Stonewalling (2022) Poster

(2022)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A stunningly good yet daunting picture
mateuszmiter28 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Stonewalling begins with a shot of Chinese students, including Lynn (Honggui Yao), taking part in a glamorous party in 2019, where they discuss their plans for the future, like moving to the U. K. for a much better, luxurious life.

Lynn's boyfriend is very much one of the main participants of the gathering, though, his girlfriend seems rather uninterested and quickly leaves due to pain in her breasts.

During the party, it is said that everyone should take life as it comes. This poetic, almost motivational speech paints a perfect contrast with what's about to happen next.

Lynn and her boyfriend live together in a life where they don't have many complaints in terms of money. He paid for Lynn's English lessons and college, so they will be able to leave the country in the future. Still, Lynn doesn't seem satisfied with the state of her life, and doesn't seem to have much control of it, though, it changes when she discovers her unwanted pregnancy.

Despite her boyfriend wanting to have Lynn undergo an abortion, the pretty, young woman sees an opportunity to finally take action, motivated by her mother's financial problems. She's presented with an option to give birth and give up the baby to another family, to which her mother owes money. She accepts the offer, however, being pregnant doesn't stop her from working tirelessly to earn some money.

Stonewalling is a movie with many themes, and its two-and-a-half-hour run allows them to grow and prevail. But it's not a movie with a racing tempo. It's rather a slow journey that pains the viewers with each next shot.

While pregnant. Lynn enlists herself in a company that offers women's bodies as surrogates to rich families, while also helping her parents in owning a limping pharmacy clinic. Suddenly, the environment changes from lavish apartments in Changsha to dreadful, gray pictures of Chinese suburbs. The movie's beautiful, detailed, and almost flooded with different items, yet, they are absorbing.

This often agonizing but hypnotizing camera work blends beautifully with Honggui Yao excellent work as the movie's lead. Her emotions are often as bleak and subtle as the control the character has over her own life, but as it takes flight and accelerates, so does her work in front of the camera.

While exposing some valuable insights into Chinese suburban communities and their life, which rarely make the papers of Western media, Stonewalling also questions the unbreakable bond between a mother and her child. Can the bond be broken even if it hasn't been molded in the first place? Or is it always there from the first signs of pregnancy?

These and other themes are dancing with each other on a daunting stage, which turns even more gloom once China is struck by the first signs of COVID-19. We all lived through the pandemic and each have our own horrible memories of it. With the virus becoming a pivotal part of the movie's setting, the ongoing horror suddenly feels slightly familiar.

By the end of the movie, Lynn returns some money to his boyfriend, about which he complained throughout the two-and-a-half-hour spectacle. She intends to pay him back for English classes, with him refusing to take them as if he learned his lesson. Yet, Lynn keeps holding it in the air, insisting for him to accept, as if she also has learned her lesson, at last.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Dreary
gbill-748779 December 2023
That giant statue of young Mao's head in Changshan looking so glorious is such a contrast to this young woman in her claustrophobic life. Despite what appears like opportunity in going to school to learn English and becoming a flight attendant, there is a sense of quiet desperation for her character, with her mother a link in a pyramid scheme hawking the cure-all "Vital Cream," and she herself looking into selling her eggs for cash. She listens in as wealthy clients examine young girls as if they were livestock, the scenes of which are perhaps even more disturbing because they are so matter-of-fact, but can't do it herself because she's found out she's pregnant. To pay off a lawsuit aimed at her mother and to conceal the fact she's having a baby from her boyfriend and others, she hatches a scheme to essentially sell her baby. It's a sobering window into commodification and dehumanization which certainly had merit, but for me the film was too ponderous, far too long at 148 minutes. Ironically, despite the length, I'm not sure I ever really learned enough about this character. In any event, it was too dreary for me to enjoy.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed