Madame Claude (2021) User Reviews

IT COULD HAVE OFFERED MUCH MORE

[albertval-69560 · 5/10 · 3 April 2021]

Fernande Grudet's life is a fascinating story but the film falls short of making it compelling. The main focus is on the requisites of the sex sex trade: how she manages her burgeoning business and the growing power and influence that go with it. It does little to dive into the interesting characters that inhabit her story.

Given the story's potential, one could imagine dramatic encounters with the police and her influential clients. But when such opportunities arise, the encounters happen mostly matter-of-factly except for that memorable meeting of Sidonie and her father in the restaurant where he got his comeuppance.

More for the female market

[shaun-35238 · 6/10 · 8 April 2021]

It's a different movie and not too much happens. It meanders along from start to finish with little change.

It's watchable, but it's not for everyone.

No thank you

[marimarcachon · 4/10 · 18 May 2021]

You keep waiting for something to happen and it all slips like nothing. I think that's the big issue I have with this film: it doesn't compromise with anything, just stays in the surface. It doesn't go on the glamour of the brothel and Claude, it doesn't go into her ties with the police, politicians and mobsters, it doesn't get into the life of the madame and the prostitutes, nor into her past... Some reviews say the ending was worth it... that must be a trap because it's a lame ending.

Siodine never ages and you never see the amazing love she feels for Claude so she has to make a phone call to say it. Just as most of the movie relies on Claude's narration that -as someone already pointed out in another review- it's often the contrary to what is happening in the film.

Confusing if your not French, or don't know the back story.

[MsPomerol · 2/10 · 19 April 2021]

I had so many questions afterwards. Her police involvement? Sidonie, does she not age? 20 ish years later and she looks exactly the same. Did she reconnect with the daughter? What exactly was she doing in the US? How did she support herself in Nice until 2015?

Interesting biopic - I do not understand all the negative ratings here

[von_stauffenberg · 7/10 · 4 April 2021]

Not a high drama action film but interesting biopic of a highly ambivalent figure in a well reconstructed Paris of the late 60s/early 70s. Madame Claude is certainly no feminist hero, but at a very basic level she not a brutal pimp either: she does provide a "family" for her "girls" while managing her "business" in a male dominanted environment to satisfy male desires (but that does not prevent her from exposing her girls to dangerous situations and she certainly does not get the sympathy of the viewer). She operates at the fringes of legality yet police and security forces use and exploit her to their ends (and drop her likel a hot potato), while she also has to deal with the figures of the underworld... Film scores very highly on the reconstruction of the peculiar atmoshere of the period, and I recommend viewing this picture.

What's the point?

[michael-sidiropoulos · 2/10 · 2 April 2021]

Trying to think what the point of this film is. Is it purely biographical? Probably. Are there any cinematic values? Probably not. An environment of prostitution would lend itself to some character development. There is none. Okay, there may be some other redeeming features. An interesting storyline, some surprises and plot twists. Nope. Normal acting and direction, nothing superb. This film doesn't rise above mediocrity.

Realistic portrayal

[skepticskeptical · 7/10 · 13 September 2021]

Madame Claude (2021), dir. Sylvie Verheyde. I am not sure why this Netflix film has such a low rating at imdb. I found it to be, if not especially original, at least a plausible depiction of the world's oldest profession. There are quite a few films about brothels and madames, and it's true that this one does not chart any new territory with regard to the profession itself. Nonetheless, I found the acting decent and liked that the film was based on a true story and followed the entire trajectory of the life of Madame Claude.

So empty

[soprano-69707 · 2/10 · 3 April 2021]

It looks tecnically well done and this is great; but this movie is superficial, empty, almost vulgar and a waste of time..Whats the point of this story?

Much more than a "madam"

[danybur · 7/10 · 25 May 2021]

Summary

Interesting and at times controversial biopic of the most influential pimp woman in France. Also a film about the many and sometimes surprising but inevitable derivations of high-end pimping.

Review

Madame Claude is concerned above all with the heyday of who was the most exalted and famous pimp woman in France during the presidencies of de Gaulle and Pompidou, how she ran her "house" and her "mansion" and her relationship with the circles of power.

This Silvie Verhayde partial biopic of Fernande Grudet, aka Madame Claude, focuses on three aspects. On the one hand, she was the pimp of the most exclusive network of female prostitution for more than a decade, which led her to link with circles of power, organized crime and others that the viewer will discover, striking a dangerous balance between them. Coupled with her sixties setting, this sometimes surprising but unavoidable aspect of high-end pimping lends the film, at times, a fascinating and sophisticated spy-movie climate. Do not demand a broad development of these subplots from this film as if it were a documentary or a miniseries; they simply place us in what the protagonist negotiated, trafficked and dealt with.

The other two aspects, closely related to each other, have to do with his private life and the way in which he managed his network, concentrated in high-end brothels (houses and later mansions), describing how he related to "his" prostitutes and the "Community" or "family" that they made up, which the film describes in an unbiased way, but without sparing any of its facets. This description of the intimate realm of VIP prostitution (and by extension of prostitution in general) will be controversial for some. In particular, Madame Claude's bond with whoever was her right hand, the enigmatic Sidonie (in a very good performance by Garance Mallinier, protagonist of the notable Voracious), develops. The director and actress Hafzsia Herzi also appears in the role of another call girl.

Karole Roche carries out a very good interpretation, combining toughness, dryness and passion of her difficult and complex character, showing a Madame Claude determined to make a place in the male power plot, exercising tight control of her prostitution network with a imprint that went from the maternal to the despotic and ruthless and going through the difficult relationship with her family.

The re-enactment of the period is very successful, with a soundtrack with French themes from the period very conveniently located and the usual European casualness in the intimate scenes.

Mais où est Emanuelle?

[francofarina-52527 · 3/10 · 5 April 2021]

It's heartening to know that the French are capable of making a crappy Netflix movie. Perhaps they even consider it a genre. Some favorite bits: Madame Claude going full Citizen Kain on her cheating lover, worst prostitut killer ever running through the woods before being shot, shoving Dadies face into the food, and the same set up over and over of Sidonie leaving some party to privately talk with Claude. The interesting things historically are skimmed over in favor of spending time with the girls. Oh ma petite chou, you are not hurt so bad. Barf. A take on this tale with new eyes could have been interesting. But with this flic, Emanuelle should have done a cameo.

The end is worth the wait

[rwkenyon-09484 · 8/10 · 5 April 2021]

I watched Madame Claude by Sylvie Verheyde on Netflix, which just premiered a couple of days ago. It's the second French biopic about "Madame Claude," née Fernande Grudet, who operated the most illustrious brothel in Paris for fifteen years in the 1960's and 1970's--the first, also titled Madame Claude, by Just Jaekin, dates from 1977 and starred Francoise Fabian. I wasn't sure I would like the new version, since a few of the reviews panned it, but I decided to start watching it to see if I liked it. I watched it all. I saw it VOSTF--speaking French with French subtitles.

The best thing about this film is that it is directed by a woman, Sylvie Verheyde. This is important, although little discussed by the mostly male critics and commentators, but I doubt that any male director could have enjoyed the intimacy with the almost entirely female cast. There is only one principal male character, the voyou--gangster--Jo Attia, played by veteran actor Roschdy Zem, who occupies a minor role. Most of the film ostensibly takes place in Madame Claude's maisons closes at 18, rue de Marignan, near the Champs-Elysées, and 32, rue de Boulainvilliers, a discrete location in the 16th.

A crucial aspect of the film is mostly ignored by the American audience or even by French people who did not live in Paris in the 1960's and 1970's, as I did. A Yugoslav, Stevan Markovic, whose name is mispronounced by some of the characters, a Corsican, François Marcantoni, President George Pompidou, his wife, Claude, and the actor Alain Delon were all involved in a bombshell scandal that erupted in 1968 and is evoked a background to the film to suggest Madame Claude's connections with la pègre, the French underworld. According to the Wikipedia, the affair began when one of Delon's bodyguards, Markovic, was found dead. Both Delon and his longtime friend Marcantoni were questioned by the police. Marcantoni was originally charged with the murder, but after further questioning by the police, he was released. Markovic's murder is still unsolved.

Most of the sexy scenes are near the beginning of the film. There are a few violent moments, but most of the film revolves around the entrepreneurial Madame Claude's business and the "Claudettes" she recruited for her wealthy and powerful clients. The end is worth the wait.

There are several good articles online, some with cheesecake photos, about Madame Claude. Several books, including her 1994 autobiography, Madam, describe her life. She died in Nice in 2015 at the age of 92, keeping many of her secrets to her grave.

French actress Karole Rocher is excellent in the title role and will probably garner a Cesar, the French equivalent of an Oscar, for her starring role as Madame Claude.

The young Garance Marillier, born in 1998, is excellent as Sidonie, the daughter of a diplomat. The enigmatic Sidonie puffs or pretends to puff a Virginia Slims most of the time. (I checked: the iconic cigarettes premiered in 1968, the time of the film.) Sidonie becomes Madame Claude's favorite Claudette and her confidante.

Because of some confusion in the script, I'd rate the film a B overall. It's worth watching, but not destined to become a classic. Netflix rates it "steamy" and "cerebral." Right, it probably is both.

Interesting - dont trust the 1 star ratings

[chrismise · 7/10 · 7 May 2021]

Based on a real story of a bordel owner int eh 60-70.

One of the worst editing ever

[dierregi · 1/10 · 8 April 2021]

If you watch this movie you're probably aware of the overdose of sleazy you'll be experiencing. While I could accept the sex scenes that go with the territory, I wasn't prepared to deal with the disjoint, pedestrian editing.

Madame Claude is the occasional voice over, but her narrative is unreliable. For instance, she mentions she started her "career" as a prostitute (not much of a surprise) and we're shown a scene in the past where she defended a colleague from a customer's beating. You might assume Madame is against violence, but immediately after, one of her "girls" is subject to brutal beating and Madame comment is just "Wash and have a good sleep to forget about it".

Then she proclaims she doesn't have the time for a "love story" and immediately after she's hooking up with a sleazy guy. The lack of consistency is not the only problem, the editing goes from past to present with no logic; the character of Madame's daughter is introduced for no reason and then abandoned; the sex scenes are way too frequent, so that the movie is more a soft porn that doesn't need a plot than a legitimate film.

Inept filming

[louisesweeting · 2/10 · 8 April 2021]

I do not care about the nudity or sex BUT what offends me is the quality of this film. Atrocious acting; bad dubbing; non-existant storyline. French movies are so good. Perhaps they should have had a French team on it and this sorry saga would have been a success.

Nice.... c'est tout

[bethjazotte-60931 · 7/10 · 21 April 2021]

Um drama no Netflix baseado na história real de uma dona de bordel na Paris dos anos 70. Eu gostei, mas é preciso gostar do gênero...A Netflix drama based on the real story of a brothel owner in Paris from the 70s. I liked it, but you have to like the genre ...#movieslover #netflix.

Boring

[thespira · 3/10 · 2 April 2021]

I started watching as the story of Madame Claude is quite famous. I dropped the show after 30mn. Too much sex and no story line. Actors are not even good.

It's a hard pass... don't loose your time.

All day and night delight

[kosmasp · 7/10 · 16 April 2021]

I have no idea why I came up with this summary line - well I have some idea. Considering what the movie is about and all that. This depicts a certain woman and how she made her living and what an adventure her life was. Quite a few have at least heard her name - but how much do they actually know about her? Some I assume know so much, that they will be able to say where the movie took creative license - as you can tell I am not one of those people.

I am also not one of the people who has issues with nudity and sexuality in movies. And there is quite a lot of that in here - which is not a surprise - unless you didn't know anything about that woman of course. Of course someone else who may have issues and is more sensible and still reads as little as I do ... well we all have different views. So I'd understand if you don't like it like that. I also understand that the true nature of the movie and the moving through the years makes the pacing of the movie unbearable to some ... it's a drama you see?

Its boring

[itsjaycube · 1/10 · 2 April 2021]

Had to stop watching half way cause its so boring. I rather watch cartoon than watch this.

Boring

[xjacquix-59210 · 1/10 · 6 April 2021]

I very rarely give up on films but after 30-40 minutes I couldn't even get the point of the movie, it bored me and nothing made any sense.

How blind can one be

[orlyco-72883 · 10/10 · 5 April 2021]

To not appreciate this painful, beautiful movie? What's wrong with you people? It's far from being boring it's a movie about a madam running a bordello, naturally sex scenes will be part of it and those scenes are important for the story of the characters. It's a story about lonely broken yet strong women who chose a complicated way to deal with their pain.

Could be better

[faer_kr · 3/10 · 3 April 2021]

A drama based on real events.

It is about the life of a pimp woman in France and everything that goes into running such a business.

Quality.

Slightly parsimonious.

The time spectacularly recreated.

Good costumes and hairstyles.

Music instead.

Well-managed nude and sexual scenes, far from looking grotesque, add the touch to the film.

Talk about corruption, the prostitution business, what you have to do to survive in it. Of loneliness, love and what guides a person to get there.

The voice-over gives the film agility to get to know the character better.

Good performances.

Safety pin.

It carries the tone of French movies.

Editing does not help at times and it becomes somewhat confusing.

Pointless

[zohaeffendi · 1/10 · 8 April 2021]

Utter crap and pointless , no purpose ,depth or story ! Waste of time.

Amazing

[kanifuker-84708 · 1/10 · 16 May 2022]

Amazing movie if you can't sleep and you need something to knock you out. There is nothing great about this movie, the sex scenes are woeful, acting is dire and the whole movie pointless about some old dog who neglects her daughter and runs a high end prostitution racket amongst politicians and police. Similar case and movie about some old hag in a high end london brothel etc.

Stick to Madam Tussaud and Claude Chabrol

[jgcorrea · 2/10 · 18 April 2021]

To appreciate this painful, plain movie? No way. It's boring , it's about a madam running a bordello, naturally Sexploitation is everywhere. Who cares who was Madam Claude? It's a story about a lonely and broken yet strong woman who chose a complicated way to earn her living and deal with society's whims.

What's even it trying to say?!

[fuckinghuman · 2/10 · 3 April 2021]

I hated it so boring so disgusting. I don't understand the point. Such a bad movie and director isn't good too. Nothing to say don't waste your time.