Circus of Life (2019) User Reviews

One of Pakistan's most shunned pieces of artistic endeavors shines yet again!

[ahmedhasan-85889 · 7/10 · 11 August 2023]

Finally, finally, finally I get to see "Zindagi Tamasha", a brainchild of the immensely talented Pakistani director, Sarmad Sultan Khoosat, that had not seen the light of day in cinema screens across the country due to its criticism and depiction of the mainstream religious clergy dominating the socio-political spectrum of the country.

Unfortunately though, the only medium graced by this movie, a considerable loss for all associated with the creation of this gem, was You Tube. Khoosat, in his introductory note, is visibly emotional as he lets his creation out of a cage imposed upon it by fundamentalists that have, for decades, proved to be an impediment to free artistic growth and expression in the country.

"Zindagi Tamasha" depicts an aging man who still has an air of youthful exuberance about him along-with a genuinely affectionate heart trapped in a quagmire of criticism and societal rejection when a video of him replicating a childhood dance to his friends is posted on social media.

"Zindagi Tamasha" depicts the human need to categorize events and characters into "right" and "wrong", "good" and "evil". It talks about how an intellectually starved society has no space to cultivate acceptance and fluidity of thought, emotions and opinions. Rather, every individual is expected to fit a mold, a pre-conceived caricature of righteous and non-righteous beings. In this belief, a transgender individual is an inherently evil being while an aged man who recites religious hymns is inherently pious, devoid of any interest in activities that do not fit the ideals of a dominant sect.

Voices like Sarmad Khoosat are key in the preservation of artistic expressionism in a country that has, in recent years, lost its voice out of fear and repudiation. In a spine-chilling scene a typical Molvi (cleric) unabashedly blackmails the protagonist, Rahat Khawaja, in a crowded gathering by saying, "Lagaun naara?" ("Should I raise the allegation?"), referring to the weaponization of archaic blasphemy laws prevalent in the country that to this day are used to stifle dissenting voices and minds.

A true gem of Pakistani cinema and a beacon of hope for independent, thought-provoking film-making in a country that is in dire need of it.

good movie but not great.

[rizw4n · 7/10 · 5 August 2023]

Just watched it after they released it for free on youtube.

The pace of the movie is rather slow but the acting from the leading characters is very good.

There aren't any dialogues or lines in the movie that stand out (comparing to other hit Pakistani movies like Bol/Khuda Kay Liye) but some scenes are very powerful. I really liked the scenes involving the hypocrisy of the clergy.

The soundtrack is nice as well.

Some, especially the international audience, might find the story slow or boring and might not really understand the subtleties of the topics in the movie, but it is quite relevant to the Pakistani society.

It's a good effort by everyone involved.

Loss for Cinema

[uphazstephen · 8/10 · 5 August 2023]

Heartbroken for director Sarmad Khoosat, as his cinematic masterpiece was denied a theatrical release by higher authorities, settling for YouTube. This country's treatment of artists deprives us of quality cinema.

Undeniably one of Pakistan's finest cinematic creations, portrays the poignant story of an elderly Naat reciter who commits a mistake, not a grave sin. Tragically, he has been outcast by his community, including his own family, solely due to his age and religious profession.

This movie bravely shows the extremism in religious clergy, and ironically extremism is the reason why this movie is not released in cinemas.

P. S : This movies shows us that extremism is not always means to kill other people.

Sometimes extremism means to not forgive others for their forgivable misdeeds.

Based on truth

[vaibhavfeb · 10/10 · 19 July 2020]

One of the best movies of Pakistan a dark side and truth about their society.

Masterpiece

[asharwaheed-08512 · 10/10 · 31 December 2021]

It's a Masterpiece. Can't wait to wait it. Everyone needed to watch this movie. It's on another level. It is a beginning of a great era for Lollywood.

Zindagi Tamasha - A Poignant Mirror of Pakistani Society

[aaasifjamil · 10/10 · 7 August 2023]

In an industry saturated with formulaic plots and superficial narratives, "Zindagi Tamasha" stands out as a breath of fresh air. Directed by Sarmad Khoosat, this thought-provoking film delves deep into the complexities of Pakistani society, presenting a true portrayal that resonates with its audience. Through its powerful storytelling, evocative performances, and a meaningful message, "Zindagi Tamasha" earns its place as a masterful cinematic gem.

Set in the heart of Lahore, the movie revolves around the life of an aging, humble and devout naat khawan, Rahat Khawaja (played magnificently by Arif Hassan). The story takes an unexpected turn when a private video of him goes viral, putting his reputation and dignity at stake. As the film unfolds, we witness the hypocrisy, judgment, and unforgiving nature of society, especially in the age of social media.

One of the film's strongest elements is its unflinching honesty in depicting the prevalent issues within Pakistani society. It fearlessly explores themes of religious fervor, moral complexities, and the repercussions of modern technology on human lives. The director masterfully showcases how a single mistake can snowball into a devastating nightmare for an individual, forcing viewers to reflect on their own behavior and prejudices.

Sarmad Khoosat's directorial finesse shines throughout the film. The carefully crafted scenes, nuanced character development, and attention to detail make the story both immersive and relatable. The use of traditional music and qawwali in the background enriches the film's emotional impact, seamlessly connecting with the audience's hearts.

Arif Hassan delivers an award-worthy performance as Rahat Khawaja, effectively portraying the inner turmoil and emotional vulnerability of his character. The supporting cast, including Samiya Mumtaz and Ali Qureshi, deserves applause for their authentic and compelling portrayals.

At its core, "Zindagi Tamasha" imparts a powerful message about empathy, compassion, and the consequences of intolerance in a society grappling with its own flaws. The film urges viewers to question their perceptions, biases, and judgments, emphasizing the importance of forgiveness and understanding in the face of societal pressures.

In conclusion, "Zindagi Tamasha" is an exceptional film that dares to challenge norms and open dialogue on issues often swept under the rug. Its honest portrayal of Pakistani society, coupled with stellar performances and a thought-provoking message, makes it a must-watch for anyone seeking meaningful and socially relevant cinema. Sarmad Khoosat has crafted a poignant mirror reflecting the flaws and virtues of Pakistani society, and "Zindagi Tamasha" deserves all the accolades it receives.

OUTSTANDING

[tradism · 10/10 · 21 March 2024]

Watched a while ago, it is absolutely an outstanding effort by all means. Get ready to face a real face of Our Pakistani Society which claims to be religious but not even closer to ISLAM.

We must accept some reality and start correcting ourselves. Sarmad is one of the finest young promising fellow showing his commitment towards his duty as a director.

This commercial cinema probably didn't accept it from earning business point of view, but it has earnt respect for this incredible work. Each detail was taken care of. It must be released globally with subtitles. Congratulations to everyone involved into the project.

A controversial topic but Nicely done

[cawaqas · 7/10 · 8 August 2023]

Loved the ending, as I was expecting controversial ending, but Mr. Sarmad covered it well. Told us about the sensitivity and didn't hurt our feelings at the same time.

The story n cinematography is excellent.

The scenes of "Mehfil.a.Naat" are the peak of story but not doing any unnecessary drama was the maturity of Director.

I think if someone had watched it n then commented there must not be such huge uproar from religious people.

Dear Sarmad Thanks for releasing it I wish could pay you for this.

Tell me how can I Send you Money so that you keep us entertained without suffering any financial loss.

Worth Watching. Lovely Movie,

Another Masterpiece that Pakistan Cinema missed!

[hafiznumair · 8/10 · 25 August 2023]

With another powerful story by the one & only Sarmad Khoosat, we see another Film based on the Exploitation of the Religion in the country and how it effects the norm. The characters were made alive by Arif Hassan & the all famous Samiya Mumtaz. With the release we see the same political problems we have always dealt with before. Before watching this, I had only seen clips of the movie but the whole watch on YouTube just made me appreciate the craft even more. The powerful & intense moments reallt hit the heart and mind in moments unnoticed. We see the typical Khoosat style in this film with long shots & realistic settings. Although the movie conveys a clear message of exploitation and effects of society on a person, I can't help but feel this is just a hint of something more complete yet to come. But talking about the Technical aspect which my analytical brain couldn't help but see, the edits especially the SFX seemed a bit choppy & repetitive considering this was being made for Cienema release. All in all, would have loved to watch it on the biggest possible sceen but the art still lives on. More power to you Sarmad Khoosat!

Amazing and extremely realistic movie

[meluck · 10/10 · 6 August 2023]

Well done team Zindagi Tamasha, especially Sarmad for creating a master piece. Your movie Shows an ugly face of an extremely religious and sick society. Which refuses to accept the reality and ban all efforts which shows the reality.

You should be proud that you are in the category of Faiz, Faraz, Manto, Ismat and Jaun. I hope this movie will make people think of the suffocating and conservative atmosphere they live and they need to breathe in the fresh air of freedom of speech and freedom of expression. And break all this barriers and finally live like humans. I hope I will see this change before I die.

Storytelling is a recurring issue that many Pakistani films face till today

[Hussain-AL-Naseer · 5/10 · 6 August 2023]

Keeping all controversies aside, the state's seriousness towards the performing arts genre becomes evident through the Directors' three-minute message before the film begins.

The movie started off with a powerful and engaging introduction, capturing the audience's attention from the beginning. However, as the story progressed, it seemed to lose its direction, and the film began to unfold shot by shot without a cohesive narrative, leaving the viewers somewhat perplexed.

Despite the film's weak storytelling, it was evident that the plot held great potential, presenting a captivating premise. Regrettably, this struggle with storytelling is a recurring issue that many Pakistani films face. It is essential for filmmakers to enhance their narrative techniques and pacing to fully realize the potential of their stories.

Amidst the film's shortcomings, the performances by Arif Hasan as Rahat Khawaja and Samiya Mumtaz as his wife were truly commendable. Arif Hasan's portrayal of Rahat Khawaja exuded strength and conviction throughout, while Samiya Mumtaz's portrayal of his wife added a touch of warmth to the movie. Their chemistry was delightful and proved to be the main highlight of the film.

In conclusion, while the film's promising beginning and stellar performances contributed to its appeal, the lack of a cohesive and well-developed storyline hindered its overall impact.

Remarkable and thought-provoking art movie

[bbaig-76576 · 10/10 · 6 August 2023]

Directed by Sarmad Khoosat, "Circus of Life" is a thought-provoking and introspective exploration of the challenges faced by an elderly devout Muslim named Rahat Khawaja. The film delves into themes of identity, societal expectations, and the complexity of navigating a strict Muslim society.

What makes "Circus of Life" truly impactful is its portrayal of the conflicting reactions Rahat faces from his immediate circle. While his wife understands and supports him, Rahat discovers that the society he once felt a part of is quick to criticize and judge him.

Sarmad Khoosat's direction skillfully captures the subtle nuances of Rahat's journey. The film offers a calm and detailed picture of the challenges faced by individuals in a strict Muslim society when they step out of their expected roles.

Khoosat's film succeeds in initiating a dialogue around societal expectations and the pursuit of personal identity.

To conclude, "Circus of Life" is a remarkable and thought-provoking art movie. Sarmad Khoosat's direction, accompanied by the powerful performances, brings to life the complexities of a man's struggle for self-expression within a conservative Muslim society. Through its calm and detailed storytelling, the film urges viewers to engage in challenging conversations about societal expectations and personal identity.

Masterpiece For Pakistani Audience

[talharafique-17035 · 10/10 · 17 February 2024]

Zindagi Tamasha, titled Circus of Life in English, is a 2019 Pakistani drama film directed by Sarmad Khoosat. It premiered at the 24th Busan International Film Festival, and won awards at Busan and at the 2021 Asian World Film Festival in Los Angeles.

People who have dissent taste in movies its a must watch for them.

All the character's acting in movie was wonderful. Especially the main character's innocence was portrayed beautifully and the society and culture of Pakistan was shown as its in real life. How internet leaves a major mark on Khawaja Rahat's character and how society reacted to it was flawless.

Harsha reality of our society

[shalbukhari · 10/10 · 5 August 2023]

How much we are suffering due to lack of knowledge as a society and how much we have to learn about respecting others. How much so-called clerics are using religion for their own benefits. Being a true believer of Islam, I think that this religion is full of peace and gives us the teachings of live and let live. However only handful intolerant, illiterate and ignorant people using the name of Islam to get votes in the election. You will know about all these harsh realities of our society when you watch this movie, especially when you know the background of why it was banned in Pakistan. Hats off to Khoosat films.

Zindagi tamasha bani, Duniya da haasa bani

[sayamasjad · 9/10 · 23 August 2023]

It's a truly remarkable film that takes a bold look at the complexities of society. The movie presents a heartfelt narrative that reveals the hidden truths and double standards prevalent in our world. Through its captivating storytelling, the film dives into themes of judgment, hypocrisy, and the misuse of religion.

Sarmad Khoosat's directorial finesse is evident in every frame. He didn't disappoint me, and my love for his direction and acting has increased. The movie doesn't just tell a story; it raises thought-provoking questions about our society's values and behaviors. It was an emotional rollercoaster and I felt the pain of the main character.

A must watch for everyone, don't know who are the idiots who banned it.

This movie is a must watch!!!

[waqasr · 9/10 · 17 August 2023]

I will not talk about the story because I don't want to spoil it for anyone but this is an original and very unconventional story to say the least. Very gripping and deep that it will touch your soul.

Every single person in this movie acted so well that you can't believe that you have not seen their faces before in any mainstream projects yet. The lead actor just owned the role and made it his own. I have no words to explain where he took me with his acting but OMG he was damn good.

This movie shows you what is going on in this word at the moment where people's private moments are not private any more due to the miss use of technology.

This is the best movie I have seen so far which came out of Pakistan this year and it even beats all Bollywood movies I have seen this year as well hands down!!

Zindagi tamasha bani! Black Mirror-Pakistan

[choprapals-79521 · 8/10 · 19 August 2023]

Kudos to creative team for dealing with subject of masculinity, patriarchy and religious orthodoxy in one go. Personal is political!

Characters i liked- Rahat had a stoic presence in the way he dealt with the mayhem around him. He was just being human and enjoying his little delights. Alas! Society thinks otherwise Son In Law - Such a sweetheart. Mediator between daughter and father. Supported the family without any judgment throughout. World needs more men like this

Being from a neighbouring country, could relate to each and every nuance portrayed in the movie.

Breach of privacy and memefication of someone's personal moments, that's how our society is behaving. Mercilessly, creating stir in one's life.

Appreciate the way LGBTQ community is showcased in many Pakistani dramas. Quite sensitive.

Overall, a must, is you want to watch drama without theatrics!

An western story forced into a Pakistani context

[jareers · 5/10 · 6 August 2023]

'Zindagi Tamasha' captivates visually, encapsulating the essence of Lahore with finesse and palpable affection. The level of craft and dedication poured into the film is evident throughout.

However, the narrative appears to rest heavily on the inspiration of a real lesser-known video, where a maulvi apologizes for a dance perceived as 'inappropriate' in the Pakistani context.

How come a family living in the smack middle of Lahore in the 'mohalla', with a purportedly famous and reasonably sought-after naat-khwaan husband and a seemingly wise wife, is practically enjoying the isolation of an east coast metropolitan american family? Why aren't neighboring women barging in to help the ailing woman every other day? Why doesn't the mother speak to her daughters every day, telling them what their father is going through? Why aren't 25 or so mohalledaars, co-naat khawans forcefully arranging a baithak, panchaiyat, jirga, anything to let the sought-after naat khwaan, a person they knew for ages, make amends for his mistakes? In fact, why doesn't everyone already know that the guy liked Punjabi movies, songs and the dance for like 30+ years now? He didn't seem to be hiding it at all. None of it makes sense in that context, in that culture. If you have lived it, you would know that there is almost no concept of privacy in those lives.

Also, just find the original video on Youtube, and you will see people actually commending the man for accepting his fault in the comments. This culture has serious issues, it is invasive, brutally insensitive, horrible at times, but apart from that one 295C 'sin' which everyone knows, it forgives every other, even the most atrocious sins of men, particularly religious men. I seriously doubt if the original maulvi's career took more than a few months hit.

I know it is a movie, and it can take all the liberties it wants as long as it doesn't take a moral position and is simply aiming for entertainment, because when it does take a position, I believe it will be judged for its internal consistency. Here it is clearly about an issue of this society, but not remotely as grievous as it is imagined here. It would have been a completely different story altogether if it was about a woman, but here, to perpetuate a narrative about an imagined issue from a society brimming with so many real, relatable issues, it seems lazy.

Furthermore, it has that banal character of a self absorbed, young adult daughter with victim complex, who is utterly blind to her parent's struggles. Which daughter in Pakistan can break all those mental structures she grew up with, even if she wants to, to scathingly tell her father to wear her mother's clothes as hatefully as she did? I always felt Hollywood hates young women, the reason it always make them seem venomous under the garb of empowering them. Sad to see it imported here as well. It would have been far more believable if it was her in-laws that had made her to be critical, or to ostracize her father, where she would have to maneuver between saving her marriage, and her love and empathy for her old father. Instead what we get is a mindless import of Hollywood-style storytelling, which is disappointing, particularly from a director like Sarmad Khoosat, whom one expects to be more discerning about integrating foreign narrative structures.

In sum, while 'Zindagi Tamasha' is a visual delight, its portrayal of cultural nuances and dynamics leaves room for deeper introspection, but despite my strong disagreements, I would still strongly recommend it, and would urge everyone, who can afford it, to watch this on Vimeo to support the studio, and support independent film making in Pakistan.

Mind blowing

[ihatemyemailaddress · 10/10 · 5 August 2023]

It's such a pity this masterpiece was banned and received unnecessary controversy.

The poster was perhaps misleading.

This film beautiful shows hypocrisy in society. The irony is censor board allows cheap tacky dances in films to pass but not this?

I would urge people to watch it and then judge it and not listen to the rumours that are unrelated to this film content.

This film deserved the awards it has received internationally, it was a movie that pushes all boundaries in cinema, hope this does not put of people from experimenting and creating fresh content.

Well done Mr Khoosat for creating this masterpiece.

Realistic to the point to scare viewers

[zm-296-458388 · 10/10 · 12 August 2023]

The movie has a gripping beginning and it keeps mesmerising you stronger and stronger ... it's such an accurate depiction of what happens in reality that it's scary... movie was banned in Pakistan due to similar angry allegations on the movie that has already been depicted in this movie...

The speechless parts of acting seem to leave more resonating memories. Direction, acting, situations, everything about it is amazing. While tamasha / circus has been made out of the main character's life it's amazing that no mourning our shouting has been used to depict it ... the silencing drowning death is felt by viewers without traditional over reactions common in regional work. Real masterpiece reflects the director's and team's deep understanding of media and their acting educators' fantastic success ...

If you have been slightly effected by any similar situation in your life, watching it may give you due nightmares ... and also give you a deep drive to acknowledge and think about possible ways out...