Eve (2008) Poster

(IV) (2008)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Wow....
planktonrules9 May 2010
This is interesting--a short film directed by Natalie Portman. This is actually the second short from her I have seen, as she also directed a segment in last year's "New York I Love You".

The film begins with a rather daring into. You see bits and pieces of a clearly elderly woman getting herself ready for the day--with makeup and a wig. When you see that the woman with age spots and fake hair is played by Lauren Bacall, you really have to respect her for allowing others to see her as being older and vulnerable--something I am sure many glamorous older stars would never allow. Thank heaven Ms. Bacall is NOT one of these vain older ladies. And, speaking of not vain, it's also nice to see Ben Gazzara--post-cancer and post-stroke with his speech clearly affected. Once again, I praise these actors, Ms. Portman and the film for being honest and not hiding old age! Too often, the covert message in most films is that there are either no old people or they have to be perfect or they have to be adorable--all of which are stupid stereotypes.

Kate (Olivia Thirlby) drops by her grandmother's house as Grandma is getting ready for a big date. However, Kate seems a bit concerned--after all, these elderly people plan on doing a lot of drinking and so she tag along. Surprisingly, she does NOT drive but lets Joe (Gazzara) do it--for a while! Once he demonstrates he is a menace to everyone else on the road and sidewalk (a prerequisite for getting a drivers license here in Florida), she drives them home instead.

Later, when they return home. Bacall does something even more daring--and removes her makeup and you see her in all her glory--not just bits and pieces like the beginning.

Overall, while the film hasn't got much in the way of plot, I was just shocked that Portman can both direct and write. The combination of great daring, fantastic and evocative music and interesting characters make for a lovely film--one I think is better than the recent crop of Academy Award-nominated live action shorts. Too bad this one was overlooked. Plus, imagine a film where elderly people have normal desires, drink too much and are simply old...and look it! And, in the process, they aren't made fun of, made to be cute or are caricatures!
16 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Okay for a first film, not enough otherwise
Horst_In_Translation25 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Eve" is a 20-minute (with credits) live action short film from 2008, so this one will soon have its 10 anniversary. It was written and directed by Natalie Portman, who was in her mid-20s at that point. Her name attached to the project is probably also the main reason why this little movie is still somewhat famous. Or it could also be the three big names in the cast and you have to say on a positive note that young Olivia Thirlby holds her own very well next to these 2 acting legends in here. I am a bit surprised she did not make it bigger in the last years. For both the late Lauren Bacall as well as the late Ben Gazzara, it is one of their final career efforts, though not very final. I got curious about this movie here as Portman directed her first full feature film recently (and starred in it), so I wanted to take a look at what other stuff she has done behind the camera. I would say that this work here is solid for a rookie filmmaker. Her direction is sometimes pretty good, but I just never felt the script good enough to do justice to the talent of the three actors involved in the center of it all. Such a shame, this definitely could have been much better. I have not made up my mind yet if I like the soundtracks. All in all, this was a pretty mediocre watch and nothing about it really stands out to let me recommend checking it out. Watch something else instead.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed