The Divide (2021) Poster

(2021)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Social Critique without stereotypes
rfndayitabi15 August 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Raf (Valeria Bruni Tedeschi) and Julie (Marina Fois) are separating after ten years together. However, both will find themselves in the emergency room, because Raf fractured her arm following a trivial fall on the street.

Yann (Pio Marmai) is a truck driver, who participates in the protests of the yellow vests. He is in the hospital because he was injured in the leg during the violent clashes with the police.

The three find themselves in an overcrowded emergency room, where Kim (Aissatou Diallo Sagna) works as a nurse. The hospital hosts a variegated and suffering humanity, more or less patient waiting to be assisted, while outside the scuffles between demonstrators and riot officers continue.

In the film, light moments alternate with other dramatic ones. Clear elements of social protest emerge from the latter.

There are several fractures represented in the film: the one that is separating the Raf-Julie couple, the fracture of Raf's arm, those that are stirring in the French social body.

The issues Catherine Corsini focuses on are not those relating to the coexistence of different cultures or homophobia, but concern the distance between the state and the citizens whose interest she should pursue.

An abysmal distance, destined to fuel the movement of the yellow vests, which includes Yann, a young truck driver forced to still live with his mother, due to starvation wages.

If Yann belongs to the working class, Raf and Julie's bourgeois world isn't faring much better either. The latter runs a small publishing house in the world of comics, for which she works as a designer Raf, but things are no longer going as well as they used to be.

Kim is a black nurse forced into grueling shifts, which go far beyond what is theoretically permitted by the employment contract.

The hospital itself is dilapidated, with false ceilings falling on patients, a staff that has to jump through hoops to guarantee a minimum of service, also having to deal with a structural shortage of drugs and equipment.

What is missing is certainly not the will of the operators, but the resources invested in the public service.

And the initial distrust, also due to the class difference between Yann on the one hand, and Raf and Julie on the other, dissolves in the face of the dramatic events that the three have to face in the emergency room, also caused by the wild and irrational repression of the movements. Of protest by the police.

Events whose impact is mitigated by the profound humanity of most of the health workers, Kim in the lead. But in the real world, no one can work miracles ... in this film Corsini tries to represent with realism the tragic events linked to the manifestations of the "yellow vests", but using the point of view of characters who live these experiences from a particular angle, which lends itself to creating situations in which there is also space for humor.

Characters sometimes too over the top, as in the case of Yann, but which allow the director to show what happened without falling into the trap of didacticism, excessive trivialization or stereotypes of politics.

Characters who find themselves overwhelmed by events much larger than themselves, who find the only way to salvation in the rediscovery of their most deeply human dimension, destined to make any difference in class, gender and skin color irrelevant.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Efficient in the drama genre even though it lacks subtility
The Fracture tells us the story of a group of people that nothing brings together who end up in the hospital emergency room during a Yellow Vests demonstration that goes wrong. A demonstrator injured by the police (Pio Marmaï, perfect), a middle-class couple in the process of separating (Valeria Bruni Tedeschi and Marina Foïs), and of course the medical staff around them.

Many themes are addressed: the demands of the yellow vests, the functioning and difficulties of a hospital emergency unit, the states of mind of Valeria Bruni Tedeschi (brilliant in the interpretation of a selfish and unbearable character). By confronting a yellow vest injured by the police with a bourgeois woman with existential problems regarding the existence of her couple that can seem completely outdated compared to what is happening around between the police smoke and bludgeon the Yellow Vests and the other patients in the emergency room. The film is pretty good in its component of not favoring one side over the other or at least developing the characters well from each point of view.

So it's a rather realistic social film, not necessarily subtle, but it gets its messages across clearly and asks some questions. This is one of its important virtues. It is perfect for provoking debate. On the technical components, there is nothing to say. The actors are good with all the pathos their characters carry.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Social and physical divide too.
searchanddestroy-121 June 2022
Using a good metaphor in the title and the story, this typically French social drama depicts France of the late 2010's and early 20's, the yellow jackets crisis and hospital structural, financial problems, the difficulties that doctors and nurses have to face to do their job properly. Social fracture illustrated thru a broken leg and elbow, excellent metaphor. The main problem here is the comedy line, too devastating to permit any tension or even emotion. But acting is flawless, especially concerning Marina Fois and Valeria Bruni; the Yellow Jacket character is however a bit overplayed, too much to be realistic. I could not resume this movie till the end, precisely because of those comedy lines.
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Crazy country
aleskander31 July 2022
Godardian & critical French film which uses pan right-pan left, tracking & hand held shots generating a crazy atmosphere in a hospital which represents in a kind of metaphor, the political and social French fracture and disenchantment.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Would have been even better if not so politically one-sided
euroGary12 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Seen at the 2021 London Film Festival, 'La fracture' (English title: 'The Divide') would be very much at home on the stage, as it is mostly set in one location (a Paris hospital emergency department) in which a small group of characters play out their stories while confrontations between Gilets Jaunes protestors and the police take place outside - confrontations which eventually threaten the safety of the hospital itself and those in it.

The long-term relationship of lesbian couple Raphaëlle (Valeria Bruni Tedeschi) and Julie (Marina Foïs) is on the rocks when Raphaëlle damages her elbow, putting her career as a cartoonist in jeopardy ("It looks like a knee on my elbow!" she wails when she sees the swelling). Truck driver Yann (Pio Marmaï, as grubbily sexy as ever) is brought into the hospital with a leg riddled by police bullets and uses much of the time he spends waiting to espouse the Gilets Jaunes' cause. Rounding out the quartet of top-notch leading performances is Aïssatou Diallo Sagna, very convincing as a harrassed but competent nurse (she is, apparently, a medical worker in real life).

This is a very political film and that provokes its weakness - just one point, but a major one: it is extremely one-sided in its sympathy with the Gilets Jaunes' cause. To some, the Gilets are a group of heroes fighting for 'economic justice' and political reforms; to others they are a mob bent on achieving - at best through disruption, at worst through violence - the reversal of political decisions taken by a democratically-elected government that can anyway be voted out at the next election. Discuss! But the film puts forward so heavily the 'heroes' argument that by the time, close to the very end of the film, a police officer comments how scared he has been by the violence - the first time any even remotely anti-Gilets comment is heard - it is as if director/co-writer Catherine Corsini has included that scene merely to refute any allegations she has produced a very long party political broadcast. But by that stage it is far too late - Corsini's colours are nailed very firmly to the mast. Personally, I prefer to be treated as adult enough to make up my own mind, so at least one sympathetic main character putting the French State's case would have been welcome.

Do watch this film - the story is engrossing and the performances are brilliant. But - whatever your political opinions - do not treat it as a documentary!
10 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed