The best parts of this film are the ones where they explore the mystery - the interviews with various townsfolk. It works the most as an earnest horror movie about ghost hunters that aren't charlatans. I'd give these segments 7 stars on their own.
The worst parts of this film are the denouement - the tension felt forced, the urgency felt artificial, and the acting really took a turn for the rushed and unbelievable. The main characters, who have been more than acceptable up to now, somehow lose the ability to act.
The film seems to forget about all of the other people besides the original inhabitants that were somehow lured there. There's no explanation for them, and no resolution, either. The movie would have been better off excluding them from the mystery altogether.
Moreover, the death of post-death dialogue of one of the main characters is so incredibly anticlimactic and off-screen that the movie would have been better off leaving it out, or letting the guy survive - it would have been better to see him fight off the guy, die to the smoke inhalation and then get CPRed back into existence.
We were promised a terrifying ultimate evil and it did not deliver. The filmmakers would have been better off recognizing the limitations of their budget and talent and revising the ending to do what they can do well, rather than doing what they can't do terribly.
The worst parts of this film are the denouement - the tension felt forced, the urgency felt artificial, and the acting really took a turn for the rushed and unbelievable. The main characters, who have been more than acceptable up to now, somehow lose the ability to act.
The film seems to forget about all of the other people besides the original inhabitants that were somehow lured there. There's no explanation for them, and no resolution, either. The movie would have been better off excluding them from the mystery altogether.
Moreover, the death of post-death dialogue of one of the main characters is so incredibly anticlimactic and off-screen that the movie would have been better off leaving it out, or letting the guy survive - it would have been better to see him fight off the guy, die to the smoke inhalation and then get CPRed back into existence.
We were promised a terrifying ultimate evil and it did not deliver. The filmmakers would have been better off recognizing the limitations of their budget and talent and revising the ending to do what they can do well, rather than doing what they can't do terribly.