Steel Magnolias (1990 TV Movie) User Reviews

Was not a bad show

[cajunboi · 8/10 · 14 October 2007]

I remember seeing this episode when it aired and though it conflicted a little from the movie, it was good.

One of the main things I remember was that M'Lynn and Jackson were kind of in a custody battle over the little boy.

I was surprised that Cindy Williams did such a good job, picking up where Sally Field left off. With big shoes to fill, Elaine Strict was a great Weeza and Polly Bergen did a good job as Claree.

The character of Anelle seemed to be back to the way she was at the beginning of the movie, with very little character development. Sally Kirkland seemed a little too harsh as Truvy. Throughout the episode, I never began to care for her.

It is a shame this show was not given an opportunity to develop and grow.

Nice attempt to continue the story, but ultimately pointless.

[mark.waltz · 5/10 · 6 February 2018]

With the original Off Broadway play a huge hit, a revival that sold out in spite of mixed reviews, a smash hit movie and a TV remake, "Steel Magnolias" has gotten so much attention I'm surprised that it wasn't musicalized. The attempt to make a TV series out of it (which probably would have been an hour long drama rather than a half hour sitcom) was nice and almost perfectly cast, but something in watching it again after almost 30 years since it aired makes me think it would have only lasted a short while.

It is a year since the death of Shelby, and the widowed Jackson (Tim Grimm) has started to date again, much to the concern of Shelby's mother, M'Lynn (Cindy Williams) and her big hearted but gossipy pals. They all still hang out at Truvy's (Sally Kirkland) and badmouth the briefly spotted Janice Van Meeter, and now they all express concern that Jackson's new girlfriend Elise (Dana Reeve) will be no replacement for Shelby should the relationship continue to grow. M'Lynn confronts her son-in-law, gets to meet Elise, and in a nice touch, opens her eyes to the fact that, like Sally Field's M'Lynn said in the movie, "Life goes on."

It's the ensemble that stands out, although I have my doubts that Sally Kirkland was the right choice for the big-hearted Truvy. Even with her declaration that nobody cries alone in her presence, I never quite believed those words coming out of her mouth like I did with Dolly Parton. Sheila McCarthy gets a few good lines in as the still quiet and religious Anelle, but the best dialog of course goes to the TV Ouiser and Clairee, played by two "Follies" Broadway babies, Elaine Stritch and Polly Bergen. Their friendly banter is both cantankerous and big-hearted, and I couldn't think of better casting for those parts. The chance to see this ensemble working together was a nice dream, but like many TV pilots, it got lost in the shuffle, and somebody wisely decided that the risk wasn't worth the taking, although a full TV movie with this cast of a follow-up story might have been a better idea than the half hour brief slice of Southern life we get here.

It was okay

[gleekout29 · 4/10 · 13 March 2018]

Watched it tonight on YouTube it wasn't awful but it wasn't great. Great cast. Annelle seemed to be more ditzy than she was in the film kinda reminded me of Charlene from Designing Women. M'Lynn seemed a little weak. Truvy was to harsh. Clairee and Ouisa was okay. Drum seemed too young, Jackson actually was a good fit.

Good cast

[MrDeWinter · 10/10 · 8 October 2021]

Not bad. Who knows why it didn't sell. Good cast and everyone seemed to lover their parts.