"CSI: NY" Personal Foul (TV Episode 2008) Poster

(TV Series)

(2008)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A pleasant surprise
LoveIsAStateOfMind29 December 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I just have to say Lindsay and Flack have some of the best facial expressions, especially in the scene when they're interviewing the suspect.

  • LINDSAY ROCKED. Her shooting Danny down several times made me SO DAMN HAPPY and just the way she did it and Anna's acting and ...... glah. I love her. "Honestly? I don't know." - I hope that Rikki leaving for good (and I'm sure the writers have to have enough sense for this to be a definite end of that whole storyline) doesn't mean that Danny feels like he doesn't have to come clean about the whole thing to Lindsay.


  • Thumbs up to the Lindsay/Flack/Danny scenes/working together etc. They have a great dynamic and play off each other well. LOL at the disapproving look Lindsay gives the guys when she's with the cheerleaders. She can't see them but she just knows that they're watching and leering at the girls. Haha.


  • But I disapprove of Flack's "You should **** Lindsay off more often." He might not know exactly what's going on and what Danny did but he must have some idea and he should be giving Danny a kick up the backside not joking about it.


  • The whole fat cheerleader thing was so ridiculous it was funny. (Also obvious. As soon as I saw the photo I knew it was going to be her) and the whole interview just underlined the point like the writers were poking fun at themselves, knowing it was kinda stupid.


  • I love the whole walking in the rain idea. Don't know why, it just seems very Lindsay.


  • Oddly enough I'm choosing to ignore the whole phone call itself. Okay the Lindsay part of it I liked but I have such an intense dislike for Danny that I still just wanted to slap him - like how DARE him even say those things to her knowing what he's done. Ugh. Points for the goofy photo of him coming up on her phone though.


  • Really why do characters always do this? A massive sign saying the station's not going to be open for months and you still try to open the locked doors?! Some points do not have to be emphasised. I think the audience can interpret what this means thanks.


  • I liked the interplay of the Lindsay-cab / Reed-cab thing. Anyone think that it would be a good thing for Lindsay to have been the taxi-cab's victim? It'd certainly give Danny a wake up call. Too fanfiction? (Also possibly contradicting with my point of wanting them to be apart but eh....) I know it works equally well for the Mac/Reed relationship though.


  • Talking of the whole serial killer taxi cab thing. I wasn't fond of the idea at the beginning. A procedural crime drama should only have a certain number of multi-episode story arcs / season and especially since this is a shortened season it seems this is just one too many BUT this episode has won me over. Kinda. As long as they resolve it well.


  • Ahh Reed. You'll forever be "My name is Cassidy." LOL. Anyway, TPTB get points for not bringing up Mac's wife's son and then pretending like he doesn't exist any more. They've managed to characterise him really well in the short scenes he's gotten in the past couple of episodes and it's an interesting way to bring him back.


  • The Mac/Stella scene and the confidence that Stella has in him and the team and the way she tries to restore his faith... and the way her voice catches when she says "we have to." - And it actually seemed that Hawkes did something for once. Don't know why since he didn't do anything he doesn't usually do but I think the absence of Adam meant he got more screen time and I dunno, it's a good thing.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Kiss Me Deadly
ccthemovieman-11 December 2008
Warning: Spoilers
The Taxi Killer" story is dragged on for at least another week as it not solved and another victim, which we see early on, is dumped somewhere in the same tarp with the same letters and numbers scratched on her dead body. Real progress, however, is being made and it looks like it could be wrapped up in the next episode.

However, it also looks like Mac's annoying reporter/adopted-like son "Reed" might be the next victim! That's okay with me; the kid is a royal pain in the butt. I doubt if the writers will kill him off, though.

Meanwhile, the major case of this episode is solving who killed a season-ticket holder of a New York pro basketball team. (They use some other name than the real-life Knicks). The guy had just had his "lucky number" called and went down to the court to try a half-court shot for a million bucks. Shortly after making the shot, he drops dead. CSI workers discover he was poisoned by one of the cheerleaders. Someone had deadly lipstick!

Another subplot involves the continuing saga of Danny and Lyndsay as the latter now plays hard to get after being disappointed several weeks earlier by Danny, who showed he wasn't really that interested in getting serious with her. The writers aren't overdoing this angle, which is good......just giving us a little bit at a time.

Overall, another interesting episode that went by very quickly.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed