'Seirei no Moribito' may be not the most popular anime out there, nevertheless it has gained some fame - given that even I heard about the series and I'm not an avid anime fan. It is 26 episode show adapted from the novel which is under 300 pages long. And unfortunately one can see that - many episodes felt like a filler only. But I should start by listing good things.
First of all it definitely isn't your typical teenage anime filled with over-the-top duels, excessive talking during them, fanservice panty shots (or however they are called) and other similar monstrosities. Typical anime humor is also notably absent. It has strong, somewhat interesting, capable lead female character (with rather non exposed sexuality - I know it may be considered minor but these days even show which only restrains from sexual objectification is worth praise). The fight scenes are really entertaining and well choreographed, animation is nice (however I'm not an expert on the subject and above some level I don't really care) and soundtrack doesn't annoy. And sometimes emotions depicted by the show resonate with viewer acceptably well.
But it should be strongly stressed - despite really good fight scenes it is almost entirely non-action anime. It is very unevenly-paced, but mostly very slow, even sluggish. In some episodes almost nothing interesting happens. And by that I don't mean only lack of action (because many, many episodes lack action), but also lack of any plot development, any relationship dynamics, any tangible emotions, any character exposition, lack of everything really. I'm not exaggerating, there are 2 or 3 episodes in which literally NOTHING happens. And when you add to them several in which something happens but it certainly doesn't fill up whole 20 minutes you can grasp how abysmally BORING this anime can be. This problem haunts especially the middle part of the series, the beginning and end are noticeably better - but I still wouldn't call them good in that aspect.
When it comes to the story it feels, I'll put it bluntly, stupid. Motivations of certain characters (the ones from the imperial court) are for me utterly non-comprehensible, in the result main reason for the plot "emperor wants to secretly kill his second son, because the son is possessed by dangerous demon who can cause massive drought" seems unconvincing, all the more the demon turns out to be not so dangerous and actually prevents drought. And I really can't shake off the impression that many things happen ex machina, without explanation, only to save the day or advance the plot further.
By the way most characters (apart from protagonist and maybe his underage sidekick) are completely forgettable. It is especially apparent with antagonist side - the show lacks real villain, everyone is at most gray. It could be seen as a departure from the cliché but in this case it isn't really a good thing, because it makes the forgettable antagonists even more forgettable.
To make things worse protagonists tend to do things which even inside their world make no sense at all - e. g. two main characters (which are shown to be well known) want to escape from the palace and disappear - yet they stroll inside the very city the palace they have run from is located in, they wander through streets of said city in their usual outfits equipped with accessories they are known of, stick to their original names, buy and operate the mill near this city (sic!) and don't make absolutely any effort whatsoever to hide themselves. And it's not the excuse to advance the plot - they are indeed not found for many months! Maybe it's a small detail, but very annoying one.
To sum it up - I wouldn't recommend this anime to anyone seeking action or intelligent narrative. I think there are people who can find the characters and interactions between them interesting (and can live without actual character or relationship development) or who can derive pleasure from slow-paced, well-animated depiction of simple life in medieval fantasy world with occasional bursts of fighting. But ultimately I consider this series bland and boring.
3 out of 40 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink