"Lie to Me" Pilot (TV Episode 2009) Poster

(TV Series)

(2009)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Everyone lies
MaxBorg896 June 2010
As far as unusual angles for a cop show go, Lie to Me is most certainly a winner: a series about a man who specializes in telling whether a suspect is lying or not, based solely on body language and so-called "microexpressions". That it works is essentially down to three things: it's based on a real person (series consultant Paul Ekman), Samuel Baum's writing is precise and entertaining at the same time, and the cast is very impressive.

Leading credentials belong to Cal Lightman (Tim Roth), founder and leader of the Lightman Group, an organization that is hired by various government agencies and/or private companies when cases get - you guessed it - complicated. Working with him are psychologist Gillian Foster (Kelli Williams), who tries to focus on the human side while Lightman is very cold and rational, and Eli Loker (Brendan Hines), whose penchant for "radical honesty" isn't as charming as he'd like to think (when coming late for work he calmly admits he got drunk the night before). While working on a delicate matter (a minor who's facing the death penalty for allegedly killing his teacher), Cal also hires airport security officer Ria Torres (Monica Raymund), whose track record indicates she's a "natural" when it comes to spotting lies.

What sets the show apart from any other cop show (except possibly the CSI franchise) is its staggering attention to detail: as Sherlock Holmes used to say, all the clues matter, and no other series highlights it more. Whether it's an eyebrow twitch or a seemingly casual shrug, nothing escapes Lightman and his team (see the highly entertaining teaser sequence), and that makes for a fascinating watch episode after episode (plus, it's intriguing to see guest actors deliberately pull off what normally is considered completely involuntary). Also, on a writing level, the show isn't afraid to explore delicate subjects, often with surprising results, as this episode's cases show (the second one involves a politician suspected of paying for sex).

More than anything, however, the show really stands alone thanks to Tim Roth's sardonic central performance. Not that the other three regulars aren't up to it (Hines' earnestness provides a nice contrast to Williams' warmth and Raymund's youthful energy), but it's the leading man's uncompromisingly quirky work that gives the show its admittedly weird heart and show (just watch the scene between Lightman and his daughter). Besides, it's a pleasure to finally hear a British actor speak with his own accent, as opposed to Hugh Laurie (House M.D.) and Damian Lewis (Life): it adds that extra dimension to a character who is already memorable.

The truth (pun not intended) is all in the details, and based on the pilot, Lie to Me has everything going for it. A brilliant program, worth watching over and over again.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Great Show Out Of The Gate, And That's The TRUTH!
cchase26 January 2009
With my schedule already overstuffed with new shows I like PLUS returning favorites, I would rather not risk tipping the whole thing over into chaos with one more, thank you very much. But if I HAD to do it, I'm glad it's with something like LIE TO ME. Especially since an actor as great as Tim Roth doesn't just stroll onto the small screen everyday. For him to risk getting tied up in a series, it's got to be something good, and the premise of LIE TO ME is irresistible.

Roth plays Cal Lightman, the one guy you would probably never want to have as a boss. That's because Cal's specialty is dealing with human behavior, in this case the fine art of lying. Well, make that lie DETECTION. In a fascinating conceit, Lightman and his group study everything from body language, to skin temperature, to something called "micro-expressions" - facial tics and tells that can go by in the blink of an eye, but to the trained observer can reveal everything; from what you had for breakfast on your birthday seven years ago, to what you REALLY think about your spouse. Yep, it's that detailed, that incriminating and that startling.

Like most crime procedural shows, the pilot episode shows Lightman dealing with several cases at once, while also setting up his relationships with the rest of the cast: business partner and resident psychologist Gillian Foster (THE PRACTICE'S Kelli Williams); "radical truth-teller" and assistant Eli Loker (Brendan Hines), who has no filter on his ability to edit his feelings or opinions whatsoever, and newcomer Ria Torres (Monica Raymund), a former TSA agent who has an uncanny natural ability to sniff out prevaricators.

A fascinating concept, indeed, if a lot higher than most TV shows shoot for. But we wouldn't expect any less from the same production company that gives us ulcers every week with '24'. One can only hope that an attempt isn't made to shoehorn LIE TO ME into that same kind of genre. This plays much better to the same kind of audience geared towards something like CBS's THE MENTALIST or USA's popular, long-running MONK. Given the proper amount of room to breathe and episodes that continue to be driven more by characters than by car chases and explosions every ten minutes, this is a show that might actually gain some staying power - a minor miracle these days when shows have about the length of a "micro- expression" to gain an audience.
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Truth Behind the Lie
claudio_carvalho28 September 2017
Dr. Cal Lightman (Tim Roth) is an expert in facial expressions and body language and works seeking the truth behind the lies of people under investigation of the police and authorities. His assistants are Dr. Gillian Foster (Kelli Williams) and Eli Loker (Brendan Hines) and they have just hired the TSA agent Ria Torres (Monica Raymund) to join their team. Dr. Lightman is presently working in a murder case where a teenager Jehovah witness is accused of killing his teacher. He is simultaneously hired to investigate a congressman that will be accused by the press for having sex with a whore in a brothel.

"Pilot" is a promising episode of the series "Lie to Me". Dr. Cal Lightman is an interesting character capable to identify the truth in what people in general is saying. The conclusion of the show is witty. My vote is eight.

Title (Brazil): "Pilot"

Note: On 01 January 2024, I saw this episode again.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Great Show, But If You're Going To Bring JWs Into It...
jmacdono12 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This was a great first show; I loved The Mentalist, and this followed a similar theme, but the science behind it is a little more solid. The only thing that annoyed me was their depiction of Jehovah's Witnesses. They portrayed them as religiously devout, but to an extreme. JWs would never talk to someone about the evil of the world, nor would the son say things like most fundamentalist Christians who say we can't know God's plan. They could have done 10 minutes worth of research on Jehovah's Witnesses to show them in a more accurate light. Plus, that stupid poster on the wall in the kids wall? No JW has that. Plus, Jehovah's Witnesses don't keep their kids out of school to shield them from the evils of the world, any more so than non-JWs do. Most Witnesses put their kids in public schools.

That's my only real beef with the episode though.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fascinating concept and interesting characters, questionable acting and production, episodic format I hate you
igoatabase19 June 2010
I wasn't expecting to find their applied psychology techniques so fascinating. I already knew a few things about body language and facial expressions but I definitely learned a lot. For example I didn't know a liar kept eye contact so it's natural to look somewhere else when you're thinking about what you want to say. So the episode was very insightful but I found the acting wasn't genuine enough and it was obvious the performers forced their expressions to make us believe in the concept. However using historical photos to assert their arguments was quite convincing.

As for the characters I was gladly surprised by them because for once I think they're well balanced. The leader keeps a distance, his female assistant skills were also well used and the younger mates also contributed to make their team as likable as possible. The protagonist can detect lies because he's a micro expressions experts but he knows that using it is not always appropriate even if he apparently can't control his ability. As for his assistant she's a words worm and knows how to convince someone, by using affirmations for example, but also to analyse what they say. In fact she reminded me of Dune by Frank Herbert but her gift is real, she doesn't magically charm people with her voice. An other character I liked was the guy who always tell the truth. He's not Jim Carrey but definitely someone you can relate to. As for their new female recruit she's gorgeous but I'm not really fond of her for the moment even if her more natural approach could be interesting to follow. It contrasts with the protagonist more rational and mechanical one. Last but not least they made me laugh from time to time so you should instantly fall in love with them.

But even if it has many qualities I also noted a few flaws. First the production quality is average and I suspect some budget cuts because at times it reminded me of shows like Mental where even the lighting has issues. However it's not that bad and even good enough so immersing into their universe shouldn't be a problem. Second I worry that the writers have used all their bright ideas in the pilot to amaze the audience. I'm sure they have kept some bullets for the whole season but the concept has its limit. Third and last I can't help comparing it to Castle and CSI: NY, other procedural shows. The very first minutes you know the format is episodic and I just hate that. They didn't even try to develop a major arc to intrigue us. Right from the beginning they started a new déjà vu investigation. In fact there were two arcs but none of them really interested me. There was nothing original about the story and only the fresh ideas made it entertaining.

For me such a format can only ruin a show because it depends on the quality of its many scripts. I can't imagine how great Lie to Me would be if it had the strong format of shows like Dexter ! One major arc with a serial killer to catch and new investigations from time to time. But if you don't mind its procedural approach then I can only recommend it.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
An okay pilot, but it doesn't leave you wanting more.
ASuitableUsername28 July 2023
After 14 years since its first airing I thought I'd give Lie to Me a go seen as its available on Disney+, however the last 14 years haven't been fair to the series as the show feels dated.

Perhaps its unfair to judge an entire show from its pilot, but I need a great pilot to keep me hooked. Whilst I enjoy Tim Roth's acting, the pilot didn't leave me with a desire to watch more, the series simply wasn't for me.

If you're into phycology from an entertainment perspective this show probably will be for you, but if you're looking more for a crime show with more traditional stories you might find yourself getting a little bit bored.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed