"Doctor Who" The Curse of Peladon: Episode Two (TV Episode 1972) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Great story, great episode.
poolandrews25 March 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: The Curse of Peladon: Episode Two starts as the Doctor (Jon Pertwee) & the Galactic Federation delegates Alpha Centauri (Stuart Fell), Arcturus (Murray Grumbar) & Izlyr (Alan Bennion) narrowly avoid being crushed & killed by the falling large granite statue of Aggedor. High Priest Hepesh (Geoffrey Toone) says that it is part of the ancient 'curse of Peladon' while the Doctor feels deliberate sabotage is a more likely cause. With the committee in disarray the servo junction unit from Arcturus life support systems is removed & taken, the Doctor manages to bypass the circuits & save him but is implicated as a traitor. With his plan failing Hepesh orders the King's champion fighter Grun (Gordon St. Clair) to kill the Doctor whom Hepesh sees as the biggest threat to his plans...

Episode 6 from season 9 this Doctor Who adventure originally aired here in the UK during February 1972, directed by Lennie Mayne I am really enjoying The Curse of Peladon so far. It's nice to see the third Doctor Jon Pertwee away from contemporary Earth if nothing else. The script by Brian Hayles is obviously a allegory to Britain entering the European Community & as such sets out to have two distinct sets of character's with opposing views. There is King Peladon who is for joining the Galactic Federation for the benefit of his people while High Priest Hepesh who is against it & is using underhand tactics to get his own way. This is one aspect of The Curse of Peladon which could have worked better, the fact that it's Hepesh who is the traitor & behind all the violence has come a bit too early & the makers could have prolonged the mystery elements a bit & kept the viewer guessing as to who they can trust. With only Jo as the one human being in the cast of character's it's nice to see that Hayles has given all the alien creatures & races their own distinct personalities from the shy & timid Alpha Centauri to the agitated Arcturus with the Doctor as the middle man trying to keep the peace. The character of Jo is also given more to do than has been the case in past stories with the romantic subplot involving her & King Peladon along with her efforts to try & help find the saboteur.

With the six part action packed story The Sea Devils (1972) expected to be very costly the production team had to make an entirely studio bound serial & The Curse of Peladon is it, in fact The Curse of Peladon is the first Jon Pertwee story not to feature any 16mm film outside location shooting although the model work & the fight at the end of Episode Three between the Doctor & Grun shot at Ealing studios was captured on film. The sets are very good actually & were obviously inspired by ancient Rome with stone statues, huge concrete pillars, corridors lit by flaming torches & the leather strap style clothing of the local inhabitants. It's an effect that works very well especially as director Mayne keeps a lot of things darkly lit with only the light from the flaming torches to illuminate scenes & as a consequence there's lots of atmospheric shadows as well. Is it just me or has Jo's hair which started off curly in the TARDIS magically straightened out? Episode Two also sees our first proper look at the monster Aggedor, well it's not as bad as some Doctor Who monsters but it does look like a guy in a bad monster suit. Luckily Mayne hides it in the shadows & only show's glimpses of it.

The Curse of Peladon: Episode Two is another fine episode in a fine story, it's Doctor Who with a message. What more do you want?
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
High drama and Politics.
Sleepin_Dragon17 March 2020
The Doctor has had previous dealings with The Ice Warriors, and is convinced that they are to blame for a near accident, and for an attempt on the life of Arcturus.

First of all, we've had many criticisms of the show now being too political, I chuckled as I watched this one, a small isolated planet is about to join The Federation, just as The UK is about to join The EEC, EU.

Former enemies are now friends, The Ice Warriors who had previously been warriors, are now brokers of peace. I like all of the mythology surrounding Agador.

It's a strong performance from Katy Manning, one of Jo's best stories.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
EU in or out?
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic29 September 2014
Review of all 4 episodes:

The Doctor and Jo have a rare adventure away from contemporary Earth as The Doctor manages to take the TARDIS on a 'test flight' and they end up on the planet Peladon. The Doctor is mistaken to be the Earth delegate of a committee from the Galactic Federation and is made chairman of the committee. Jo is believed to be an Earth princess. The task for this committee is to assess Peladon's application to join the Galactic Federation. This is all an allegory for the UK's accession to the European Common Market (which became the EU) which was a big issue at the time.

A legend of a monster and strange incidents begin to threaten proceedings and there is a mystery surrounding who or what is behind the apparent attempts to stop Peladon from joining the Federation. The other committee members provide varying, interesting alien species. The efforts to create these unusual aliens is to be admired and it is surely the clear inspiration for a very similar scenario in the second episode after Doctor Who returned in 2005 'The End of the World'.

One of the alien delegates, Alpha Centauri, may seem slightly annoying and somewhat lacking in credibility to a modern viewer but the effort to make it a very different life form (as they tried valiantly but unsuccessfully in 'The Web Planet') is highly commendable. The other aliens are interesting and well realised with the Ice Warriors providing a nice twist on previous stories where they featured.

The script from Brian Hayles is very well written and intelligent with nice political undertones. There is plenty of fun and action and some very good performances, particularly from previous Doctor Patrick Troughton's son David as King Peladon who is excellent.

Jon Pertwee is superb as the Doctor and Katy Manning is very strong in this story as Jo. Ice Warrior delegate Izlyr is very well performed by Alan Bennion.

It is not perfect with the hypnotism and its effects being my least favourite aspect but it is all highly entertaining and intelligently written with plenty of fine acting.

My ratings: Episodes 1 & 2 - 9/10, Episodes 3 & 4 - 8.5/10, Overall 8.75/10
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed