Saw Rebirth (2005) User Reviews

The best thing that has been ever done in the "Saw" franchise

[Rectangular_businessman · 7/10 · 27 August 2012]

Okay, I have to admit that at first, I was reluctant to see this, mostly because I don't like very much the Saw franchise (I didn't like that much the first movie, and I hated the only two sequels that I watched) However, since I'm interested in motion-comics, I decided to give this a try.

Personally, I think that this short motion-comic was the best thing produced by the "Saw" franchise. Without having the same level of other motion-comics (Such as "Broken Saints") the result is way more interesting than the actual movies, with a convincing story, giving a much fascinating hindsight to the Maine antagonist of this saga, particularly his motivations and psychology at the very beginning of the history.

The art is fairly well done, the effects used to give a cinematic feeling to this comic were effective and the narration was good (Well, the voice was a bit cheesy at moments, but the overall result was still pretty decent) And the best part of it, is that this motion comic is able to be more suspenseful and interesting than all the Saw movies, being able to reach such achievement in a very short time, without having to use any of the annoying plot twists that sadly became a common characteristic of the "Saw" franchise.

We need more saw comic books

[kamora-39603 · 5/10 · 9 February 2021]

The art is fairly well done, the effects used to give a cinematic feeling to this comic were effective and the narration was good (Well, the voice was a bit cheesy at moments, but the overall result was still pretty decent) And the best part of it, is that this motion comic is able to be more suspenseful and interesting than all the Saw movies, being able to reach such achievement in a very short time, without having to use any of the annoying plot twists that sadly became a common characteristic of the "Saw" franchise.

"Saw: Rebirth"- A mildly engaging short that should intrigue franchise fans, even if it has been rendered non-canonical.

[TedStixonAKAMaximumMadness · 7/10 · 7 November 2017]

Few modern-day horror franchises have made as big a splash as "Saw"- the brainchild of Australian filmmakers James Wan and Leigh Whannell. Since first erupting onto the silver-screen in 2004, the series has grown and expanded almost constantly. Sequels... video-games... toys... clothing... You name it, "Saw" has done it. And around 2005, just in time for the release of "Saw II", a peculiar comic-book prequel was released entitled "Saw: Rebirth", which sought to explain the backstory of the infamous villain of the series. John Kramer, the man also known as "Jigsaw."

The comic was a fascinating one-off story that actually was fairly well drawn and written, with an interesting take on the character. And it was eventually recreated in the form of this animated film, with voice-overs and effects added in to create a more dynamic piece. And on the whole... yeah, it's actually pretty engaging and should serve as an adequate watch for longtime series fans. Though the fact it has subsequently been rendered non-canonical due to ret-cons and re- writes might put off the most hardcore of franchise fanatics.

George Williams supplies the role of John Kramer, here portrayed as an unambitious factory worker whose fear of commitment eventually drives away his significant other. Now alone and stuck in a dead- end rut, John is shaken to the core when he is given the news he is suffering from terminal cancer, and has very little time left. This plants the seeds for his titular rebirth, as we see him slowly transform into the man who will come to be known as the "Jigsaw Killer."

The short is definitely entertaining and manages to hold your attention. At about six minutes in length, it's a perfect bite- sized piece of "Saw" history, and it has a good sense of pacing and structure. It doesn't meander, nor does it rush, and it doles out information in a very deliberate fashion. The dialog and inner monologues are written true to the characters as portrayed in the films, and the artwork is very well-accomplished and detailed. Particular in how they capture and re-create the look of John's live-action actor Tobin Bell.

This unfortunately makes the short all the more frustrating in the places where it falls flat. While the writing and execution are generally well-done, the way the short is animated left something to be desired. It's just a bit too manic. It eschews typical motion- comic aesthetics and has the frames and dialog-boxes zooming, shooting and flying about in different configurations, which can distract from the story. I also felt the voice-acting got a bit hokey as the short entered its second half... it started to feel silly. And of course, there's the fact that the short has been rendered completely non-canonical, which also was the source of some mild irritation. While it fits nicely into the timeline as seen in the first three films, further developments added into the story in later movies completely contradict "Rebirth."

Still, for horror-fans and especially for "Saw" fanatics, it's worth checking out. The good artwork and sharp writing are a nice compliment to the series, and it's intriguing seeing how it fits into the overall history of the franchise. I'm giving "Saw: Rebirth" a pretty good 7 out of 10. If you have the chance to watch it, give it a shot.

Not a Fan of the Format

[baileycrawly · 3/10 · 26 December 2019]

This is more on me than on the story itself, but I really don't feel that this was an appropriate way to present the back story of the character. The only reason I watched this at all was because IMDb registered it as being a part of the "Saw" cannon and, in the interest of viewing the entire franchise, I deemed it only appropriate to check it out. It's got a back story of the character, sure, but it wasn't exactly engaging. In fact, it was downright dull. The character of the Jigsaw killer thrives on the unknown, and I think the filmmakers have slowly been peeling away layers of the character in each subsequent instalment in the series, always getting one step closer to revealing the real person behind the gimmicks, where he came from, and why he was really doing the things he was doing. Comic books bore me, and I always get disappointed when something in a good series is presented in that format, because I can't say I've experienced the entire story without having endured those other things. I will not be watching this again. I really don't see much of a reason for it to exist in the first place aside from making even more money off the already bankable franchise. Yawn.

Only for the biggest Saw fans

[Horst_In_Translation · 4/10 · 16 October 2015]

"Saw Rebirth" is a 6.5-minute short film that was made 10 years ago. It is fairly famous, at least for a short film, because of the reference to the famous horror movie franchise. It is basically a comic book put to the screen and the style is something you will either love or hate. I myself did not really like it and it even hurt the viewing experience in general and too away from the nice idea and decently written story. I have not see the "Saw" film except the okay short movie that preceded the series, but I would not say that this one here is really a must-see by any means. However, if you like the style or really love the series, you can give it a go. I'm not too surprised that Shuter and Viney who made this did not have a great career afterward in the last 10 years. Their work here is not memorable at all.

Deadly Games: The Rebirth

[Fernando-Rodrigues · 3/10 · 18 February 2021]

Not really that necessary, but interesting. I'm just not a fan of the format.

Cool movie short

[ariadem · 9/10 · 8 December 2019]

Why I gave it a 9 is probably because this story intervines and messes with original story SPOILER : how he left Jill and never talks to her again but in the movies they're much closer How in this he isn't making a legacy

But overall cool movie

Got to be one of the worst horror movie ever. Saw The final chapter is better and that was awful

[jacobjohntaylor1 · 1/10 · 11 July 2017]

This is a prequel to Saw. Saw the short film from 2003 was so much better then this. That was scary. This is not. This is self we know from seeing the Saw remake from 2004. That was better then this movie and that was awful. Saw II is a better movie and was awful. Saw III was a better movie and was awful. Saw IV is a better movie and that was awful. Saw V is a better movie and that was awful. Saw VI is a better movie and that was awful. Saw the final chapter is a better movie and that was awful. This movie has awful story. It is boring pointless. It just trying to give Saw II a promotion. I do not know why it got a 6.3. That is just overrating it. This is a 1. A Saw prequel was the most pointless movie ever.