The Wild Swans (1977) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Beautiful and touching anime version of the timeless story
TheLittleSongbird29 April 2010
As I like anime very much, after seeing a captivating anime version of Swan Lake, I was wondering if there were any similar ones. By chance on YouTube I came across the Wild Swans and watched it. First of all, I'm 18 and I adore the timeless Hans Christian Andersen story, at a young age I always found it beautiful and touching. And this 1977 anime was exactly that.

The animation is stunning, mystical and ethereal with backgrounds that are lavish and characters that are well designed. For example you have the protagonist Elisa, she is beautifully drawn and I could relate to her because of the fact she was very kind-hearted here and loyal to her brothers, in contrast with a grotesque-looking character such as the Witch who serves as the main villainess of the piece. Another delight was the music, some of it was simple but it was nevertheless haunting and beautiful.

The film does keep true to the spirit of the story which is quite melancholic and poignant, it isn't word from word and one or two characters and situations are added, but that doesn't matter to me. I still loved the story here, as it was beautifully told and well structured. And the dialogue isn't clichéd or trite, it is honest and mysterious-like, a major plus in my book. Even the King's dialogue was worthwhile, there are some instances where a character may have dialogue that makes you groan, but because of the sincerity the King had here, that wasn't the case.

And of course I loved the characters. I loved Elisa, the Witch and the King. And I loved how Elisa's brothers weren't bland or obnoxious, and Greta like her mother is someone you would love to hate. When Elisa spared them at the end, I was like be thankful you weren't burned at the stake because you deserved that seeing how badly you treated Elisa and her brothers. In short, they got more than they deserved in my opinion, sounds callous I know but I kind of get angry when an innocent person is slandered for selfish reasons. Finally, the voice work is dynamic and expressive, I recognised the voice actress of Elisa from somewhere(presently I can't remember exactly where though) and she was really appealing. It is a shame really none of the voice actors are credited here, because the voice actress of the witch I thought was superb, she reminded me slightly of Susanne Pleshette's Yubaba/Zeniba in Spirited Away.

Overall, beautiful and touching film, deserves to be better known. When I saw it I could find absolutely nothing wrong. 10/10 Bethany Cox
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Favorite film version of The Wild Swans
ja_kitty_7111 July 2022
The Wild Swans is another fairy tale from my favorite writer, Hans Christian Andersen. The story has been adapted four times on stage and in films. But I love this version of the story in this lesser-known anime film from 1977; I am a huge anime fan like my twin sister. At first, I'd never seen this movie, but after I watched it online, I loved it. The film combines both Andersen's and the Grimm Brothers' versions of the story. Instead of eleven brothers, it was narrowed down to six, like in the Grimms' version. And in the middle of the story (with the nettles) and the ending are strictly Andersen's; I do prefer Andersen's version.

The film begins with the king hunting in the forest. But suddenly he lost his way in the spooky woods, until an old woman (who was really a witch and the main villain of the film) came by and offered to help if the king would marry her daughter Greta; my educated guess is that her voice actress is Billie Lou Watt. After they returned to the castle, the king left Greta to tell his seven children (six sons and a daughter named Elisa) about their new mother. The children lived in a house in the woods because their late mother thought it would be safe, and only the good queen's magic spool of yarn knows where the house is. Of course, Greta did not like this at all, and she became jealous. In the dead of the night, Greta searched for the magic spool of yarn, and she did because there were some leaves sticking out of the yarn as proof this was the magic spool of yarn.

The next morning, she took the yarn, and the yarn bounced all the way to the house where the royal children lived. She finally reached the house and greeted the children. But little do they know what evil trickery is afoot for them, because when the six young princes went outside to greet the queen, she flung six magic, white cloths on them, and they were turned into swans. But not Elisa; she was saved by her brothers, who attacked the evil witch queen while she escaped. While searching for her swan and brothers, Elisa rested under a tree and cried. But her magic tears encouraged her not to give up hope. So she continued to search for them until finally she found all six brothers, and what a happy reunion they had. But Elisa can only see her brothers at night, when the enchantment breaks. And when spring comes, they'll have to migrate to a colder climate. Before leaving, they tell Elisa that she alone could break the spell. She would have to collect nettle and spin it into thread with which to make six shirts, one for each of her brothers, for six years. During this time, she would have to remain silent, for if she were to speak a single word or make the slightest sound, they would all die. So Elisa worked on the six nettle shirts throughout the years. Until one autumn, when the fifth shirt was finished, a young king's hunting party found her, and the king beckoned Elisa to come with him to his kingdom and bring her basket of nettles and shirts with her. That's all I could tell you, folks; you will have to see the film for yourself to see how it ends.

Overall, I loved every minute of this film, and it is a must-see for anime fans everywhere. You know, I think Elisa and also Rosa, from another anime fairy tale film, Puss in Boots, fit the part of being non-Disney princesses, don't you? As I said before, this might seem strange to you guys, but I put on a list I have made of my favorite movie princesses, animated or live action, including these three ladies. So overall, this is another great film from Toei Animation.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Loved it as a kid, still love it as an adult!
meggbburn17 August 2023
The description claims she had to knit sweaters/shirts/garmets from "poison ivy" but anyone who has seen the movie would know it's Stinging Nettle.

The sounds in this movie are so memorable and sacrifice this girl makes and the peril she endures for the well-being of her brothers is amazing.

This movie is on our family playlist and our children enjoy it. It has stood up to the test of time!

I don't know why this review is required to be a certain length... I just wanted to point out the mistake regarding the stinging nettles.

If you like animated movie like older studio ghibli and the original Disney stuff, you'll like this one. Enjoy!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed