I have to say that I'm really looking forward to it.

I was struck by several scenes in the film.

During this movie, I sometimes felt sad, sometimes felt funny, and sometimes felt heavy. When the stone lion was filled with sparrows, I felt very, very shocked. I shuddered and every nerve in my spinal cord trembled when I saw the donkey on the river bank in the deep southwest. Tang Zhijun's neurotic perseverance impressed me so much. I was also impressed by the character Sun Yitong. The ending of the film sublimates the theme and makes people move.

I like it very much!

I'm looking forward to Kong Dashan's future work!
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Tale of Absurdity, Passion and Neurosis
gogoal126 July 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Tang Zhijun's appearance on the stage was unlike any character in Chinese cinema. Between destitution, aloofness, stubbornness, and timid conformity to reality, shadows of Don Quixote and Onegin shimmered around him. Yet, one cannot simply label him as mad or inconsequential. Tang Zhijun, the editor-in-chief of a faltering "Cosmic Exploration" magazine, firmly believed in extraterrestrial beings and was fervently devoted to unraveling the mysteries of the universe. Little did he know that he was the alien on this planet, torn between lofty ideals and the constraints of reality. The film "The Cosmic Exploration Editorial Office" presented, just like Tang Zhijun's character, an amalgamation of absurdity, deep emotion, neuroticism, and a poignant sense of loss. Ultimately, Tang Zhijun discovered the secrets connecting the universe and the individual, as the countless stars within him aligned with the vast expanse of the cosmos. The narration during his nephew's wedding can be seen as a profound realization after his successful cosmic exploration, or perhaps as a colored self-consolation of an idealist who had faced failure.

Regrettably, after Tang Zhijun's stunning entrance, his character underwent a minimal transformation. The near-tragic gait and the comedic muttering seemed to dissipate and disintegrate, akin to repeated annotations following a noun's appearance. The original character setting failed to undergo cell-like division, and the film's narrative revolving around Tang Zhijun became drawn-out and fragmented. The transformation began with the search for a higher purpose. It began when he found companions. It began when the exuberance of Tang Zhijun's lively loneliness softened. Rebellious idealism thrives in a relatively closed space, fermenting its power in solitude. His zeal burns with the cold stares and spit of others, only to evaporate and dissipate under the scrutiny of sunlight. The film employed a relatively convenient method, with incessant interventions from eccentric characters and rural folklore, diluting the resolute and desolate determination that says, "Even if all abandon me, I shall proceed." Surprisingly, the middle-aged woman Qin Cairong became an exception, as her current hysteria paled in comparison to her former biting sarcasm. The wandering monk, the itinerant poet, the wanderer with no place to call home, and the middle-aged woman grappling with the secular world-all of them are extraterrestrials from some distant planet.

True passion is detached from others, unaffected by either disapproval or approval. The idealist stands in opposition to the entire world and the era. The radiance of the idealist lies in its dimness. The strength of the idealist stems from his weakness. The pride of the idealist is a rebound from a certain degree of self-abasement. He oscillates between disdain for companionship and the yearning for recognition, repeatedly coming back and forth.

The film failed to capture the complexity, entanglement, conflict, and contradictions. The character development bore semblance, all earnestly indulging in incongruity, respectfully mocking one another. They entered the world with an ascetic posture, endeavoring to present the clumsiness that follows the refinement of intelligence, like heavy grains from coarse materials. In terms of storytelling, it exhibited an elitist expression of overflowing desires, shaping central ideas as the plotline. The film exuded a densely hollow atmosphere, nonchalant tension, and an approach to heavy matters with lightness. "The Cosmic Exploration Editorial Office" derived its creative impetus not from aesthetics but from attitude. Aesthetics represent the shortest line between two points, the mortise and tenon structure of cause and effect. In contrast, attitude is an unrestrained impulse, the instinct that springs from the depths of life, eager to explore while glancing around. For example, the film attributed multiple metaphorical meanings not to different characters and actions but to various objects, like stone lions, sparrows, donkeys, carrots, and the journey from Beijing to the countryside and then to an abandoned mining area. It was like capturing a feature film with the mindset of a short film.

The viewers' admiration is also worth contemplating. It is necessary to discern whether the characters they identify with represent a form of self-rejection and whether their appreciation merely reflects self-admiration. The knowing smiles during viewing represent both introspections after tearing oneself apart and the secret relief after self-reflection-hoping to be like him, yet being grateful not to be him. Moreover, this is not merely the viewers' perspective; it may even reflect a certain subconsciousness of the creators. The enigma of human communication is eternal.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed