Whitetail (2021) Poster

(2021)

User Reviews

Review this title
14 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
You ain't no cowboy.
nogodnomasters25 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Frank (Paul T. Taylor), Tom (Tom Zembrod), and Autistic Donnie (Dash Melrose) go hunting in West Texas following the suicide of Virginia. She was Frank's wife, Tom's sister and Donnie's mother. Donnie has never been hunting and not someone I would give a gun outside of Texas. Frank has rough edges and doesn't get along well with Tom who is less rugged. While hunting they find a man (Jason Douglas) who has been shot. Frank is suspicious and believe he is a bank robber who has a large sack of cash. He claims he is going to start a church with his life savings. There are two other men well armed looking for him and the money. They cross paths and somehow don't see things eye to eye and since they all have guns and it is Texas. . .

Not many characters and all men. They didn't even get their deer. (Sorry for that spoiler.) Wasn't a fan on how they ended the story the slow burn story.

Guide: F-word. No sex or nudity.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Couldn't make a worse movie if you tried
frazenk10 December 2021
And boy does it feel like they tried. If anybody tried to tell me that the people making this were trying to actually make a good movie I would have to laugh at them and call them a liar. Theres no way somebody could make something this bad on accident.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Give it up
greenbennygreen22 December 2021
The team behind this is the same team behind so many other terrible movies that have to buy ratings to trick people into thinking their good. It doesn't work and people aren't convinced. The movies are bad and if enough people just come out and say it then the illusion is broken.

Sorry but this is another bad attempt. Give it up.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Who cares !
rotini-5258624 October 2021
Stupidest movie I ever watched . No plot. Little Rickie...dumb dumb dumb. Acting is horrible. Nothing happens the first hour. Is it Tom ? Tom? The suspenseful music is suppose to add drama to a drama less movie. Dumbest movie ever made. Period ! You boys got yourself into a pickle ???? Who writes this garbage ?
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Better than I thought it could be
jacksonmaze28 January 2022
I rented this without much hope of it being good.

I was pleasantly surprised to not only be entertained but actually caught myself thinking about the film afterwards.

This is not a horror film. That's the first thing people should know. It's also not an action movie. The scenes are intense and the overall message may be too depressing for people to like but I thought this was exceptionally well made. Definitely not represented the right way through the fact it was in wal-mart and the cover looks like it's a different kind of movie. Why this wasn't in festivals or something is beyond me. My wife and I try to go to the Atlanta Film Festival when we can (we've been three times) and this would have played really well there.

THE GOOD Very good movie and has some depth I honestly didn't think it would have. Opening scene was great. Complicated move. Music was good. Another scene was a shootout between the characters. It was done with a great deal of reality. Was a sense of dread.

THE BAD - The film may be too slow for American audiences. The scenes are great and the pacing is pretty good but there is a lot of talking and one must be patient to get the pay off. Most people my son's age (20s to 30s) just don't want to watch slower paced films. Not that that is bad but it's just a matter of preference.

The film also has a rather drab ending that I didn't like but I guess understood it was that way for a reason.

Pessimistic message.

Overall I recommend but you need to know what film you're renting or buying before you do it. If you think it's a typical thriller you'll be disappointed. If you want to watch a film that hits you in the gut, then you'll like it.

7 of 10 - mostly because the acting was extremely good and I loved the old school look of it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Bleak as heck
eongamerdude20 July 2021
Bleak as heck film I saw at Texas tHeater when it showed. This is the type of film that makes you think. I got to hear the producers talk about it for a few minutes afterwards and they seemed like they were really passionate about it. The camera and acting was great. I was surprised because I don't know any of the actors but holy s**t they were good!

Some people will not like it and some will love it. Not sure if I'll ever watch it again because it really was bleak but it's a good film. But i was interested the whole time and there were some really intense and scary scenes.
5 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Surprisingly good.
nelsonjack-9906112 October 2021
I watched this because I saw Paul T. Taylor was in it. I grew up a Hellraiser fan and while I didn't like it, I loved his take on Pinhead.

So I was fortunate enough to see this early and I have to say...I was honestly surprised how good it was.

It comes off like a masculine survival film but it's actually way deeper than that. The characters are well developed. The story is traditional (finding bag of money and getting chased by bad guys) but it's always moving forward and entertaining.

While there is a ton of dialogue and sometimes it bogs down the flow, it's still really well done and the actors are great.

Pinhead (Paul Taylor) is awesome and not what I thought he would be.

Overall good film and surprised it wasn't in some festivals...
3 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Whitetail" (2021): Like father, like son?
jtncsmistad18 July 2021
Evil has infected a vast and forested remote Texas ranch. Into this crucible enter a father, son and uncle.

What follows is terrifying.

Thus is the sinister and multi-layered parable presented us in the new domestic crime thriller "Whitetail".

I spoke with writer/director Derek Presley.

Q: Having grown up in, and lived and traveled throughout, Texas, it is of particular personal interest that "Whitetail" is shot in the north central region of the state. How did this unique choice of location come to be?

A: There's a couple of different reasons why. Mostly, it's because the story originated from my past when I'd go hunting at my family's farm out near Coleman, Texas. The farm was this really flat and dusty stretch of property. I believe it was a few hundred acres, but I was younger so it may as well have been thousands to me. I wanted to shoot the film at the exact location but my family sold the property a few years back. So Austin Williams (producer/upm) had this perfect piece of land that he'd actually shot a few films on. The land was very similar to what I wrote about and off we went. The other reason was that the core group of filmmakers consisting of Jason Starne, Garrett Schwindt and Austin Williams, all lived within an hour or so and we could get to it much easier than what I had originally planned.

Q: Masculinity, and the ofttimes fragility of such, is investigated on a number of levels in this story. Share your thoughts on this prominent and complex theme running through "Whitetail".

A: Well, it's really the nucleus of the whole film. There were two characters in the film that were entirely based on one person in my life from my past. That person quite literally had two different personalities and both of them, while vastly contrasting, were overly masculine. I think there's so much of it going on in the story where there's only men doing men things and behaving like children. The only one with any sense is the one person who has yet to reach real "manhood". My cinematographer/producer, Garrett Schwindt, told me he believed the whole film was a moral cautionary tale about toxic masculinity. I think he's right.

Q: As a Christian, it is especially heartening to see the faith, and, more specifically, The Bible, being presented with both dignity and thoughtfulness. I watch and review a lot of movies. This is enormously rare in the secular film industry. Your thoughts?

A: That's interesting that you've seen it that way. Some people have said it's a secular story and some have thought it was non-secular. There's no direct message from me to anyone about religion in the film. What that was, was to show how this man wouldn't back down and wouldn't give up on seeing the good in someone, even if it didn't turn out the best for him. But at the same time, it was also a way to show that there is pure evil in this world and evil can do a lot of damage, despite the good.

Q: One interpretation of the final moments of "Whitetail" is that we are bearing witness to a "right of passage" between father and son. It is a most uncommon legacy, one that involves unflinching focus and the will to claim life. As both writer and director of the film, does this approach the intent of enduring impression?

A: Partially, absolutely. Hunting is something that is almost ritualistic in deep Texas. Father and son go and bond that way. Not everyone enjoys it. I most certainly won't take my son hunting to bond. Not because I think one way or another about the act of it, but mostly because I just don't find it appealing. There's a bit about innocence because Donnie can't bring himself to take the animal's life and at the end that's all he's really thinking his father would be mad at him about. So that "rite of passage" was kind of never executed, at least on the surface.

I'd say more than anything it's about the innocence of the son and the guilt of the father. Innocence prevailed...kind of....

Q: Where does your creative muse take you and your audience next, Derek?

A: RED STONE is the film we shot after WHITETAIL. Production was in June of 2020, pretty much right after people were coming out of lockdown from Covid. That is a southern crime thriller taking place over the course of one day in a small Texas town. BOON was shot this past January in Washington state up in the mountains and it's a Neo-Western filled with snow and the bitter cold.

"Whitetail" opens in select theaters on July 21, and becomes available on home entertainment this fall.
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Derek Presley does it again!
cody-berry15 November 2021
I've been a huge fan of Derek Presley's film for years. I'm glad he is starting to get the recognition he deserves. This movie has his style all over it. The movie is beautiful. It combines the calming Texas landscape with a truly unnerving story. Every actor brings their unique and flawed character to life. This not only keeps you guessing about who will come out on top, but also who to root for. You will be doing yourself a disservice if you miss this movie!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Southern Gothic Done Right...
SurrealDeal2 November 2021
Whitetail knows exactly what it is, namely a Southern Gothic thriller with a minimalist approach to its themes. It's not a "feel good" movie, nor does it pretend to be. It's reminiscent of a Cormac McCarthy novel with a side of Deliverance (other films such as Frailty and A Simple Plan come to mind). If you're looking for a traditional good versus evil film with a large budget, then don't bother. If, however, you're looking for a pessimistic yet strangely cathartic story about the possibility of redemption, then you'll most likely enjoy Whitetail. I personally did. If you "get it," then it's an easy four stars out of five. Any rating below that tells me the viewer probably watched it with a very different set of expectations that didn't align with what the movie itself sought to achieve in the first place.

Speaking as someone who appreciates the Southern Gothic genre as a whole, I hope Derek Presley (the writer and director) continues to use it as a model for future films.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Loved it
Didn't expect to like this as much as we did. I caught the trailer for it while we saw a film last week.

I love films like Blue Ruin and this reminded me of it.

Very well done. Slow burn thriller that is full of tense moments. Beautiful looking and the performances were strong. Again, very surprised to like this. Good thriller that reminded me of the old films that took their time telling the story.

Thumbs up.
2 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Strong indie
perryjon-2623119 July 2021
I caught this when it screened in Dallas this month. I looked for it again but couldn't find it playing anywhere else. I hope it does becaue I recommended it to a few friends I know would love it.

It won't be everyone's cup of tea, because it's pretty intense and dark. But man, it's a ride. I would say it was a tad long, but again it never really got slow. The actors were locals and were really really good!

Catch this if you can.
1 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Solid Story. Well Made.
TrustCarterBurch6 April 2022
I got sucked into the woods as I watched this one play out. Fun, unusual characters. Great traditional filmmaking. Writer / Director Derek Presley is an homage to raw, instinctual, pulpy films that resonate with Texas southern personality. A guy's movie!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Dark but good
timspencer-4725219 July 2021
This movie was extremely dark and made you think. Filled with intense moments but was paced well. The actors did great and the story was interesting. I was annoyed with the ending because it didn't go where I thought it would, but it I guess that it was still good.

Really crazy characters.
0 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed