Red Fields (2019) Poster

(2019)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A musical that is depressing and confusing
chong_an7 September 2019
I saw this at the Toronto International Film Festival, with director Q+A, so I could more understand this film. It is based on an old rock opera, but the director changed the music from western to traditional - an artistic choice that, however, helped keep the mood downbeat, especially since the music was the key to the film. There is a (singing) narrator, and musicians were hired to perform, rather than actors hired to sing.

The story, and the production, is timeless, given that Israel is in a state of perpetual war, and soldiers with injuries are not uncommon. However, when Mami takes her husband out of hospital and tries to make it in Tel Aviv, she suffers a series of misadventures that lead to a transformation. While this seems to be a fantasy, logic rules don't apply, as the vegetative-state soldier gets to sing songs too.

Rather than use the original title of Mami, the director retitled it Red Fields, a reference to bloody battlefields. The confusing part is that I thought the film was pro-war, when the director's intent was to be anti-war.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
They should know better!!!
liattzuberi23 May 2020
They needed to leave the moovie on the floor in the Gas station. Never I was so disappointed and disgusted from a re-make.

Shame on all of you
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of a kind
Nozz4 October 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I might say this is the best movie to come out of Israel so far, but that wouldn't be fair because MAMY can't be compared to other Israeli films. The most similar film is TOMMY, which is echoed in a number of aspects. War brings disaster to a young couple, someone becomes disabled, there is a sexual threat, we meet a powerful and evil woman, there is intervention from a doctor, and the patient becomes a famous leader but is ultimately rejected by the public. And it's a pop opera. But it's a very Israeli opera, dealing with the country's underprivileged, and for this movie the music has been adapted to a more Middle Eastern style than the stage version used. As a rock opera, the stage version had a little musical levity. The movie version doesn't; the music is compelling but consistently mournful although the story veers into satire once the characters have sunk to rock bottom.

As an opera, the movie can take advantage of an exemption from the demands of realism. It hops over plot holes and lets its budget constraints show freely. It's swept along largely by the singing and acting of Neta Elkayam in her first movie. Like Mazi Cohen, who played the part on stage, Elkayam does not have a conventionally pretty face. That she isn't pretty, and that she isn't well known, helps produce a feeling of honesty that sells the story despite the artificiality of the genre. And you can't help believing her when she sings, against the arrangements by Dudu Tassa (who also serves as narrator) and Nir Maimon.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed