Victor (TV Movie 2008) Poster

(2008 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Passionate Athlete
bkoganbing15 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Victor tells the life story and tragic death of Victor Davis, Canadian swimming champion who set all kinds of records in the breaststroke and also fought a lot of health issues in his career as a swimmer. Those health issues also included mental health issues because he had one ungovernable temper that got the better of him.

Mark Lutz who is also something of an athlete as well as an actor has that dual persona serve him well in portraying Davis. Davis sustained so many setbacks physically, mononucleosis, spina bifida, an enlarged spleen the wonder was that he was able to have a career at all.

Davis also could not control himself when things went wrong. A highly specious decision about disqualifying the Canadian relay team in 1982 sent him on a rampage. What probably would be a highlight reel like George Brett coming out of the dugout to rearrange Billy Martin's skull after the pine tar incident doesn't go over in amateur sports especially when Queen Elizabeth is in attendance. She was after Queen of Canada too. There's a different mindset in Canada about these incidents except on the professional hockey rink. That's where Canadian fans can get into it as rough as the players. But swimming is an amateur sport and there are different rules to play by.

The tragic death of Davis got to me because years ago in my working life at New York State Crime Victims Board I did a case where someone was run down in a car as Davis was. To say that justice was not done in the Davis situation would be outrageously understated. My victim survived it, but could easily have died as Victor Davis did. His perpetrator got a slap on the wrist, considerably less than the four months of jail time that Victor Davis's killer got. The whole thing doesn't speak highly of the Montreal PD.

Standing out in the supporting cast are Polly Shannon as Victor's girl friend and Peter MacNeill as his father. Victor is a nice tribute to a genuine Canadian hero and sports legend.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Poorly Written and Acted Movie
rhp9612 November 2014
The biggest problem I had with this movie when it aired, and that I still think of years later, is that it was so poorly cast. Victor Davis was 25 when he died--and in his 20s in the context of the movie--while Mark Lutz was in his late 30s when the movie was shot. Ms. Clavel was younger than Victor Davis, much younger than Ms. Shannon who portrayed her in the film.

I knew Victor Davis. I swam in the same pool, in the same training group, with the same coach; I spent time with him away from the pool in many circumstances. I did not see anything that resembled the man I knew in Mark Lutz's portrayal. As a friend of his, I found the portrayal of the generic friend "Dave Kolisnik" rather lame. A composite of more than one person Davis was friends with at the time of his death, he fits with the sappy story Lutz wrote, but not with the real story. Moreover, since this story uses real names for almost everyone, why was "Dave Kolisnik" invented? I was also disappointed with the portrayal of journalist Dave Stubbs in this film. I've met Mr. Stubbs a few times over the years and never in him have I seen the lackey that he was portrayed as in the movie.

It is understandable that a movie like this will change some things, or skip details, but as someone who knew Victor Davis in the years portrayed in the story, it just came across as weak writing and acting.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Back and Forwards
RedPlum5 August 2018
Movie goes forward and backward the whole time, stupid to follow. Lot of the stuff is continuously repeated.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent movie
jakethedouglas25 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I would strongly recommend this movie to everyone. It is truly really well written and acted, and serves as an inspiring and compelling tribute to the legacy of Victor Davis. Mark Lutz undoubtedly does an excellent job of playing the role of Victor, and I was captivated throughout the entire duration of the film. I especially appreciated the use of symbolism to portray Victor fighting through his coma by depicting him drowning in the swimming pool. This movie was truly an emotional roller coaster, and watching it made me feel as though I was in the very shoes of Victor himself. This movie wasn't just some film, it was an experience. I hope anyone who watches it can enjoy and appreciate it the same way I have. This film was a masterpiece, and is extremely underrated. Don't base your decision to watch this film on those critical reviews, as I feel like they don't truly represent what this movie is. Not many people have seen it, and this film has not had the same chance to be viewed and appreciated, as compared to other films.

If you get the chance to watch this, I can't possibly recommend it more.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed