"The Office" The Return (TV Episode 2007) Poster

(TV Series)

(2007)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Hits it home with this one
dmdebruyn24 November 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Season 3 of The Office takes the show's main characters into very complicated terrain as each of them struggles to navigate the rough waters that make up his or her story. 1. Jim moves to Stamford but then moves back after it closes down, prompting a merger with Dunder Mifflin that places new characters, Karen Filippelli and Andy Bernard, among the office regulars. Jim starts a relationship with Karen but still has feelings for Pam. 2. Dwight's his usual oddball self, secretly in a relationship with Angela, and still Dundee Mifflin's top salesman. With Andy's entrance into Dunder Mifflin, his ways of sucking up to Michael make him a bigger threat to Dwight than Jim, and they become mortal enemies 3. And Pam, heartbroken as she is, managed to maintain her perky personality in the workplace 4. And of course, Michael Scott himself, struggling to find happiness while striving to remain the world's greatest boss at Dunder Mifflin.

I'll leave it at those four for now, as I've gotta get to the review

In this episode "The Return," Dwight has left Dunder Mifflin (more on that in the previous episode) and is now working at a Staples store, while the rest of the office now has to put up with Andy's annoying antics. Through various changes in the mood and organization of the workplace (surplus of clients, wilted plants, disorganized desk toys), everyone suddenly realizes how much Dwight meant to Dunder Mifflin. It's also bad timing, as Oscar has just returned to the office after a "gay-cation" that lasted half the season. Andy, reveling in Dwight's absence, continues trying to suck up to Michael and manages to annoy everyone around him, and creeping out Michael himself. He also may or may not realize how much this reflects his own antics in previous seasons ("I don't understand how someone could have so little self-awareness"). In the end, Michael realizes his mistake, and brings Dwight back to a grateful Dunder Mifflin. As for Andy, he gets his comeuppance after a prank by Jim and Pam (back at it again (yes!)) which then leads to a rejection by Michael that leaves us thankful and then in stitches, as this is followed by a crazed wall punch by Andy Bernard himself (exposed!). There's only one thing to say for all of this: Dwight Schrute FOREVER!

In this episode, almost all of the characters' narrative story arcs for season 3 reach a climax, and what a climax it is. 1. Jim is back to his prank-pulling self, and really still has feelings for Pam, once again his accomplice in his pranks when no one else will be (no surprise by Ryan, but a real blunder on Karen's part) 2. Pam remains perky and helpful as ever, even attempting to console Angela in a heartfelt exchange where she sort of admits her feelings for Dwight, bringing us to: 3. Angela shows her sentimental side 4. Dwight remains his Dwight Schrute self, even bringing his dedicated ways into his new workplace, where it's not accepted unfortunately for him. Still, as always, Dwight perseveres, and gives us a perfect description of himself in the process ("How would I describe myself? Three words: Hardworking, alpha-male, jackhammer... merciless... insatiable..."). 5. And last but not least, Michael Scott himself. While his relationship with Dwight was certainly not his cup of tea, Michael realizes what Dwight means to the company, his surroundings, and him, even preferring him over Andy. When he brings Dwight back, not only does he admit he made a mistake and fixes it ("It takes a big man to admit his mistake. And I am that big man"), but he also takes a big step in the right direction for his fellow peers and all who view him as Michael Scott: The World's Greatest Boss.

For bringing us stunning narrative turning points for the characters as well as tons of hilarious memorable moments, I call "The Return" one of the show's shining achievements and up there among the all-time best episodes of The Office. Three cheers for Dunder Mifflin!
27 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Return (#3.13)
ComedyFan20102 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Oscar comes back and gets a welcome party. Michael realizes that he made a mistake firing Dwight.

Great episode. Andy annoying Michael was hilarious considering that Michael often does it to others but even for him Andy was too much. The whole talking of his about butt kissing was wonderful and I loved the moment between him and Dwight.

Dwight also was great as a Staples salesman who still loves Dunder Mifflin. His comeback makes not only Jim but also all the viewers happy.

