Nui yan boon sik (2007) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Very disappointing
leekandham13 November 2007
A movie to celebrate 10 years since the handover of Hong Kong, this film aims to document the difficulties Hong Kong faced immediately, from the Asian financial crisis in the late 90s to SARS.

Gigi Leung plays Joy, a powerful CFO of a hotel chain in Hong Kong, who sees her husband CEO replaced by a young mainland Chinese businessman. As the Asian financial crisis hits, relationships are strained and even the most trusted ones, both personal and business, are troubled.

Meanwhile, Fiona Sit plays the naïve assistant of Joy, falls for a cheat, yet has an admirer in the form of the flower shop boy next door.

In all honesty, the film fell into the typical trap in converting a novel into a motion picture. There are too many minor dramatic scenes that might work in describing real life in a novel, but simply doesn't add anything to a film lasting an hour and a half. The relationships between the characters seem too artificial, despite glimmers of chemistry amongst some of the actors, but generally, it just didn't work.

But my greatest gripe was that this film just relied so heavily on product placement such that it turned out to be one long advertisement. I understand that films need funding, but that just ruined any artistic value this film had (not that it really had much to start with).

I'm rather disappointed overall. Gigi Leung has proved that she can be a good dramatic actress, but sadly, her talent was wasted this time.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Woman's Film
crossbow010622 March 2008
All I was thinking was that film could have been so much better. It spans just about ten years, from the handover of Hong Kong to almost now (2007). The story mostly revolves around 2 women, the career climbing Joy and her assistant Tung. The film chronicles the changes in Hong Kong over this time, especially in the financial end. It even includes a segment about SARS, which is almost heartbreaking. The problem is, the movie is too broad. In those ten or so years, Tung doesn't age at all (lucky her) and has one ultimately bad relationship. Joy, played by the very pretty Gigi Leung, suffers greatly in this film. The film took so long to get to where it ended up. There wasn't enough interaction between the two main characters. There is sadness, anger, suicide all through this film, so the film has an emotional center. The reason why I gave the film six stars is that the last twenty five minutes are very good. If you can get through the film up to then, its worth it. So, while I can't recommend it to everyone, its not bad. It could have, however, been tightened to be just about Joy and Tung, not about their families, business etc. Its a decent film that I wanted to like a lot more.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
10 years of HongKong (1997-2009), "Nothing is Impossible"
mac_chew13 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Disclaimer: Never like Gigi Leung movies before. But Wonder Women is one movie, that can be watched.

China Political Influence views aside. To be accurate with the time period, the period need to be dealt with.

Uncomfortable item, but politics does play apart in big business.

Start of Spoiler Alert++++++++++++++

Look out for Prince Charles sad look, when Hong Kong was returned.

End of Spoiler Alert++++++++++++++++

Fortunate or not, this movie will go down as a Hong Kong historical backdrop movie, unless someone made another to replace it. It covers a Critical period of time from 1997 till 2007.

Historical Time Line 1997 Hong Kong Handover/Currency Crisis. 1999 Property slump. 2003 SARS 2007 Recovery

Movie is a slice of society, showing what crisis that the Hong Kong People dealt since the Handover.

Good Points

  • Show the People Business attitude.


  • Creating opportunities and recovering from failures.


  • Rare, but there are some people with conscience in that society.


Bad Points

  • Self destruction, two successful, and one failed attempt(s).


  • Money Culture, money talks. Wife leaving husband and child when he lose his job. Branded goods culture. Not a uniquely Hong Kong trait but common drama/movie theme when depicting Hong Kong culture, a bit unfair.


Acting. Been Biased against Gigi Leung, She is the Lead actress and focus of the movie.

Found her portrayal of person undergoing the tribulation acceptable to watch, she has improved over her previous movies.

As the other cast played minor support roles, not much character development in their roles as they drift in and out of the movie. Most are used as fillers in the movie.

Only Fiona Sit supporting Gigi Leung from the start to the end. But unfortunately she didn't have much a role to play, limiting her potential in this young star.

Watch-ability Watch this Movie if:

1) Like either Gig Leung or Fiona Sit.

2) History Bluff, who want a fast and simple 10 history lesson of Hong Kong from 1997 to 2007.

3) Like a simple "Ladies Be Strong" Story, in the movie, seem that men cannot make it without ladies support.

a. George Lam-wife lending money,

b. Shiu Hung Hui-a loan from Gigi Leung,

c. The CEO (Osim), whose Mom had to take out a loan from the company for his MBA (Gigi Helped),

d. Guy chasing after Fiona Sit, had to be helped by his cousin (a lady whose name slip my mind)

Watchable, but there are many Movies around the release date that offers more bang per buck in terms of storyline.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Terrible piece of propaganda
osund14 July 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Barbara Wong has apparently decided that the way to revive her career is to become the Chinese Communist Party's Leni Riefenstahl. This film received its premiere at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing to mark the 1997 handover of Hong Kong to the PRC, so it's no surprise that everything in the past 10 years is presented in a positive light. The Asian financial crisis? All the fault of George Soros, according to this film. Donald Tsang's "election"? Just another example of the great things that have happened since 1997, according to the director.

With the clear political motive in mind, the storyline is secondary. Basically, Joy (played by Gigi Leung) is moving up in her career, juggling her work and her newborn child. Then, all sorts of challenges come up, none of which come across as plausible. Her assistant (played by Fiona Sit) helps her face the challenges, even though Joy's character seems hardly suited to fight back. Unbelievable coincidences also help Joy revive her situation.

Many Hong Kong films have product placements, but this film has even more than most. Overall, there is no reason to see this movie unless you want to see propaganda.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The heart and soul of Hong Kong...
chengwinghei8 July 2007
As we pass the 10th anniversary of the political coup d'etat/long awaited return to motherland (depending on your POV), inevitably there will be numerous movies that will have something to say about what went down these last ten years. And what a ride it was! Seen through the eyes of strong-willed Joy (played by G. Leung) and her eccentric assistant Tung (played by F. Sit), it chronicles their exploits in the real estate industry, and especially the men that come and go in their lives.

Music/film veteran George Lam plays the real estate executive and husband of Joy, who struggles to find his place in society as the Anglo-American commercial-political clique is replaced with a Chinese Communist one. Kevin Cheng plays the young idealistic rookie doctor, brother-in-law of Joy. Yuan Nie plays the young, debonair, Chinese communist CEO who replaces George Lam's post because of his connections up north. Hins Cheung plays the shy, admirer of Tung who unfortunately is stuck in a job that is not terribly macho. Shiu Hung Hui plays Joy's extremely money-minded father in law. Eddy Ko plays a member of the director's board at where Joy works. Kitty Yuen plays the relentless multi-level marketer who's "friends" with everybody at Joy's place of work. Hacken Lee plays a surprise role.

First the problems: there is the mis-casting of Lam as spouse of Joy, as Lam is old enough to be her father, and Leung has no marriage experience in real life. The gap between the acting skills of the full-time actors (Kevin Cheng) and crossover pop artists (Sit) are pretty obvious. The story can get a bit moralistic at times and political bias can be alleged, but no matter, since Hollywood films are generally critical of the government too. Those acquianted with recent events of Hong Kong will easily predict what will become of the various "functional characters". Hardened, cynical types may find the story a bit sentimental at times. Some symbols of historical events, such as news footage of the stock market, may have been used too repetitively without any imagination or subtlety to the point of being hackneyed.

But overall, the cast's spirited performance (after all, they HAVE all experienced what happened the last 10 years) will make you laugh, make you cry as you recall the challenges Hong Kong has faced. This is a film you could show foreigners to help them understand really matters to citizens of "the fragrant harbor".
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed