Stargate: Atlantis (TV Series) Identity (2008) User Reviews

Hard to rate

[fig-75275 · 7/10 · 23 May 2021]

This episode is ok, it's a 7 or an 8. The best thing is that it is kind of an SG-1 episode, but set in the Atlantis universe. The woman that has taken over Jennifer's body is a little bit like Vala, and it did make me think that Atlantis could do with a Vala like character. There are only two episodes left now though, so that's not going to happen :-(

Who's Responsible?!

[rcsipe · 6/10 · 13 July 2021]

The boss wants to know "who's responsible for stabbing Zelenka!" Are you serious? Atlantis doesn't have cameras everywhere!? The Dr isn't just acting a "little" weird. After the things they've seen, the fact that she is WAY off should be obvious to the crew. REALLY unbelievable. Bad start, but the premise of the episode was OK I suppose.

Filler pure and simple.

[Wirefan122 · 5/10 · 9 March 2016]

I am not aware if the writers knew the show was to end in 2 more episodes but my guess would be a 'no'. This is a filler episode with no plot advancement whatsoever. Filler episodes are certainly OK with me but they do tend to drag on.

We start with someone else's mind in Jennifer's...and it goes from there. She looks in mirror and sees Jennifer and we see the other woman. Long story short, her and her 2 accomplices go from planet to planet stealing artifacts (killing if necessary, apparently, to get them).

Fake Jennifer stabs Zelenka and the base figures she is not who she says she is. Meanwhile real villainess' body is on planet where she just got caught doing the burglary. Turns out when they were burglarizing a Ancient artifact area she inadvertently turned on a device that switched the minds. There's a much longer explanation but...

Of course, the villainess Neeva Casol is now scheduled to be executed for previous crimes within 24 hours so the chase begins. Blah blah blah all turns out well. As mentioned before, filler episodes are just fine, but not much more.