Angela was also great this episode, so not what we are used to. So one can see what she feels for Dwight and she apparently was worried Michael finds out her and Dwight date. Their handshake at the end was sweet!

Pam and Jim's prank on Andy was also good and ended up with a bid surprise. I actually like Andy as a character. Him being so annoying and representing a butt kisser really adds fun to the show. And while I feel bad for Karen I am glad Jim has feelings for Pam. We all know they belong together!
23 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An outrageously funny build up to an iconic moment
discgolf-7333420 October 2021
The Return is on of my favorite episodes of the entire show. Ed Helms is perfect as Andy and as annoying as he is, it's one of the funniest episodes!

Then comes the wall punch, a jaw dropping moment of the show that is always hilarious.
14 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Man I hate Andy
themightykazoo-3076320 December 2019
Can't stand Andy. Glad that he was gone for a while after this episode
39 out of 102 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good to see Michael as the normal person
hannanah-0334626 December 2022
This is actually one of my favorite episodes of the series, I had hard time going through the series in the beginning solely because of michael. He is the worst and unbearable. The mostly annoying kind of coworkers and to make matters worse he is the boss. Stubborn man child with the power he should never possessed.

But then we meet andy, at first I thought he's suppose to be another dwight but then they move to scranton.. andy immediately turn into an upgraded and worse version of michael. Because so far michael has only being stupid without ill intention. And I really like this light on michael, he gets to taste his own medicine. Andy really gets under his skin with all his shenanigans towards him.

We could actually see Michael being the quite one hahahaha I really like that for once he is the one try to contain him self from someone crossing the line and act silly.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Andy Is Annoying, Dwight Works At Staples
vivianla15 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Dwight goes for interviews but he gives three different documents to each hiring manager.

He ends up taking a job with Staples saying it is temporary.

Andy annoys the whole office including Michael himself.

Oscar comes back and they throw a party for him. Angela goes into Michael's office and admits Dwight went to corporate that morning for her because she did not hand in something on time. It is snowing outside.

During the party Michael encourages Pam to shake her breasts as he shakes maracas in front of his chest. Pam refuses but Phyllis shakes her chest. Michael slowly leaves, repulsed.

Michael gets angry realizing Andy was kissing his butt after Jim mentions Andy copies his boss casually. Michael drives to Staples to get Dwight back. Andy has been sent to an anger management program after Michael had a chat with corporate. Andy tells us he does personality mirroring and we see him imitate the woman.
6 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
9
Edvis-199728 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Well, that's not really suprise, we all knoew she will tell him true and Dwight will come back to his old job. It's just Andy for me... How he's more annoying than Dwight, unbelievable.
3 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of my favorite episodes from season 3
leemarksberry4 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
In this episode Oscar Martinez returns after Michael Scott kissing him in the first episode of season 3

In the previous episode Andy tells Michael about Dwight going to new York to bring in something that Angela forgot to do

When Oscar returns Angela invites him to the party planning committee

Michael Scott wants them to have a Mexican themed party for Oscar

Meanwhile Jim is going to play a prank on Andy, Pam helps Jim with the prank on Andy

Jim throws Andy's phone in the celling

I also like the part with Michael not liking Andy in the episode during one point Andy is walking around look for Michael and he doesn't find him but Michael is hiding behind his door

My number one favorite moment is when Andy punches a hole in the wall.
0 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not bad. Pretty much my feeling on the whole of season 3.
sales-61523 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
VERY SLIGHT SPOILER

This episode in part follows the exploits of Dwayne in his endevours outside of Dunder Mifflin along with the return of Oscar, hence the episode title.

Not a bad episode but not particularly good either when you look back at a very strong season 2. They embarked on territory that the English version hadn't when they decided on a longer season 2 and now season 3 and to be fair they have done pretty well. They are always standing slightly in the shadow (as every UK poster will tell you along with burning an efigy of Micheal Scott) and have gone further in the development of the series.

I enjoy this series but I do hope that they wrap it up after this one.
10 out of 81 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed